From 107 reviews overall

Denise McGuire
West USA Realty

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Coconino County
4089 Morning View Dr Coconino County
Denise was always quick to respond to all of our questions. Her knowledge of the market situation is excellent and deep. The whole process of selling our property was easygoing. There were never any unanswered questions. We can highly recommend Denise.
State Top 10
ratemyagent award
Arizona2026County Winner
ratemyagent award
Coconino County2026National Top 100
ratemyagent award
United States2026Region Top 20
ratemyagent award
Southwest Region2026County Winner
ratemyagent award
Gila County2026County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Navajo County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Happy Jack2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Payson2026From 86 reviews overall

Nancy Shelton
Realty ONE Group Mountain Desert

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Coconino County
4830 East Crestview Street Flagstaff
Nancy was simply amazing! We live in Phoenix and were looking for a second home up north. I asked ChatGPT who the best realtor in Northern Arizona was, and Nancy came up at the top — and she absolutely lived up to that reputation and more! From the start, she went above and beyond to help us learn the ins and outs of every part of Northern Arizona so we could find the perfect fit and neighborhood for our family. Her knowledge of the area is unmatched — everything from wind patterns to snow levels, and even septic versus sewer systems — she was a wealth of information! Nancy’s patience and calm guidance through situations beyond our control kept us grounded and confident throughout the process. She didn’t just help us buy a house; she helped us find our dream home. By the end, she truly felt like family. We couldn’t imagine doing it with anyone else!
570 East Crestline Road Munds Park
We met with multiple brokers before deciding to hire Nancy. It was clear that she had done her due diligence before meeting with us. Her comp analysis was clear and concise and supported her initial pricing. We had many showings and a couple of lowball offers early in the process. She was always prepared to outline the current state of the market with updates and explanations of outliers. One of our issues was the prospects not being able to visualize the size of the parcel. Her creativity was evidenced with the idea to put a marker on the property that could be pointed out during showings. A couple of months in, we met and decided to reduce the price to attract a broader market. Again, she supported her recommendations with market research. Shortly thereafter we received an offer and she guided us through the counter offer process. It was clear during the sale process that Nancy had a strong reputation and relationship with the local brokerage community. We could not have been more pleased with the overall experience and results of our relationship with Nancy.
County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Coconino County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Munds Park2026From 48 reviews overall

Kelly Broaddus
eXp Realty

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Coconino County
419 Kiowa Mountainaire
This is the second time we have used Kelly and we can’t praise her enough for her kindness, professional staff, great communication and getting us through a tough situation. This woman is a force to be reckoned with - one who gets the job done! The first time we bought a property with Kelly's help and it was an easy process. This time we sold one that was challenging. Kelly guided us through the process with confidence. We appreciated how quickly she would respond back to questions we had and her unwavering support! She got the property sold quicker than we expected and we are beyond happy with the outcome of the sale! We have no hesitations recommending her to others!
5155 Bobcat Ln Flagstaff
Kelly Broaddus is a straight shooter who delivers every step of the way. She and her team always get questions answered fast and keep every detail tight, organized, and up to date. Working with her feels effortless because she truly knows how to get things done.
County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Coconino County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Flagstaff2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Fort Valley2026From 25 reviews overall
Lorraine De La Cruz
Realty ONE Group Mountain Desert

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Coconino County
935 East Raintree Road Munds Park
She knows how to prepare a property to show at its best!! She is always available to answer questions and goes that “ extra mile” to help. Because she lives in the area, she is an expert at helping the buyers. Over all I am so impressed with how resourceful and practical she is in negotiating with both buyers and sellers. We never felt pressured in any way and were always given the information we needed to make decisions. We have sold homes in the past and this was by far the best experience we have had selling a home.
945 East Munds Canyon Road Munds Park
Lorraine listed a cabin for us in Munds Park. She walked us through every step starting with preparation and staging to market research and the contractual processes. Lorraine coached us on how to make our home look its best, how to weigh the offers from different buyers, and preparing responses to all of the contractual questions along the way. Without Lorraine’s expertise, we would not have had such a smooth transaction. Plus, her negotiation skills ensured we received the best price!
County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Coconino County2026