Alison's profile

Alison's reviews

  5  
Alison has 82 reviewsacross 21 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Alison's qualities as told by our client reviews: dedicated, attentive, great negotiation, detail-oriented, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Never knew a realtor could offer SO MUCH
almost 5 years ago
Never knew a realtor could offer SO MUCH

(And, my parents and brother were realtors) Alison is so knowledgeable of the market, and the nuances of financing and mortgages. She finds out your needs and looks for ways to please. Through every step in the dificult process of buying one home and selling another, she was our confident guide leading us through it. We know that she genuinely cared about us and it was quite pleasant to see her get just as excited when she is pointing out features she knows we will love. I'm also certain you will have the same experience.

Buyer review
Simply an outstanding real estate agent!
about 5 years ago
Simply an outstanding real estate agent!

Alison Stottlemyer is simply an outstanding real estate agent!. Her excellence as a realtor is evident in every facet of the home buying and selling process. My wife and I recently sold two properties to purchase our dream home and Alison was paramount to it. From start to finish she was communicative, transparent, prompt and facilitated every in person interaction and subsequent transactions in a most professional and courteous manner. As her clients, she seemingly catered to our every want and need and made the often daunting challenges of buying and selling a home the best of experiences. We could not be happier! We will always recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell property here in Sarasota or anywhere in the Tampa Bay area. Thank you Alison for everything you've done to give us a home we love!

Buyer review
I have no idea what magic she worked, but I’m so grateful to have had her in our corner.
over 5 years ago
I have no idea what magic she worked, but I’m so grateful to have had her in our corner.

My wife and I recently relocated to Sarasota from Chicago with our son. Alison helped us get to know Sarasota, learn the neighborhoods, and had recommendations for everything from the best parks for toddlers to contractors for renovations. She’s a one-stop-shop for relocation because she gets to know you and what you want, then knows exactly where to find it. We are going through an epic market rush at the moment and Alison always made time to squeeze us into “it just popped up!” showings. Alison is personable, friendly, the utmost professional and overall is just an amazing person to work with. When we found our dream house she transformed into a hard-hitting negotiator and landed us awesome deal. I have no idea what magic she worked, but I’m so grateful to have had her in our corner. You could not find a better realtor to work with in the Sarasota area!

Buyer review
Fierce negotiator
over 5 years ago
Fierce negotiator

My wife and I recently relocated to Sarasota from Chicago with our son. Alison helped us get to know Sarasota, learn the neighborhoods, and had recommendations for everything from the best parks for toddlers to contractors for renovations. She’s a one-stop-shop for relocation because she gets to know you and what you want, then knows exactly where to find it. We are going through an epic market rush at the moment and Alison always made time to squeeze us into “it just popped up!” showings. Alison is personable, friendly, the utmost professional and overall is just an amazing person to work with. When we found our dream house she transformed into a hard-hitting negotiator and landed us an amazing deal. I have no idea what magic she worked, but I’m so grateful to have had her in our corner! You could not find a better realtor to work with in the Sarasota area!

Buyer review
I can’t say enough good things about her!
over 5 years ago
I can’t say enough good things about her!

My dealings with Alison we’re both professional and very very nice! I can’t say enough about the quality of her service, caring and professionalism even though I bought a less expensive home learn a lot in the area. She gave me the same great service that she would give to $1 million home buyer. I can’t say enough good things about her!! If you have the chance to use her for your real estate agent I strongly recommend it. You can’t go wrong!

Seller review
She is a local, with a great attitude, and extensive knowledge of the area and market values.
almost 6 years ago
She is a local, with a great attitude, and extensive knowledge of the area and market values.

I am so happy after hiring Alison as our listing realtor. She is a local, with a great attitude, and extensive knowledge of the area and market values. Alison gave us honest feedback and helped us at every turn. She communicated with us keeping us in the loop no matter what the news. She gave us great advice on staging the home and used technology to help market us in the COVID- world.We were under contract in less than 3 days and closed on the sale in less than a month. We were very happy and grateful to have such a positive experience and it took a huge weight off our shoulders. Alison is a breath of fresh air and looking for what is best for her client.

Seller review
Supportive, helpful & the consummate professional at EVERY level
almost 6 years ago
Supportive, helpful & the consummate professional at EVERY level

Alison was a complete breath of fresh air & not daunted by any obstacles. I had a very negative experience w/a previous realtor I had known for 30 yrs. After that experience, I was cynical & not very trusting. Alison was fantastic from the get go before we even met. First, unlike other realtors, she is Not a numbers person, just seeking your listing to pile up her numbers. She listens very, very carefully, asks great questions, takes judicious notes, makes excellent recommendations & makes you feel as if you are her only client. The day my 1st offer came in, she was negotiating 2 other contracts! She always called me back, offered sage advice, was wonderful psychologically w/how I should proceed. She appealed to my business sense, has a great demeanor about her & is incredibly tenacious as well professional. I have already recommended her to 2 people & she has already met w/1. They were equally impressed & intend to list w/Alison. I am not one who invests her ego in others, saying "you have to use my person because they are the best". But in this case, Alison was so supportive, helpful & the consummate professional at Every level. She guided me through everything & allayed my few fears. She was a great sounding board as well. You will Never be disappointed if you should choose her are your selling agent. You will be very, very pleased.

Seller review
Alison was a complete breath of fresh air
about 6 years ago
Alison was a complete breath of fresh air

Alison was a complete breath of fresh air & not daunted by any obstacles. I had a very negative experience w/a previous realtor I had known for 30 yrs. After that experience, I was cynical & not very trusting. Alison was fantastic from the get go before we even met. First, unlike other realtors, she is Not a numbers person, just seeking your listing to pile up her numbers. She listens very, very carefully, asks great questions, takes judicious notes, makes excellent recommendations & makes you feel as if you are her only client. The day my 1st offer came in, she was negotiating 2 other contracts! She always called me back, offered sage advice, was wonderful psychologically w/how I should proceed. She appealed to my business sense, has a great demeanor about her & is incredibly tenacious as well professional. I have already recommended her to 2 people & she has already met w/1. They were equally impressed & intend to list w/Alison. I am not one who invests her ego in others, saying "you have to use my person because they are the best". But in this case, Alison was so supportive, helpful & the consummate professional at Every level. She guided me through everything & allayed my few fears. She was a great sounding board as well. You will Never be disappointed if you should choose her are your selling agent. You will be very, very pleased.

Seller review
Great communicator, market savvy, and will get things done for you
about 6 years ago
Great communicator, market savvy, and will get things done for you

Alison has become my go-to realtor in Sarasota. I have used her for two separate transactions and both have been flawless. If you are looking to work with a relator who is a great communicator, market savvy, and will get things done for you, she is the one. I would highly recommend Alison for your Sarasota real estate needs!

Seller review
Full-service realtor who knows Sarasota like few do
over 6 years ago
Full-service realtor who knows Sarasota like few do

Selling your home is such a challenging process. For us, we needed someone to take the reins, put the plan in place, remind us regularly of what needed doing, and recognize when a small thing could make a big difference. Who knew that a ceramic pineapple would resonate with our buyers? Well, Alison Aidlin Stottlemyer, our agent, did. If you want a full-service realtor who knows Sarasota like few do, check out her website and give her a call. You'll be surprised how fast you sell. Home 1 sold in a week with multiple offers. Home 2? Three hours! And with multiple offers and over asking. What more could you want?

61 - 72 of 82
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent