Krissy Carnahan

Krissy Carnahan

Florida Licensed Realtor: SL3508306Community Association Manager: CAM26088
  •   5   (30 reviews)

Krissy's sales performance at a glance

See how Krissy has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

12
Reviews
10
Properties for sale
9
Sold properties
$1.2m
Average sale price
$9.1m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

  • top20badge
  • priceExpertbadge
  • aotybadge
  • top20badge

    Recognized for being in the Top 20% for customer satisfaction.

  • priceExpertbadge

    Consistently meets client expectations for property purchase price.

  • aotybadge

    Recognized for going above & beyond for their clients.

Krissy's customer service awards

See what RateMyAgent awards Krissy has won

  • County Top 5Monroe County
  • City WinnerIslamorada, Village of Islands
  • 3x County Top 5Monroe County - 2026, 2025, 2024
  • 3x City WinnerIslamorada, Village of Islands - 2026, 2025, 2024

About Krissy

Meet Krissy Carnahan – Your Keys to the Keys! Searching for a trusted Florida Keys Realtor with deep local roots and unmatched island expertise? Krissy Carnahan is a top-performing Islamorada Realtor and Key Largo Real Estate Agent dedicated to helping buyers and sellers navigate the unique Florida Keys market with confidence. Whether you're searching for Islamorada waterfront homes, Tavernier luxury homes, Key Largo waterfront property, or waterfront homes for sale in the Florida Keys, Krissy delivers personalized service, local insight, and exceptional results. A Miami native with family ties to the Keys dating back to 1967, Krissy truly lives the island lifestyle she represents. As an experienced Upper Keys Realtor and Luxury Realtor in Islamorada, she understands every aspect of Florida Keys luxury real estate — from waterfront investments and vacation homes to luxury estates and private island retreats. Her extensive knowledge of Islamorada luxury homes and the surrounding communities allows her to guide clients toward the perfect property while maximizing value for sellers. Krissy’s professional background is as impressive as the market she serves. She holds a degree in Counseling & Rehabilitation from Marshall University and a Master’s degree in Higher Education from Florida State University. Her career journey includes real estate experience in Los Alamos, New Mexico, along with nearly two decades managing condominium and resort associations throughout the Florida Keys. This unique experience gives her a distinct advantage when helping clients buy or sell luxury condos, waterfront residences, and investment properties throughout Islamorada, Tavernier, and Key Largo. Beyond real estate, Krissy is deeply committed to the Florida Keys community and actively volunteers with organizations that support local families and underprivileged children. When she’s not helping clients achieve their real estate goals, she enjoys boating, embracing the outdoor island lifestyle, and spending time with her two English Labradors and fluffy Havanese. With Krissy Carnahan Realtor services, you’re getting more than a real estate agent — you’re gaining a trusted advisor, skilled negotiator, and local expert passionate about helping you achieve success in the Florida Keys luxury real estate market.

Social profiles

Krissy's reviews

  5  
Krissy has 30 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 6.
Review Krissy
Krissy's qualities as told by our client reviews: well-prepared, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Professional and knowledgeable of related sales at hand
6 days ago
Professional and knowledgeable of related sales at hand

Krissy was outstanding at her real estate knowledge, worked around the clock to help us with any questions we had. Working with her made the purchase of our newly acquired unit very easy and seamless. Glad to have her as our realtor.

Seller review
Very helpful communication
3 months ago
Very helpful communication

Working with Krissy to sell our home was truly special — not only because she’s an outstanding Realtor, but because she’s also a dear friend. From the very beginning, her communication and efforts were , clear, and reassuring, which meant so much to me throughout the entire process. Our sale was far from simple and became a very convoluted, but Krissy handled every challenge with professionalism, patience, and confidence. Her sales strategy, strong negotiation skills, and deep local knowledge made all the difference in getting us to a successful closing. She never missed a detail, always stayed one step ahead, and made sure we were informed every step of the way. We couldn’t be more grateful to have her— and we would wholeheartedly recommend Krissy to anyone looking for a truly dedicated, skilled, and caring real estate professional.

Seller review
Knowledgeable, Communicative, and Clearly Experienced in the Local Market
6 months ago
Knowledgeable, Communicative, and Clearly Experienced in the Local Market

I worked with Krissy to sell my condo in Islamorada, and I couldn’t be happier with the experience. From day one, she was professional, prepared, and clearly knew the local market. Krissy helped me decide on a smart listing price, guided me on which improvements were worth doing, and arranged beautiful photos and marketing. We had strong interest right away and closed a fair deal very quickly. What I appreciated most was the communication. She kept me updated at every step — showings, feedback, offers, and next steps — so I never felt in the dark. Any time I had a question, Krissy responded quickly and explained everything in a way that was easy to understand. In the end, we accepted an offer that I was very happy with, and the closing process was smooth and well organized. I would absolutely recommend Krissy Carnahan to anyone looking to sell their home.

Buyer review
Very good
6 months ago
Very good

Krissy was very helpful since I’m an out of state buyer. She was quick to respond to any and all of my questions and requests

Buyer review
Everything you want in a realtor
6 months ago
Everything you want in a realtor

Krissy was so helpful and professional throughtout the process of buying our 2nd home. She helped guide us through the steps and let us know what we needed to do from beginning to end. Her timely response to any questions we had put our minds at ease. I would definitely recommend her to anyone who is buying or selling in the florida keys. She is so wonderful we now consider her a friend and look forward to great times at our new place.

Show all 30 reviews
map

Krissy's properties

Krissy has 10 properties for sale and sold 9 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldApr 28, 2026
$320,000
119 Cortez Dr
Islamorada, Village of Islands FL 33036
1
1
Condo
Listing courtesy of Realty ONE Group Destination | Key West
For Sale
$1,050,000
162 Jo Jean Way
Tavernier FL 33070
4
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Realty ONE Group Destination | Key West
SoldJan 22, 2026
$3,205,000
230 Biscayne Boulevard
Islamorada, Village of Islands FL 33036
5
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Realty ONE Group Destination | Key West
For Sale
$3,500,000
501 Caribbean Drive
Key Largo FL 33037
4
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Realty ONE Group Destination | Key West
Show all 19 properties

Krissy's sold properties

Krissy has sold 9 properties in the past 12 months, showing 4.

Enter your property details to filter

I'm selling a
bedroom
with
bathrooms in
Property imageAddressBedroomsBathroomsCarparksProperty TypeClosing PriceDate Sold
119 Cortez Dr, Islamorada, Village of Islands, FL, 33036
119 Cortez Dr
Islamorada, Village of Islands FL 33036
1
1
Condo$320,000Apr 28, 2026
230 Biscayne Boulevard, Islamorada, Village of Islands, FL, 33036
230 Biscayne Boulevard
Islamorada, Village of Islands FL 33036
5
3
Single-Family$3,205,000Jan 22, 2026
G1/119 Cortez Drive
Islamorada, Village of Islands FL 33036
Other$377,500Nov 20, 2025
1g/119 Cortez Dr, Islamorada, Village of Islands, FL, 33036
1g/119 Cortez Dr
Islamorada, Village of Islands FL 33036
1
1
Condo$377,500Nov 20, 2025

Browse nearby locations

SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent