Cutler Real Estate | New Albany

272 East Main Street, New Albany, OH 43054
  •   5   (526 reviews)

Our sales performance at a glance

See how Cutler Real Estate | New Albany has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

86
Reviews
68
Properties for sale
202
Sold properties
$476k
Average sale price
$96.2m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

Meet the team

Get to know the 31 agents at Cutler Real Estate | New Albany.

About Tiffany
Meet Tiffany Bafford, a dynamic real estate agent with a proven track record of success in Ohio, specializing in the Central Ohio area (especially Granville, New Albany, Alexandria, Newark, Heath, Gahanna, Westerville, Pickerington). With 43 glowing reviews and an impressive average rating of 5.0 out of 5, Tiffany is applauded for delivering exceptional customer experiences. Tiffany's real estate expertise is unmatched, boasting 30 successful property sales over the past year, with an impressive average selling price of over $400,000. Her properties spend an average of just six days on the market, showcasing her efficiency and expertise in securing swift and satisfactory deals for her clients. Currently managing five active property listings, Tiffany is particularly proficient in handling a variety of property types, providing specialized insights into single-family homes and condos. Her strategies are tailored to meet the individual needs of every client, ensuring top-tier service and satisfaction in buying or selling. With over $11 million in overall sales this past year, Tiffany is committed to excellence and integrity in every transaction. Her deep understanding of the local real estate market in Ohio and dedication to client satisfaction makes her the ideal partner for those looking to navigate the complex world of real estate with confidence. Whether you’re buying your first home or looking to sell, Tiffany Bafford is the trusted name in Ohio real estate, ready to guide you every step of the way.
View ProfileRateMyAgent AchievementspriceExpertbadgeaotybadge
About Linda
Cutler Real Estate asked Linda a few questions so you can get to know her better, and here are Linda's replies. 1. What is your professional/educational background? Bachelor of Science, Dual, Marketing and Administrative Management Worked in Sales and Sales Management National Sales Manager in Academic Publishing Previously a small business owner 2. Why did you choose a career in real estate? Love the housing industry and market. Enjoy the "science" of combining an emotional decision with statistical evidence to support pricing. 3. What area do you live in currently and what do you like about where you live? I've lived in most areas of Central Ohio but currently live in Blacklick, Ohio. I enjoy the rural feel but being close to all the city has to offer. 4. How do you spend your free time? Most of my free time is spent with my children and their activities. 5. If you could only keep 3 possessions what would they be? Photos Grand Piano Family Keepsakes 6. In one word, how do you think your friends/family would describe you? Efficient!
View ProfileRateMyAgent AchievementspriceExpertbadge
About Wendy
Cutler Real Estate asked Wendy a few questions so you can get to know her better, and here are Wendy's replies. 1. What is your professional/educational background? Marketing Major BGSU Worked for PGA Tour Country Club Management at Muirfield Village Golf Club, Country Club @ Muirfield Village South Carolina Yacht Club New Albany Country Club 2.What area do you live in currently and what do you like about where you live? New Albany, Ohio rated #1 Suburb in U.S. by Town and country magazine - cultural, health & business excellence 3. How do you spend your free time? Swim, Lake house at Lakeside/Marblehead 4. If you could only keep 4 possessions what would they be? Husband Dog Mom Engagement Ring 5. In one word, how do you think your friends/family would describe you? Compassionate/Loyal
View ProfileRateMyAgent AchievementspriceExpertbadge
About Leah & Lyss, I Care Home Group
Cutler Real Estate asked Leah a few questions so you can get to know her better, and here are Leah's replies. 1. What is your professional/educational background? Graduated from Marietta College with a Marketing Degree, minor in Music 20+ years in the title industry\ Hondros College 2. Why did you choose a career in real estate? Title was a perfect segue into being a realtor. My title knowledge has been invaluable. 3. What area do you live in currently and what do you like about where you live? Currently Westerville, moved several times but have always lived north. 4. How do you spend your free time? I enjoy time with my family: golfing, boating, snow skiing 5. If you could only keep 5 possessions what would they be? A special necklace my Dad gave me Wedding ring and special rings from my Mom My phone to stay in touch with family and to look through all my pictures My select comfort bed My Engish Mastiff, named Greeley 6. In one word, how do you think your friends/family would describe you? Caring
View ProfileRateMyAgent AchievementspriceExpertbadge
About Barb
Cutler Real Estate asked Barbara a few questions so you can get to know her better, and here are Barbara's replies. 1. What is your professional/educational background? Graduated from Texas State University, San Marcos Texas. Bachelor's in Fashion Merchandising/Business Administration. Have been in retail for my entire career life. I have been at Lbrands for 30 years. Many different roles - Executive Assistant/Project Management, Human Resources, Store Management. 2. Why did you choose a career in real estate? I have always had an interest in Real Estate but never felt the timing was right until now. 3. What area do you live in currently and what do you like about where you live? I live in Gahanna. It has been great raising a family in the Gahanna area. All of our children enjoyed growing up in Gahanna and did very well in the school system and the community. Gahanna is a great location with convenient access to the airport, Easton, downtown, etc. 4. How do you spend your free time? Going out to dinner with my husband and close friends, spending time with my 2 sisters that live in Columbus. I like to garden, enjoy working out. My husband and I enjoy going to Farm Markets, Art Shows, Broadway productions, and we love to travel. 5. If you could only keep 5 possessions what would they be? Pictures of my Family Wedding ring Personal items my deceased Mom gave me & 5. My dogs 6. In one word, how do you think your friends/family would describe you? Friends - Compassionate; Family - Loving
View ProfileRateMyAgent AchievementspriceExpertbadgeaotybadge
About Tima
Cutler Real Estate asked Tima a few questions so you can get to know her better, and here are Tima's replies. 1. What is your professional/educational background? Graduate of OSU - Bachelors of Science degree 2. Why did you choose a career in real estate? Helping others 3. What area do you live in currently and what do you like about where you live? I live near Galena, Lewis Center, Polaris, and Westerville. I love the convenience 4. How do you spend your free time? What's free time? Ha...I love spending time with friends and family. 5. If you could only keep 5 possessions what would they be? Photos Family heirlooms iPhone Car Wallet 6. In one word, how do you think your friends/family would describe you? FUN
View ProfileRateMyAgent Achievementstop20badgepriceExpertbadge

