From 70 reviews overall

Sandra Tuttle
Island Welcome Real Estate

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Cudjoe Key
22440 Jolly Roger Drive Cudjoe Key
Sandra represented us as the sellers for our home at 22440 Jolly Roger, and she made the entire process straightforward. She knows the Keys market well and priced the house exactly where it needed to be. We were very happy with the final outcome and felt the value of the home was accurately captured in the sale. We also had a couple of open permits from Hurricane Irma that we didn’t realize were still active. Sandra helped us sort through everything, guided us through the steps to close them out, and kept the sale on track without unnecessary stress. Her communication was clear, she stayed on top of the details, and she handled every part of the process with professionalism. We were very satisfied working with her and would gladly work with her again.
165 Colson Drive Cudjoe Key
We’ve worked with Sandra for more than a decade and across multiple transactions, and she’s been consistently excellent. She helped us buy our first place in the Keys in 2011, and we’ve trusted her with over a dozen purchases and sales since then. For our recent home at 165 Colson Drive, she represented us as buyers and once again made the process straightforward. She knows the market extremely well, communicates clearly, and stays ahead of potential issues before they turn into problems. What stands out most about Sandra is her consistency. She’s steady, professional, and genuinely focused on getting the best outcome for her clients. After this many years and this many deals, we can say with confidence that she’s earned our trust, and we continue to choose her for that reason.
County Winner
ratemyagent award
Monroe County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Cudjoe Key2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Big Pine Key2026Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Cudjoe Key
Lot 357/701 Spanish Main Drive Cudjoe Key
My buying the Venture Out house # 357 involved a contingency contract on the sale of another house for a 1031 like kind exchange. It was a complex transaction that Trish and her team handled very well, enhancing and clarifying all communications between me and the seller. It took 5 months but it all worked perfectly in the end. Thank you, Trish
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Cudjoe Key
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Cudjoe Key
22924 Lookdown Ln Cudjoe Key
Pam has been awesome on this transaction and the previous 12-15 transactions she has represented me on over the years here in the keys. I am a licensed general contractor here in Florida since 1989 and Pam has been great with representing me in buying and selling homes and undeveloped and developed homes sites. I would recommend her to anyone.