975 real estate agents in Sarasota

GREAT ,one-of-a-kind very patient.

Toni was very helpful beyond my expectations & took me threw the process,many hoops & hurdles to go threw. Very stressful for me but Toni made me feel assured that all would be good & im very pleased & im having Toni help me purchase another property. Thank you Toni.

We were a seller of a home needing deferred maintenance, and Toni proved invaluable in navigating a challenging real estate market. She was professional, yet personable; extremely knowledgeable; quick to communicate updates; and always available to answer our questions. As we live well outside the Sarasota area, Toni's contractor contacts were a lifesaver, and she often stepped in herself to accomplish what was needed to upgrade the home to secure the sale. We would not have achieved as successful an outcome without her. Toni would be my first choice for any residential real estate need in South Florida.

We recently worked with Alison to sell our home, and we couldn't be happier with the experience. From the initial consultation to the final closing, Alison was professional, proactive, and incredibly knowledgeable about the local market. They handled every detail with precision, making what could have been a stressful process feel completely seamless. If you’re looking for a dedicated professional who gets results, we highly recommend Alison!

Alison is the best realtor we’ve ever worked with. Her communication is proactive and clear. She’s incredibly responsive, extremely knowledgeable, and if there was ever a question she didn’t immediately have the answer to, she found it quickly and thoroughly for us. She kept everything organized and made the entire transaction feel seamless. Three weeks later, we closed on our dream beach condo — and we truly couldn’t have done it without her.

I have had a number of real estate agents, including a very duplicitous one. Whereas most have been pleasant, they have not been outstanding or remarkable. I am not the sort of individual who brags about anyone who has provided a service for me...with one exception: Alison Stottlemyer is Outstanding!! I have referred her to several friends who have also been equally impressed with her & her abilities in selling their homes & with very good reasons. I have a partner who had never met her. He too now is not only equally impressed with her skills, dedication & attention to the most minute details, that he too is going to have her list his house. She is one in a million & no one who enlists Alison to sell or buy a home, will be very satisfied at how incredibly smooth she makes things flow & lowers the stress level by many, many degrees. And she's an incredible delight deal with, to boot!

Carolyn was wonderful to work with. She went above and beyond to make our experience a great one.

I had the most wonderful experience working with Roberta and her incredible team (Jessica) . My daughter, who works for a Sotheby’s affiliate (Daniel Gale) in New York, connected me with Roberta & Jessica, and from the very first meeting I knew I was in the best hands. They instantly made me feel comfortable, listened carefully to what I was looking for, and provided thoughtful guidance every step of the way. I had my heart set on staying in the building where I was currently renting, even though there wasn’t much inventory available. Roberta & her team kept a close eye on the market, and when the perfect unit finally came on, she moved quickly and skillfully to help me secure it. Thanks to her expertise, we successfully negotiated the deal, and the entire process was seamless, smooth, and handled with the highest level of professionalism. Roberta is truly exceptional at what she does—knowledgeable, supportive, and dedicated—and she made what could have been a stressful experience feel easy and enjoyable. I would highly recommend her, along with the Sotheby’s brand, to anyone looking to buy or sell.

I’ve worked with Roberta Tengerdy three times now—in 2008 when I bought my first home, then in 2022 when my wife sold her home, and again in 2025 when my wife and I sold our first home. I wouldn’t use anyone else. Roberta works incredibly hard for her clients and has a remarkable ability to negotiate. She will fight for you every step of the way. I worked mostly with Roberta, but also with Carolyn Barker Collins, and together they make a fantastic team. When the Sarasota real estate market was hot, their expertise was invaluable, but when the market cooled down more recently, it became absolutely crucial. They know how to assess the true value of your home and how to advocate for you so that you get the best outcome possible. What really stands out is their honesty. They don't just tell you what you want to hear—she tells you what you need to hear. For example, they told me my yard needed fixing up before listing. It created a lot of work for me, but she was right, and it made a difference. Even more importantly, they put our interests ahead of their own when we we were selling. That kind of integrity is rare, and it showed me how trustworthy they really are. If you’re looking for agents who will work tirelessly, negotiate fiercely, and always put your interests first, I can’t recommend Roberta and Carolyn highly enough.