Sandy helped us find our home in The Keys. She is super knowledgeable of the area and super easy to work with. I was not in town for the closing and she went above and beyond to make the experience go smooth for me. I would highly recommend her.

Sandra represented us as the sellers for our home at 22440 Jolly Roger, and she made the entire process straightforward. She knows the Keys market well and priced the house exactly where it needed to be. We were very happy with the final outcome and felt the value of the home was accurately captured in the sale. We also had a couple of open permits from Hurricane Irma that we didn’t realize were still active. Sandra helped us sort through everything, guided us through the steps to close them out, and kept the sale on track without unnecessary stress. Her communication was clear, she stayed on top of the details, and she handled every part of the process with professionalism. We were very satisfied working with her and would gladly work with her again.

We’ve worked with Sandra for more than a decade and across multiple transactions, and she’s been consistently excellent. She helped us buy our first place in the Keys in 2011, and we’ve trusted her with over a dozen purchases and sales since then. For our recent home at 165 Colson Drive, she represented us as buyers and once again made the process straightforward. She knows the market extremely well, communicates clearly, and stays ahead of potential issues before they turn into problems. What stands out most about Sandra is her consistency. She’s steady, professional, and genuinely focused on getting the best outcome for her clients. After this many years and this many deals, we can say with confidence that she’s earned our trust, and we continue to choose her for that reason.

We’ve had the pleasure of working with Sandy Tuttle on multiple real estate transactions over the years—both buying and selling—and we wouldn’t trust anyone else. Most recently, she helped us sell our home, and once again, she went above and beyond every step of the way. Sandy brings a rare combination of professionalism, deep market knowledge, and genuine care for her clients. She was always available to answer our questions, offered honest advice, and guided us through the entire process with confidence and ease. From pricing and staging to marketing and negotiations, Sandy handled everything with incredible attention to detail. What sets her apart is her personal commitment—she doesn’t just list your home; she treats it like it’s her own. She’s not only a skilled agent, but a true advocate, always working in our best interest. After two purchases and two sales with Sandy, we can confidently say she’s the best in the business. If you’re looking for someone you can trust, who will go the extra mile, and who genuinely cares about helping you succeed, Sandy Tuttle is the one.

Sandra is extremely knowledgeable of the FL Keys and was very responsive to any inquiry or question we had along the way. If we were buying or selling again in the keys we would reach out to Sandra immediately.

We have purchased property many times before and have never had a better experience. Sandy was very knowledgeable and followed through to answer any questions we had. She worked hard to help us choose the right property and with no pressure. Such a professional!

Sandra has vast knowledge and experience in the Lower Keys market and and used this to our advantage to help us acquire our property. I highly recommend her and would not want to buy or sell a home without her on our side.

Very experienced, professional, and knowledgeable realtor. Sandra had all the best contacts for photos and videos and emphasized social media in her strategy. House was on the market about 2 1/2 weeks before we began negotiations on an offer and the closing occurred on time and without a hitch thanks to Sandra's attention to detail.

We appreciate Sandra’s local expertise and guidance- she had all the right contacts to keep things on track. I highly recommend her and the team at Island Welcome Real Estate- they were very accommodating and experienced that was great!