Back Siesta Key

Find a real estate agent in 6 easy steps

Share your situation without sharing personal details, and we'll find the right real estate agent to help you.

Find Me An Agent

213 real estate offices in Siesta Key

Sorted by most reviews for offices in Siesta Key over the past 12 months.
View KELLER WILLIAMS ON THE WATER S's profile

KELLER WILLIAMS ON THE WATER S

5.0

From 570 reviews overall

Last 12 months in Siesta Key

3

Reviews in Siesta Key

30

Sold

39

For Sale

$32.7m

Total sales value

$1.1m

Avg. sale price

Incredible Professional Realtor!

From day 1 we knew Mike was our agent. He not only sold us our brand new home, he found it, made several construction site visits, with video updates, and guided us through the process of buying a new construction home even though we were 1,500 miles away the entire time. He also sold our existing condo in record time even though other properties similar properties remain on the market. His professional approach to listing, marketing and closing a sale are second to none! Thanks, Mike for your incredible commitment to your craft!

5 months ago
Email
View MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY's profile

MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY

4.9

From 524 reviews overall

Last 12 months in Siesta Key

2

Reviews in Siesta Key

87

Sold

114

For Sale

$111.8m

Total sales value

$1.3m

Avg. sale price

Accommodating and Motivated Agent!

The agent's vast knowledge and resources made the offer to closing process seamless and efficient process- very professional!

Brian Polmanteer 5 months ago
Email
View COLDWELL BANKER REALTY's profile

COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

5.0

From 783 reviews overall

Last 12 months in Siesta Key

2

Reviews in Siesta Key

19

Sold

20

For Sale

$27.9m

Total sales value

$1.5m

Avg. sale price

Patient and professional

My wife and I have been interested in finding a place near Sarasota for four years. We met Steve in 2022 and shared our plans with him. He patiently worked with us to help learn the area and narrow down our search. For three years, he showed us numerous properties until we finally found the right place early in 2026. When we were ready to commit, Steve and his team were there every step of the way to help us buy and close on our property. We did a remote close without any hesitation, knowing that he was our representative. We got the right place at the right price. All our questions were answered. If you have the desire to acquire a property in the Osprey / Siesta Key / greater Sarasota area, we can't recommend Steve highly enough.

6 months ago
Email
View Bright Realty's profile

Bright Realty

5.0

From 350 reviews overall

Last 12 months in Siesta Key

2

Reviews in Siesta Key

8

Sold

8

For Sale

$8.4m

Total sales value

$1m

Avg. sale price

Bill did an excellent job!

Bill and his team did an excellent job! Always answered the phone when I called him about a question. And always had an excellent answer to my questions. Bill and his team were very supportive and knowledgeable. They always made me feel like I was there number one priority. They made the whole process very easy and I would highly recommend them to whoever is looking to buy a house or Condo.

Brian Abeling 4 months ago
Email
View COLDWELL BANKER REALTY's profile

COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

5.0

From 291 reviews overall

Last 12 months in Siesta Key

1

Reviews in Siesta Key

64

Sold

83

For Sale

$70.8m

Total sales value

$1.1m

Avg. sale price

Agent was very helpful in the process of buying a home in Florida and knew the market very well.

We worked with Julia Montei, she is an excellent agent with good communication skills and was very knowledgeable about the market area. She was always available to answer our calls and very helpful with answering all our questions in a timely manner. She worked well with the sellers agent and referred us to a loan officer to help navigate a smooth closing. She is a professional that never missed a meeting or call and was always available with her knowledge to help us make some hard decisions. We would recommend her to new buyers because she is a hard worker who cares about her customers. We were very satisfied with the timeliness and her ability to get things done in a professional manner.

Steve & Renee Belak 4 months ago
Email
View COLDWELL BANKER REALTY's profile

COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

5.0

From 304 reviews overall

Last 12 months in Siesta Key

1

Reviews in Siesta Key

13

Sold

16

For Sale

$18.2m

Total sales value

$1.4m

Avg. sale price

Smooth Purchase

Andree was very easy to work with! She’s responsive and wasn’t too pushy with us, which I appreciated. She’s knowledgeable and professional.

5 months ago
Email
View MANGROVE REALTY ASSOCIATES's profile

MANGROVE REALTY ASSOCIATES

5.0

From 29 reviews overall

Last 12 months in Siesta Key

1

Reviews in Siesta Key

2

Sold

1

For Sale

$2m

Total sales value

$985k

Avg. sale price

Her market knowledge, communication and professionalism is outstanding

She is excellent. A majority of our interactions occurred when we were not living in the area. She kept of constantly informed about what was happening and responded immediately to our responses. At a time when the market was slowing down, she was able to sell our house and condo in a few months. She is very professional but also cares a great deal about her clients. She has our highest recommendation.

Peter & Janet 6 months ago
Email
View COLDWELL BANKER REALTY's profile

COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

5.0

From 615 reviews overall

Last 12 months in Siesta Key

1

Reviews in Siesta Key

1

Sold

8

For Sale

$895k

Total sales value

$895k

Avg. sale price

Simply the best!

We are empty nesters who were moving to the west coast of FL to be near family after living in the same East Coast FL town for 32 years. Our house of 21 years was under contract with closing scheduled in one month and we had a long weekend to either find a new home or resort to a rental property should we be unable to find a suitable home to purchase. Joe was referred to us by my sister who is a Coldwell Banker agent in Charlotte NC. I had been scouring the various realty websites for over 1 year searching for homes within a 30 minute radius of our family members. He was able to arrange viewings for a number of properties that we had chosen as a possible landing point for us. One neighborhood in particular was quite appealing to us as they allowed our dog and the HOA fees covered all exterior maintenance including the roof. Joe was able to uncover that the HOA was going to replace the roofs next year but at an assessment to be charged to each homeowner of $25-30k! We were not finding any existing homes that seemed suitable for us and Joe suggested that we take a look at a new home community nearby from a respected builder that was offering great incentives for their completed spec homes. We had never considered a new home but Joe thought it would be a good fit for us due to the lower HOA fees vs a condo as well as the warranties and lack of maintenance and updating required and the amenities available in a new build community. We found a home that was WAY nicer than anything that we had considered buying and he managed to also negotiate a lower price than asking and paid closing costs which made the home affordable for us. We could NOT be happier with our new home purchase and it truly is due to Joe’s real estate knowledge and expertise as well as his care and concern for the needs of his clients that we are enjoying a new chapter on our family’s life!

11 months ago
Email
View The Team at Hunt Brothers Realty's profile

The Team at Hunt Brothers Realty

5.0

From 181 reviews overall

Meet the team

Andrew McNeilTravis KreischerRob Hunt, Jr
+9

Last 12 months in Siesta Key

1

Reviews in Siesta Key

1

Sold

1

For Sale

$1.7m

Total sales value

$1.7m

Avg. sale price

Tremendous support throughout the entire process

Andrew was incredibly professional, knowledgeable and we always felt like he was working with us to find the right home for the right value. We were able to do that, finding a home at market value vs what the owners were asking. Once the offer was submitted, the real work began and Andrew and his team did a great job supporting us throughout the entire process. We were in good hands. I would highly recommend Andrew and the team at Hunt Brothers.

Satisfied Buyer 2 months ago
Email
1 - 9 of 287

View nearby Cities

© 2026 RateMyAgent