From 84 reviews overall

Mike Martino
KELLER WILLIAMS ON THE WATER S

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Siesta Key
910/5880 Midnight Pass Road Siesta Key
From day 1 we knew Mike was our agent. He not only sold us our brand new home, he found it, made several construction site visits, with video updates, and guided us through the process of buying a new construction home even though we were 1,500 miles away the entire time. He also sold our existing condo in record time even though other properties similar properties remain on the market. His professional approach to listing, marketing and closing a sale are second to none! Thanks, Mike for your incredible commitment to your craft!
5369 Shadowlawn Drive Siesta Key
I initially called Mike about one of his listings, and was not intending to hook up with a realtor quite yet. As an out of state buyer, I had also never purchased a property in Florida before. While the property I called about was not right for me, Mike was so personable and knowledgeable, I quickly knew he was the right realtor for me; no BS; absolute professionalism. After reviewing multiple listings Mike sent to me, I flew down to Sarasota and did a two day marathon viewing houses. As a recent retiree who has renovated several homes through the years, I had promised myself I would not buy another fixer upper, but when you find the right home, you have to go with it. Mike educated me about the pros and cons and local regulations regarding the property. With me back North, Mike attended all of the inspections (property, sewer, mold, pool) and kept in close contact with me. He helped me to negotiate an excellent buying price, and also to obtain temporary housing during the renovation. It has been several weeks since the closing, and Mike continues to assist me and be available for questions and obstacles. I don't think I could have done this without his help, dedication and knowledge (without losing my sanity lol). I have nothing but accolades for Mike. If you want a top notch realty agent, without question, contact Mike Martino!
City Winner
ratemyagent award
Siesta Key2026Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Siesta Key
303/5780 Midnight Pass Road Siesta Key
My wife and I have been interested in finding a place near Sarasota for four years. We met Steve in 2022 and shared our plans with him. He patiently worked with us to help learn the area and narrow down our search. For three years, he showed us numerous properties until we finally found the right place early in 2026. When we were ready to commit, Steve and his team were there every step of the way to help us buy and close on our property. We did a remote close without any hesitation, knowing that he was our representative. We got the right place at the right price. All our questions were answered. If you have the desire to acquire a property in the Osprey / Siesta Key / greater Sarasota area, we can't recommend Steve highly enough.
4941 Commonwealth Dr Siesta Key
Thank You Steve and crew. You opened the door to our new Condo at Blackburn Point Marina Village in March and Closed the deal on selling our Siesta Key Home 48 hours later. Doesn't get any better than that....... Thank you for helping us through-out the two months of the process. You're the BEST! Joan & Don
County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Sarasota County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Osprey2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Vamo2026Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Siesta Key
118B/1048 West Peppertree Lane Siesta Key
Cheryl had both great in-depth knowledge of the condo and overall negotiating/closing process. She was very personable, competent, and responsive throughout the whole process. We'd choose her again.
From 32 reviews overall

Shane Lewis
Michael Saunders & Company - Siesta Key Office

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Siesta Key