From 163 reviews overall

Roberta Tengerdy PA and Carolyn Barker Collins PA
Premier Sotheby's International Realty

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 34236
501/707 South Gulfstream Avenue Sarasota
I had the most wonderful experience working with Roberta and her incredible team (Jessica) . My daughter, who works for a Sotheby’s affiliate (Daniel Gale) in New York, connected me with Roberta & Jessica, and from the very first meeting I knew I was in the best hands. They instantly made me feel comfortable, listened carefully to what I was looking for, and provided thoughtful guidance every step of the way. I had my heart set on staying in the building where I was currently renting, even though there wasn’t much inventory available. Roberta & her team kept a close eye on the market, and when the perfect unit finally came on, she moved quickly and skillfully to help me secure it. Thanks to her expertise, we successfully negotiated the deal, and the entire process was seamless, smooth, and handled with the highest level of professionalism. Roberta is truly exceptional at what she does—knowledgeable, supportive, and dedicated—and she made what could have been a stressful experience feel easy and enjoyable. I would highly recommend her, along with the Sotheby’s brand, to anyone looking to buy or sell.
512 Madison Ct Sarasota
Carolyn was fabulous every step of the way. No question was too silly, her expertise and knowledge of the market, vendors , etc was incredible!! Carolyn ensured the process was easy and stressless! And we had fun along the way. I couldn't be happier with my new home- thank you Carolyn!!
501/707 South Gulfstream Avenue Sarasota
My daughter in New York works for a Sotheby’s affiliate and introduced me to Roberta. From our very first meeting, we had an instant connection, and she—along with her wonderful assistant Jessica—took exceptional care of me throughout the entire process. Since I was only interested in purchasing a condo within the Essex House, my options were limited. When two units became available, Roberta and Jessica guided me through the negotiations and helped secure the perfect fit for my needs. I would highly recommend them to anyone—they will truly take great care of you
From 46 reviews overall

Yvette Sellyn
Coldwell Banker Residential Real Estate - Longboat Key

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 34236
418 Meadow Lark Drive Sarasota
When I decided to sell the smartest decision I made was hiring Yvette to be my realtor. The sale was quick and easy. Yvette was a true professional and went out of her way to make sure everything was as convenient as possible for me, I could not have been happier with the entire process, I would strongly recommend Yvette Sellyn to anyone who is thinking of selling.
604 Mourning Dove Dr Sarasota
Yvette is fantastic to work with. After touring one of her Bird Key listings' open house (we fell in love with) and speaking with her, we ultimately used Yvette as our agent for the Buyer's side and are grateful we did just that. The transaction went as smoothly as anyone could hope for between all parties and Yvette was the keystone to make that happen. Yvette worked around the clock coordinating efforts between us and the Sellers to get us closed ahead of schedule per our request (from inspections, minor repairs, furnishings moved out, etc). She is a straight shooter that wants the best for her clients, whether it be the Buyer or Seller, and for all parties to be happy when it's all said and done. We highly recommend Yvette to anyone looking around Bird Key and/or Sarasota area in general and look forward to seeing her around! Thank you Yvette!
From 36 reviews overall

Bruce Myer
Coldwell Banker Realty - Longboat Key

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 34236
430 Pheasant Way Sarasota
I highly recommend Chase Myer. He showed us numerous properties over the year and was never pushy. He answered all questions and was available throughout the purchase of our home. I now consider Chase a friend.
City Winner
ratemyagent award
Longboat Key2026Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 34236
2220 Palm Terrace South Sarasota
Monica is a true professional—knowledgeable, sharp, and incredibly tenacious. She goes the extra mile without hesitation and is absolutely relentless when it comes to representing her clients’ best interests. Add in her kindness and intelligence, and you have an exceptional real estate. I have bought and sold several houses with Monica. Put simply, she is, by far, the best agent in town!
3467 Byron Lane Longboat Key
I purchased and later sold a home using Monica's services and in both cases, she was a great communicator, very responsive and performed beyond expectations. Monica coordinated most activities and vendors to prepare my home for sale which was a great benefit to me as an out of town owner. I wouldn't hesitate to use her services in the future and appreciate all her efforts.
6621 The Masters Avenue Bradenton
I can’t say enough good things about our realtors. They consistently went above and beyond throughout the entire process, always putting our best interests first. Their professionalism, responsiveness, and deep knowledge made every step smooth and stress-free. From the very beginning, Monica and Kelsey treated us like more than just a client — they truly care. If you’re looking for someone who will go the extra mile (and then some), I would highly recommend them!