Big Pine Key

Find a real estate agent in 6 easy steps

Share your situation without sharing personal details, and we'll find the right real estate agent to help you.

Find Me An Agent

22 real estate agents in Big Pine Key

Sorted by most reviews for agents in Big Pine Key over the past 12 months.

Sort by

5.0

From 70 reviews overall

Sandra Tuttle

Island Welcome Real Estate

2026 Award Winner

Top 20%

Price Expert

Last 12 months in Big Pine Key

$889k

Avg. sale price

Sold (as lead agent)

Reviews in Big Pine Key

29462 Geraldine Street Big Pine Key

Verified Review

The Best Agent in the Keys!

Sandra Tuttle did an excellent job of advertising my house through Home.com and other means available to the large public. Her descriptions of the house and location were right on and definitely geared to the correct potential buyers. She works hard and successfully sells! Thank you Sandy!

Theresa Raven 5 months ago

31463 Avenue G Big Pine Key

Verified Review

Excellent Experience

Working with Sandy was great, she made everything very easy. She is a Florida Keys expert, and I was in Michigan. You need someone you can trust when you are so far away, and Sandy made that very easy.

Abbey Brooks 5 months ago

Accolades

County Winner

ratemyagent award

Monroe County2026

City Winner

ratemyagent award

Big Pine Key2026

City Winner

ratemyagent award

Cudjoe Key2026

Market Report

4.9

From 14 reviews overall

Lauren Elliott

The Elliott Group

Price Expert

Last 12 months in Big Pine Key

N/A

Avg. sale price

Sold (as lead agent)

Reviews in Big Pine Key

29127 Violet Drive Big Pine Key

Verified Review

Hands On realtor!

From the start Lauren was engaged in the process, home searches, and closing days, even up to now(2 months past closing). She listens to the wants and desires of the client and does her best to match properties that meet your needs. Explained a lot of the processes as we went along. Nothing but great service! I can’t say enough about her actions.

Rick Benavides about 1 year ago