Keyseekers Real Estate

2435 Central Ave, St Petersburg, FL
Broker: BK3233972Broker : BK3269026
  •   5   (165 reviews)

Meet the team

Get to know the 8 agents at Keyseekers Real Estate.

Lisa Grey
Lisa Grey

Broker / Owner

  5   (134 reviews)
About Lisa
As Florida natives and Real Estate Professionals, we THE KEYSEEKERS, pride ourselves on unparalleled levels of service combine with a unique and informed perspective of the market, specifically the Orlando and St Pete & Tampa Bay markets. As GUILD level Certified Luxury Marketing and International Property Specialists, Our team is uniquely qualified to provide accurate data, industry perspectives and detailed current market conditions as well as a focused understanding of the luxury consumer. Our services extend well beyond a closing, creating long-term relationships based on trust and added value with all of our clients. A combination of compassion, patience and exceptional attention to detail mixed with energy, creativity and passion for design, form this powerful duo. Our personable approach is what sets us apart! From first time homebuyers to seasoned investors, our expertise will allow you to fulfill your dreams or financial goals whether you are buying or selling. We look forward to meeting you. CITY TO SEA - WE HAVE YOUR KEY Lisa Grey & Jennifer Grey
View ProfileRateMyAgent AchievementspriceExpertbadge
Jennifer Grey
Jennifer Grey

Broker / Owner

  5   (32 reviews)
About Jennifer

Jennifer currently has 18 active property listings and 32 sold property listings over the past 12 months.

View Profile
Olympia Hiotis
Olympia Hiotis

REALTOR®

  5   (15 reviews)
About Olympia
Pia is a seasoned entrepreneur and one of the most distinguished and trusted realtors in the Tampa Bay area. A native of the Buckeye state of Ohio, Pia has a long track record in delivering excellence and superior customer service, both as an executive for a group of retail brands as well as a founder of her own retail business. She created, owned, and operated an award- winning gourmet wine and spirits business for 14 years. Having built a million-dollar business from the ground up, she knows that hard work, creativity, and ambition can yield endless possibilities. In 2010, Pia traded frigid Ohio winters for a slice of paradise here in St. Petersburg. She purchased a mid-century home in Tropical Shores and never looked back. She fell in love with the beauty of her neighborhood, its convenient location with its proximity to downtown, and the tight knit community that embraced her as a newcomer. As you'll hear her say, it's one of St. Pete's "best little secrets". It wasn't too long before this passion for her adopted hometown led her to a successful career in real estate. As a result of her integrity, dedication, intuitive interpersonal skills, and her tenacious pursuit of delivering a best-in-class customer experience, she has generated $50million+ in sales volume in just over 10 years. She earns her clients' trust, secures confidentiality and seamlessly negotiates deals to turn their dreams into reality. As soon as they begin working with her, it comes as no surprise to her clients as to how she's developed such a sterling reputation. And her warmth, passion and authenticity are contagious. She won't hesitate to tell you that her Greek heritage is partly responsible for that. Having travelled extensively in Greece, she has been continually inspired by her culture's traditions and values. Let Pia find your perfect home or investment, or help you market your current property. OPA!
View Profile
Kayla Kantati
Kayla Kantati

REALTOR®

  5   (7 reviews)
About Gabe

Gabe currently has 10 active property listings and 16 sold property listings over the past 12 months.

View Profile
Jovan Georgievski
Jovan Georgievski

REALTOR®

  5   (2 reviews)
About Jovan

Jovan currently has 5 active property listings and 3 sold property listings over the past 12 months.

View Profile

About us

Welcome to Keyseekers Real Estate, an esteemed real estate powerhouse with offices in Orlando and St Petersburg, FL. We're more than Realtors; we're your partners in navigating the Commercial and Residential Real Estate Landscape. With accolades like Best of Florida, Best of Orlando, and a Nominee for New Biz on the Block in St. Petersburg, we take pride in our achievements. As Florida natives and seasoned professionals, we bring unmatched service combined with an insightful understanding of the Orlando, St. Pete, and Tampa Bay areas. Our team boasts GUILD-level certifications such as Luxury Marketing Specialist and International Property Specialist Designations, ensuring accurate data, industry insights, and a keen understanding of the luxury market. What truly sets us apart is our commitment to building relationships beyond the closing table. We prioritize trust, adding value, and a personalized approach, making your real estate journey not just seamless but enjoyable. For us, it's about more than transactions; it's about fostering connections that last a lifetime. Whether you're a first-time buyer or a seasoned investor, our expertise is your gateway to achieving your dreams and financial goals. We're here to make your real estate experience exceptional. Let's connect and make your aspirations a reality!

Social profiles

Our reviews

  5  
165 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 6.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: great negotiation, reliable, patient, responsive, supportive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Excellent communication and helpfulness.
3 days ago
Excellent communication and helpfulness.

