Sandra Tuttle

Sandra Tuttle

REALTOR® / Real Estate Agent at Island Welcome Real Estate
Real Estate Sales: SL3093204
  •   5   (74 reviews)

Sandra's sales performance at a glance

See how Sandra has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

11
Reviews
4
Properties for sale
16
Sold properties
$1.7m
Average sale price
$27.9m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

  • priceExpertbadge

    Consistently meets client expectations for property purchase price.

  • aotybadge

    Recognized for going above & beyond for their clients.

Sandra's customer service awards

See what RateMyAgent awards Sandra has won

  • County WinnerMonroe County
  • City WinnerBig Pine Key
  • City WinnerCudjoe Key
  • 4x County Top 5Monroe County - 2026, 2025, 2024, 2022
  • 2x County WinnerMonroe County - 2026, 2025

About Sandra

Sandy Tuttle is a consistently ranked top real estate professional in the Florida Keys and a leader in the luxury market. Sandy is a dedicated full time, local specialist, and has facilitated several record-breaking sales, proving that the knowledge, experience, and problem-solving mastery she’s cultivated from each deal are unmatched. Her award recognition is extensive, including at her previous company, where she ranked in the top .5% of all Berkshire Hathaway agents Nationwide. Sandy’s designations include Luxury Collection Specialist, Resort and Second-Home Property Specialist, e-PRO®, Green Designation, and At Home with Diversity® certifications. Her local prestige has also attracted the attention of HGTV, for which she offered her expertise on the popular shows House Hunters and Beachfront Bargain Hunt. Originally from New Jersey, Sandy spent her childhood summers at the Jersey Shore and vacationing in the Florida Keys. By 8 years old, she’d vowed to one day make the Keys her permanent home. With initial plans to pursue a career in animal husbandry, Sandy earned a college degree in animal behavior in Maryland, then moved to Thailand to complete a year teaching English. She set her sights high, completing a couple months of trekking the Himalayas in Nepal. Once back in the States, Sandy’s dream came true in 1998 when she and her husband became full-time Florida Keys residents as the live-aboard sailing crew of a 55-foot vessel based in Marathon. After a few years of cruising the Keys and the Bahamas, she earned her real estate license in 2004. Working as a Realtor® was Sandy’s path to securing her future in the Florida Keys because of her tenacity, hard-work ethic, and love of sharing the area’s incredible lifestyle with people joining the community. It didn’t hurt that her mother was a beloved top-producing New Jersey Realtor® from whom Sandy learned the importance of service, relationships, and prioritizing clients. In 2005, Sandy became a full-time agent, and she has subsequently outperformed every prior year by breaking records and expectations. She’s deeply grateful to engage with buyers and sellers and help them achieve their goals, and she respects them by keeping them at the center of each transaction and being a strong presence and communicator. Sandy also knows how to transform challenges into solutions, whether by her ingenuity or by accessing her solid community network for the perfect resource. Sandy is “living the dream” in Summerland Key with her husband, Kip, and mini Goldendoodles. A self-described “water girl,” Sandy has no trouble making the most of the Keys lifestyle. You can often find her diving, fishing, boating, spearfishing, lobstering, or doing just about anything aquatic. Sandy has also lent her time to many community causes, especially where animals are concerned. Dolphin Research Center, Reef Relief, the Wheelchair Foundation, the local Florida Keys SPCA animal shelter, and co-founding the Big Pine Bark Park are just a few examples of her supportive initiatives.

Social profiles

Sandra's reviews

  5  
Sandra has 74 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 6.
Review Sandra
Sandra's qualities as told by our client reviews: detail-oriented, well-connected, great negotiation, clear communication, responsive, reliable, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Excellent experience with Sandy and Island Welcome Real Estate
5 days ago
Excellent experience with Sandy and Island Welcome Real Estate

Selling my family’s home on Big Torch was an emotionally difficult decision, but Sandy and her team were sensitive, professional and supportive throughout the process. She is an extremely clear communicator and kept me updated every step of the way. Being out of state, I found her to be especially helpful in dealing with local contractors and getting all those last-minute things buttoned up before a deal can be finalized. I couldn’t have asked for a better agent, and I simply can’t recommend her highly enough!

Buyer review
A Class Act — Warm, Genuine and Truly Invested
about 1 month ago
A Class Act — Warm, Genuine and Truly Invested

Sandy was wonderful to work with from beginning to end. She is warm, accommodating, genuine, and truly invested in finding the right fit for her clients. We worked with Sandy for quite some time and looked at several homes before ultimately finding the one we purchased. We never felt rushed or pressured—she genuinely wanted us to find the home that was right for us. Her attention to detail was exceptional. During the purchase and closing process, she took careful notes about the home and its various systems so we would have information to refer back to later. That extra effort was incredibly thoughtful and helpful. Sandy also made herself readily available throughout the entire process—and continued to be available even after closing. She is professional, attentive, gracious, and an absolute class act. We would highly recommend her.

Seller review
Sandy was there every step of the way...
4 months ago
Sandy was there every step of the way...

Thank goodness Sandy was there every step of the way when I decided to sell my Cudjoe key house that I bought in 2000. After owning the vacation home for 26 years I decided it was time to move on and someone else could enjoy it. I had never sold a house before so after interviewing two realtors I decided that Sandy was the one for me. She explained everything and got me the price I had in mind. It was so easy! Now I'm spoiled...

Buyer review
Simply the best!
6 months ago
Simply the best!

Sandy's expertise showed through the whole process making us confident throughout the buying process. She also has a great network which made getting inspections easy. She is simply the best!!

Buyer review
Summerland Key Realtor
6 months ago
Summerland Key Realtor

Sandy helped us find our home in The Keys. She is super knowledgeable of the area and super easy to work with. I was not in town for the closing and she went above and beyond to make the experience go smooth for me. I would highly recommend her.

Show all 74 reviews
map

Sandra's properties

Sandra has 4 properties for sale and sold 16 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldJun 30, 2026
$4,150,000
421 La Fitte Rd
Monroe County FL 33042
3
4
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Island Welcome Real Estate
SoldJun 18, 2026
$5,000,000
24200 Overseas Hwy
Monroe County FL 33042
5
6
6
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Island Welcome Real Estate
SoldJun 9, 2026
$3,150,000
270 East Caribbean Drive
Summerland Key FL 33042
4
4
4
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Island Welcome Real Estate
SoldMay 19, 2026
$3,475,000
680 Elma Avenue
Big Pine Key FL 33043
4
4
4
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Island Welcome Real Estate
Show all 20 properties

Sandra's sold properties

Sandra has sold 16 properties in the past 12 months, showing 4.

Enter your property details to filter

I'm selling a
bedroom
with
bathrooms in
Property imageAddressBedroomsBathroomsCarparksProperty TypeClosing PriceDate Sold
421 La Fitte Rd, Monroe County, FL, 33042
421 La Fitte Rd
Monroe County FL 33042
3
4
2
Single-Family$4,150,000Jun 30, 2026
24200 Overseas Hwy, Monroe County, FL, 33042
24200 Overseas Hwy
Monroe County FL 33042
5
6
6
Single-Family$5,000,000Jun 18, 2026
270 East Caribbean Drive, Summerland Key, FL, 33042
270 East Caribbean Drive
Summerland Key FL 33042
4
4
4
Single-Family$3,150,000Jun 9, 2026
680 Elma Avenue, Big Pine Key, FL, 33043
680 Elma Avenue
Big Pine Key FL 33043
4
4
4
Single-Family$3,475,000May 19, 2026

Browse nearby locations

SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent