Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Siesta Key
N8/6005 Midnight Pass Road Siesta Key
Because of our two prior experiences with Cathy, purchasing and selling, we didn't hesitate when we decided to sell our Siesta Key Villa. Cathy was our "go to" professional. And once again, Cathy proved us to be correct. From the beginning of the process, Cathy communicated with a sound knowledge of the real estate market, current trends and an honesty that kept us in the loop constantly. Cathy has a skill for listening to the needs of the seller and all of the decisions effecting the sale were made in a collaborative manner with Valarie and I. All of our questions and concerns were addressed as needed. The present market in Florida does not favor the seller but Cathy worked diligently and sold our home after hosting two open houses. She guided us through inspections, repairs and the eventual closing, making the process as stress free as possible. We can't say enough about Cathy's professionalism, honesty, communication skills, and excellent customer service. We never hesitate to recommend Cathy to other friends who are looking to either buy or sell. Cathy takes the stress out of the real estate experience and you know that she will take care of you from beginning to end. Cathy has definitely been a true gift in our lives!
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Siesta Key
5215 Cape Leyte Drive Siesta Key
She is excellent. A majority of our interactions occurred when we were not living in the area. She kept of constantly informed about what was happening and responded immediately to our responses. At a time when the market was slowing down, she was able to sell our house and condo in a few months. She is very professional but also cares a great deal about her clients. She has our highest recommendation.
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Siesta Key
710/5780 Midnight Pass Road Siesta Key
Customer service at the forefront. Not only does Carol know the market from top to bottom, she is a wealth of information when it comes to property management. Having someone in your corner when it comes to purchase, renovation, management and sale with Carols knowledge is a value so far beyond the cost of commission. I would highly recommend Carol for all your real estate needs, I will be using her again in the future.
From 157 reviews overall

Joe Murphy
COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Siesta Key
124 Beach Road Siesta Key
We are empty nesters who were moving to the west coast of FL to be near family after living in the same East Coast FL town for 32 years. Our house of 21 years was under contract with closing scheduled in one month and we had a long weekend to either find a new home or resort to a rental property should we be unable to find a suitable home to purchase. Joe was referred to us by my sister who is a Coldwell Banker agent in Charlotte NC. I had been scouring the various realty websites for over 1 year searching for homes within a 30 minute radius of our family members. He was able to arrange viewings for a number of properties that we had chosen as a possible landing point for us. One neighborhood in particular was quite appealing to us as they allowed our dog and the HOA fees covered all exterior maintenance including the roof. Joe was able to uncover that the HOA was going to replace the roofs next year but at an assessment to be charged to each homeowner of $25-30k! We were not finding any existing homes that seemed suitable for us and Joe suggested that we take a look at a new home community nearby from a respected builder that was offering great incentives for their completed spec homes. We had never considered a new home but Joe thought it would be a good fit for us due to the lower HOA fees vs a condo as well as the warranties and lack of maintenance and updating required and the amenities available in a new build community. We found a home that was WAY nicer than anything that we had considered buying and he managed to also negotiate a lower price than asking and paid closing costs which made the home affordable for us. We could NOT be happier with our new home purchase and it truly is due to Joe’s real estate knowledge and expertise as well as his care and concern for the needs of his clients that we are enjoying a new chapter on our family’s life!
National Top 100
ratemyagent award
United States2026Region Top 20
ratemyagent award
Southeast Region2026County Winner
ratemyagent award
Manatee County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Bradenton2026