Jovan was always helpful answering my many questions, had a great feel for the real estate market at the time of our sale, and held many open houses and kept us aware of the interest shown by prospective buyers.

Jovan Georgievski
Buyer review
Outstanding service, smooth experience from start to finish
12 days ago
Outstanding service, smooth experience from start to finish

I had a fantastic experience working with Jovan. From the very beginning, he was extremely responsive, professional, and knowledgeable. He took the time to clearly explain every step of the process, answered all my questions promptly, and made sure everything was organized down to the smallest detail. What really stood out was his ability to handle changes and challenges without any stress. He was patient, proactive, and always focused on finding the best solution. His communication was clear and consistent, which made the entire experience feel smooth and under control. It’s rare to find someone who combines professionalism with genuine care for the client experience. I would absolutely recommend working with him and would not hesitate to do so again in the future.

Jovan Georgievski
Buyer review
Trusted Advisor, True Partner, Innovative Expert
about 1 month ago
Trusted Advisor, True Partner, Innovative Expert

This is my second home purchase with Pia and I will never use anyone else to buy or sell my home. She takes the time to truly understand what I’m looking for in a home, and ensures we invest time in weeding through the process of looking at homes to thoroughly uncover the nuances of what will make me happy. She is extremely knowledgeable of the neighborhoods, the state of the market and is exceptionally responsive to my many questions and requests for information. I can’t brag about Pia enough!

Olympia Hiotis
Seller review
THE BEST there is!
2 months ago
THE BEST there is!

Working with Lisa and Jennifer Grey has been one of the best real estate experiences we’ve ever had. They helped us purchase our home in St. Pete Beach back in 2020, and when it came time to sell, there was never a question about who we would call. From the very beginning, they have gone above and beyond in every possible way. Their knowledge of the market, attention to detail, and ability to guide you through the process makes everything feel seamless. What really sets them apart though is how they make you feel. You’re not just another transaction to them. They genuinely care. Throughout the entire process, it felt like we were working with trusted friends who truly had our best interests at heart. They are dynamic, responsive, incredibly professional, and always one step ahead. Every question was answered quickly, every detail handled thoughtfully, and every step explained clearly. Buying and selling homes can be stressful, but Lisa and Jennifer make it feel easy. If you’re looking for a team that is knowledgeable, hardworking, and truly invested in their clients, you will not find better. We are so grateful for everything they did for us and cannot recommend them highly enough.

Lisa Grey
Seller review
Peace when I needed it most
3 months ago
Peace when I needed it most

Lisa, Jennifer, and Kristi were amazing to work with. I did not have an ideal home selling situation, but they were patient, kind, understanding, and professional. We got multiple offers, all of which were very reasonable. They made the whole experience easy, seamless, and enjoyable- even during tense, difficult times. I highly recommend this group. I am thankful they were there to help me along this journey. I know they will do the same for any client that comes their way!

Lisa Grey
Seller review
Knowledgeable,  professional, kind, empathetic realtors
3 months ago
Knowledgeable, professional, kind, empathetic realtors

Jenn and Lisa were knowledgeable and professional with great attention to detail. They helped me sell my parents' home quickly after they passed less than 24 hours apart. I was in shock and trying to navigate the sale and my parents' funerals and handling their estate details from over 1,000 miles away. Jenn and Lisa made everything so easy; they had 12 offers on the house the first day it went public, and they walked me through the options for different kinds of buyers, helping us make the best choice. When the first sale fell through, they immediately secured a second buyer and saw the sale through to completion, getting me the best terms and price possible. I was especially appreciative that they never once pressured me to make any improvements to the house to get a better price; they immediately understood that I did not have the capacity to put any energy into selling the home after three long years of caring for my elderly parents. They did what was best for me; they went out of their way repeatedly to help make the entire process easier on me. They have a great network of colleagues as well; the title company they used was fantastic and helped us navigate a particularly difficult situation during an incredibly stressful time. The sale was handled so efficiently by Jenn and Lisa that the house was sold and closed just over two months after my parents' deaths. They were not just realtors; they became friends and supported me through one of the most difficult times in my life. I cannot recommend them highly enough.

Jennifer GreyLisa Grey
Show all 165 reviews
map

Our properties

Keyseekers Real Estate has 44 properties for sale and sold 67 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

Pending
$575,000
459 Northmoor Avenue North
St. Petersburg FL 33702
4
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of KEYSEEKERS REAL ESTATE
SoldMay 6, 2026
$750,000
4100 Central Avenue
St. Petersburg FL 33711
1
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of DALTON WADE INC and KEYSEEKERS REAL ESTATE
Pending
$599,000
861 45th Avenue North
St. Petersburg FL 33703
3
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 LISTSMART
SoldMay 1, 2026
$885,000
369 22nd Avenue Southeast
St. Petersburg FL 33705
2
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of KEYSEEKERS REAL ESTATE
Show all 111 properties
© 2026 RateMyAgent