Monroe County is home to 328 active real estate agents and 510 active real estate offices. There are 2 agents who are known for their trustworthiness, and 13 agents known for being pricing experts.
Over the past 12 months there have been 366 active and sold properties, with 37 reviews in total. This is a 34% decrease compared to the previous 12 months.
Sandy was wonderful to work with from beginning to end. She is warm, accommodating, genuine, and truly invested in finding the right fit for her clients. We worked with Sandy for quite some time and looked at several homes before ultimately finding the one we purchased. We never felt rushed or pressured—she genuinely wanted us to find the home that was right for us. Her attention to detail was exceptional. During the purchase and closing process, she took careful notes about the home and its various systems so we would have information to refer back to later. That extra effort was incredibly thoughtful and helpful. Sandy also made herself readily available throughout the entire process—and continued to be available even after closing. She is professional, attentive, gracious, and an absolute class act. We would highly recommend her.
Sandy is expert in her ability, diligent with communication and knowledgeable about the market and the area.
Thank goodness Sandy was there every step of the way when I decided to sell my Cudjoe key house that I bought in 2000. After owning the vacation home for 26 years I decided it was time to move on and someone else could enjoy it. I had never sold a house before so after interviewing two realtors I decided that Sandy was the one for me. She explained everything and got me the price I had in mind. It was so easy! Now I'm spoiled...
Krissy was outstanding at her real estate knowledge, worked around the clock to help us with any questions we had. Working with her made the purchase of our newly acquired unit very easy and seamless. Glad to have her as our realtor.
Sandy's expertise showed through the whole process making us confident throughout the buying process. She also has a great network which made getting inspections easy. She is simply the best!!
Sandy helped us find our home in The Keys. She is super knowledgeable of the area and super easy to work with. I was not in town for the closing and she went above and beyond to make the experience go smooth for me. I would highly recommend her.
Thank you Bonnie for really looking out for us. I was nervous about selling my home of 15 years but you made the experience smooth and (seemingly) effortless! You were always available when I called and I wouldn't hesitate to recommend you to others.
Working with Krissy to sell our home was truly special — not only because she’s an outstanding Realtor, but because she’s also a dear friend. From the very beginning, her communication and efforts were , clear, and reassuring, which meant so much to me throughout the entire process. Our sale was far from simple and became a very convoluted, but Krissy handled every challenge with professionalism, patience, and confidence. Her sales strategy, strong negotiation skills, and deep local knowledge made all the difference in getting us to a successful closing. She never missed a detail, always stayed one step ahead, and made sure we were informed every step of the way. We couldn’t be more grateful to have her— and we would wholeheartedly recommend Krissy to anyone looking for a truly dedicated, skilled, and caring real estate professional.
Sandra Tuttle did an excellent job of advertising my house through Home.com and other means available to the large public. Her descriptions of the house and location were right on and definitely geared to the correct potential buyers. She works hard and successfully sells! Thank you Sandy!
Working with Sandy was great, she made everything very easy. She is a Florida Keys expert, and I was in Michigan. You need someone you can trust when you are so far away, and Sandy made that very easy.
87% of sellers reported being happy with their sale price in the last 12 months.
Median sale prices for houses is up 6% YoY making it a great time to consult local agents about selling.
13 agents have earned the Price Expert badge - reflecting their ability to achieve a price that meets or exceeds their clients expectations.
Price and performance data by property type for Monroe County.
The median sale price for single-family properties in Monroe County is $1.18m, up 8% over the last 12 months. The number of single-family properties sold has decreased by 32% over the last 12 months.
Monroe County stands out for consistently delivering exceptional satisfaction and strong market results for homeowners.
This is based on voluntary sentiment collected from 22 reviews in Monroe County over the last 12 months.
Over the 12 months American Caribbean Real Estate have sold 51 properties, which accounts for 9% of the property sales in Monroe County. This is followed by Coldwell Banker Schmitt R.E. with 35 property sales (6%) and Coldwell Banker Schmitt RE Co at 33 property sales (6%).

Every verified review on RateMyAgent is linked to a specific property transaction, ensuring that the feedback comes from real buyers and sellers. This also allows you to view key property details - such as location and number of bedrooms - so you can find reviews relevant to your own real estate journey. With our verification process, you can trust that the experiences shared are real, reliable, and helpful.
Integrity is at the core of what we do. We conduct rigorous daily integrity checks on all reviews, using multi-stage verification to analyze submission data and behavioral patterns for potential anomalies. Suspicious reviews may be rejected outright or escalated for further scrutiny by our internal team.
Transparency and fairness are core to how RateMyAgent works. While it’s sometimes assumed that only positive reviews appear on our platform, that’s not the case.
Only clients involved in an actual transaction with an agent can leave a review. This helps ensure authenticity and prevents fake or anonymous feedback. Agent's have no control over what’s written - every review, whether positive or critical, is published and remains visible.
Through verified reviews and price satisfaction insights, we highlight top-performing agents who consistently exceed client expectations. All agents can request and collect reviews for free, and subscription status has no impact on rankings or award eligibility. Our Agent of the Year Awards and platform rankings are based solely on verified client feedback and performance. By celebrating excellence fairly and transparently, we help consumers find the best agents with confidence.
Agents who request 100% of vendor reviews, ensuring transparency and a commitment to client satisfaction.
Awarded to agents whose clients report 90% or more of sales meeting price expectations, showcasing expertise in pricing accuracy.
Recognising agents with a strong Review/Sales Ratio, demonstrating consistent performance.
The only awards based purely on verified client reviews, celebrating agents with the most positive feedback combined with sales performance in a specific location.
Discover what sets an agent apart with our AI-powered summary of their verified reviews, available on their profile page.