From 188 reviews overall
Tara Rutkowski
Realty ONE Group | Goodyear

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Maricopa County
17563 West Fairview Street Goodyear
Tara is a great communicator and kept us apprised about the details of our listing, changes suggested or made, and finally frequent updates about the sale and closing of our home. We felt Tara was working solely on our behalf and went above and beyond to insure a successful closing on our property.
17082 South 182nd Avenue Goodyear
We cannot say enough wonderful things about Tara! She represented us in selling our home in what was truly a challenging market, and she handled everything with professionalism, patience, and dedication. From the very beginning, she made the process feel manageable and kept us informed every step of the way. Her knowledge of the market and her genuine care for us as clients gave us so much confidence during what could have been a very stressful time. Thanks to Tara and her team, we were able to successfully sell our home and move forward with excitement into our next chapter. If you are looking for someone you can truly trust to go to bat for you, especially when the market is tough, we wholeheartedly recommend Tara!
16685 S 181st Dr Goodyear
Tara's experience and familiarity with CantaMia certainly played to our advantage throughout the process. We found her to always be prompt and courteous in her response whenever we had a question or concern and never did we feel she wasnt 100% invested in ensuring our interests were being addressed. An extremely knowledgeable and competent executive who exudes integrity and is a tremendous asset to the Real Estate profession.
State Winner
ratemyagent award
Arizona2026County Winner
ratemyagent award
Maricopa County2026National Top 100
ratemyagent award
United States2026Region Top 20
ratemyagent award
Southwest Region2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Goodyear2026From 87 reviews overall

Randy Courtney
Weichert, REALTORS® - Courtney Valleywide

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Maricopa County
17/2221 West Farmdale Avenue Mesa
Randy did a fantastic job of listing my home, and brought me a full-price offer in eight days. He was proactive during the listing process, and also while the home was being shown to various buyers. He worked diligently to sell my home in a difficult economy- not once, but twice. The first attempt to sell was September 2025, and the sale fell through just days before closing escrow in November, through no fault of Randy’s. He relisted my home in February 2026, and found a new buyer immediately. The fact that I was willing to list with Randy a second time after the first sale fell through is a testament to my confidence in his abilities. No transaction is going to be perfect, so here is where I think there could be improvement- when the other party wants an extension to closing escrow, I would suggest an uptick in communication as to the reason(s) why, and how it will affect the timeline. This would alleviate a lot of stress. My work with Randy began in September 2025 and ended in April 2026, all during a challenging market. I’m very grateful for his experience and expertise.
17590 West Bridger Street Surprise
Randy and his team are amazing professionals and we would highly recommend working with them! Randy and his team answer texts in a very timely manner, are quick to reach out and respond to anything we may need. The entire 1031 transaction was handled professionally, with every t crossed and i dotted exactly where it needed to be. Not only professional, but friendly is how I would describe Randy's team. Very helpful and a joy to work with . Highly recommend!!
4328 West Hopi Trail Phoenix
Selling my brother’s home was so much easier since we had Randy and his team by our side. It was a smooth process from start to finish; everything was extraordinary. Any time we had a question, big or small, Randy or his team would respond as quickly as possible. It made a huge difference to know that we were kept informed throughout the whole process. His decades of experience and market knowledge led to our house being sold quickly; from the guidance and advice they provided, it took less than two months. Randy and his team were responsive, professional, and truly went out of their way. That kind of service is hard to find nowadays and we are so appreciative for all their help.
State Top 10
ratemyagent award
Arizona2026County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Maricopa County2026National Top 100
ratemyagent award
United States2026Region Top 20
ratemyagent award
Southwest Region2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Phoenix2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Tempe2026From 242 reviews overall

Celeste Mcivor
eXp Realty, LLC (Referral Div - Arizona)

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Maricopa County
12630 West Eveningside Drive Sun City West
Being from Chicago/Boston, we TOTALLY lucked out when we met Celeste and Jeff and used their talents and services as our agents to buy our AZ home. Where to even start! They are amazing people. So kind, thoughtful and knowledgeable. Very detail orientated and highly communicative, answering any communications from us quickly while also keeping us proactively informed at every stage of the process. To say they go the extra mile would be an understatement. I cannot recommend them more highly. In a world where finding really good people is hard to do, Celeste and Jeff stand as reminders that straight up good, honest and thoughtful humans still exist. Thank you to you both and we look forward to our new friendship.
16643 West Yucatan Drive Surprise
The Mcivor team was absolutely amazing during a very high-stress period for us. From the moment we started, they kept in constant contact, providing the experienced perspective we desperately needed to meet our goal: selling our house quickly without sacrificing a competitive price. Celeste and her husband are the ultimate professionals. They knew exactly which strategic repairs and upgrades would offer the "best bang for our buck." Perhaps most impressively, they had a plethora of reliable contacts on speed dial who helped transform our home into beautiful, like-new, market-ready shape in record time! We feel incredibly blessed to have found Celeste. We were able to rely implicitly on her advice from the very beginning, and it paid off. If you want a realtor who is proactive, knowledgeable, and genuinely cares about your outcome, look no further than the Mcivor team. We couldn't have done it without them!
State Top 10
ratemyagent award
Arizona2026County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Maricopa County2026National Top 100
ratemyagent award
United States2026Region Top 20
ratemyagent award
Southwest Region2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Surprise2026From 163 reviews overall

Lacey Lehman and Drew Lehman
Team Lehman AZ

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Maricopa County
22749 East Poco Cll Queen Creek
Drew and Lacey Lehman were recommended to me and I am so happy that they were. I primarily worked with Drew who was amazing throughout the whole homebuying experience. What a wealth of knowledge he had about the area I ultimately bought my home in, to the home itself, and recommendations for a landscaper to a handyman. I even received a few restaurant recommendations. Drew listened to what I was looking for and what characteristics were most important to me. He made everything so easy and stress free. Drew truly looked out for my best interest. He negotiated for exactly what I needed and I was thrilled with the outcome. As a single woman, he really cared about the area I moved into to ensure my safety and even provided me with a certificate to have my locks re-keyed upon closing. The entire Lehman team was awesome and always available to answer questions. They provided updates without having to ask and always had a positive, can do attitude! I highly recommend you use the Lehman team for your next homebuying experience. You will be happy you did!!