About us

About Our New Albany Office Our New Albany office is a suburban office with a loft style, and a “chic” vibe. The office has high, exposed ceilings and modern fixtures. It was designed with an open concept that encourages conversation, collaboration, and agent networking. Many of our visitors and staff appreciate the relationship and partnership that we have created with Hayley Gallery, a local art gallery. Their artwork adorns our walls, and changes constantly as they continue to change their inventory. Because of our location and design, we encourage the REALTORS® in our office to sponsor gatherings and community events throughout the year. Our office has been utilized for everything from book clubs and seminars to a psychic fair! The agents in the New Albany office have garnered a reputation as being professional, thorough, friendly, and career minded. Our REALTORS® are very supportive, professional, ethical, and encourage one another to succeed! Although we have newly licensed agents, we are also loaded with experienced realtors that recognize the different technology platforms and training that we offer. This includes lead generation, Cloud CMA, contact management systems with “drip campaigns,” social media marketing, website design, and much more! Our REALTORS® not only join organizations through the Columbus REALTORS® Board, but also take an active role in community involvement. Although we are located in New Albany, and are members of the Chamber locally, many of our agents live in the surrounding communities and take an active role in their personal communities as well.

Our reviews

  5  
523 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 6.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, well-prepared, reliable, proactive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Great execution start to finish!
7 days ago
Great execution start to finish!

Cathy is very detailed and extremely responsive and proactive. We were never left wondering what was going on. She kept us up to date at all stages of the process. She was familiar with the area, the community and what it would take to sell, both the pros and cons. She also took care of a few issues that needed to be done prior to listing and after. It was a very quick process.

Cathy Fleischmann

Cathy Fleischmann

  4.9   (16 reviews)
Buyer review
Highly recommend
8 days ago
Highly recommend

An absolutely wonderful duo that makes the extremely difficult process of purchasing a home seem effortless. Their expertise and insight were invaluable to the negotiations, which ended up being a very favorable and fair outcome for both sides. Highly, highly recommend, especially for first-time buyers.

Cutler Real Estate | I Care Home Group

Cutler Real Estate | I Care Home Group

  5   (4 reviews)
Seller review
Erin is motivated!
9 days ago
Erin is motivated!

Erin will sell you on selling your house and/or buying the house. She is good at helping you see the larger picture and not get hung up on any one detail.

Erin Spalding

Erin Spalding

  5   (21 reviews)
Buyer review
Amazing, exerienced realator!
9 days ago
Amazing, exerienced realator!

Linda was extremely responsive, understood what we were looking for, our financial restrictions, and helped us find a house that made everyone in my family happy. Loved working with her and I will miss her now that our house finding journey is over.

Linda Wasil

Linda Wasil

  5   (72 reviews)
Seller review
Great realtor to work with!
13 days ago
Great realtor to work with!

We are returning clients :) Jerri helped us buy our first home. Then when it was time to sell it, we picked her again. She was super responsive, friendly, and helpful!

Jerri Furniss

Jerri Furniss

  5   (21 reviews)
Buyer review
Always looking into best option based on our family needs.
14 days ago
Always looking into best option based on our family needs.

Tiffany was very supportive and always looking into the best house that fit better our family needs. She was also very flexible on accommodating showings based on our calendar availability. Overall, a very good experience.

Cutler Real Estate | One Team Columbus

Cutler Real Estate | One Team Columbus

  5   (157 reviews)
Show all 523 reviews
map

Our properties

Cutler Real Estate | New Albany has 68 properties for sale and sold 202 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldMay 27, 2026
$664,990
1225 Ivy Wood Drive
Sunbury OH 43074
4
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of HMS Real Estate and Cutler Real Estate | New Albany
SoldMay 26, 2026
$369,000
172 Barry Knoll Drive
Pataskala OH 43062
4
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Cutler Real Estate | New Albany
For Sale
$474,900
9472 Haaf Farm Drive Northwest
Pickerington OH 43147
3
3
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Cutler Real Estate | New Albany
SoldMay 22, 2026
$725,000
5405 East North Shore Landing Drive
Buckeye Lake OH 43008
2
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Capital Partners and Cutler Real Estate | New Albany
Show all 270 properties
Cutler Real Estate | New Albany
Contact Cutler Real Estate | New Albany
What information would you like?

Browse nearby locations

© 2026 RateMyAgent