Alison's profile

Alison's reviews

  5  
Alison has 82 reviewsacross 21 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Alison's qualities as told by our client reviews: dedicated, attentive, great negotiation, detail-oriented, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Highly recommend for your next relocation!
over 1 year ago
Highly recommend for your next relocation!

Alison provided the patience and guidance to support a cross-country relocation that was a journey, not a sprint. Timing is key and Alison "brought it" when it came time to close. I appreciate her so much for delivering on many requests for viewings and accommodating our unique needs. Highly recommend for your next relocation!

Seller review
Alison made it easy!
over 1 year ago
Alison made it easy!

Alison was recommended to me by a friend who is a realtor in another part of Florida. My friend did me a huge favor! We thought we would need about a month to get our house ready to sell and picked an MLS listing date with Alison. Getting ready didn’t take as long as we thought, so we told her that if she had any in house prospects, she was welcome to bring them by. Surprise, surprise, one showing and we had a full price cash offer! Let me say there was nothing wrong with our asking price. The sales process has been very smooth. Alison is open, outgoing, perceptive, warm, intelligent, and knows the market. We would highly recommend her for your real estate needs.

Seller review
Best Agent Ever!
over 1 year ago
Best Agent Ever!

Alison was recommended to us by a friend who is a realtor in another part of Florida. Our friend did us a huge favor! We thought we would need about a month to get our house ready to sell and picked an MLS listing date with Alison. Getting ready didn’t take as long as we thought, so we told her that if she had any in-house prospects, she was welcome to bring them by. Surprise, surprise, one showing and we had a full price cash offer! Let us say there was nothing wrong with our asking price. The sales process was generally smooth, but whenever there was a bump in the road, Alison went into action on our behalf. Alison is open, outgoing, perceptive, warm, intelligent, and she knows the market. We have sold several houses over time and have never before had the kind of service Alison provided. We would highly recommend her for your real estate needs.

Seller review
Alison is open, outgoing, perceptive, warm, intelligent, and knows the market
over 1 year ago
Alison is open, outgoing, perceptive, warm, intelligent, and knows the market

Alison was recommended to me by a friend who is a realtor in another part of Florida. My friend did me a huge favor!We thought we would need about a month to get our house ready to sell and picked an MLS listing date with Alison. Getting ready didn’t take as long as we thought, so we told her that if she had any in house prospects, she was welcome to bring them by. Surprise, surprise, one showing and we had a full price cash offer! Let me say there was nothing wrong with our asking price.The sales process has been very smooth. Alison is open, outgoing, perceptive, warm, intelligent, and knows the market. We would highly recommend her for your real estate needs.

Buyer review
Can't begin to imagine a better realtor
almost 2 years ago
Can't begin to imagine a better realtor

I don't know if I have enough kind words to describe how wonderful it is to work with Alison Stottlemeyer. She was fully invested in me and my search for a new home in Sarasota. As I am moving from another state, she and I had multiple discussions prior to my arrival to check out the properties in the area. She worked late into the night to accomplish the task of finding my new home. She also took as much pride and joy as I when I found my new place. After I left to return to my current residence she continued to work tirelessly taking it upon herself to find roofing estimates for minor repairs and even personally dropping off my application for the new HOA. You will not be disappointed by Alison. She definitely goes the extra mile. Consider yourself very fortunate to have Alison as your realtor.

Buyer review
Outstanding Customer Service
almost 2 years ago
Outstanding Customer Service

Alison has been our trusted advisor throughout our lot selection and new custom home design process. We are currently living out of town and we required a local real estate expert to steer us through this complex journey, of which Alison went above & beyond to make the total customer experience flawless. We were especially pleased with her local knowledge of important decisions we made such as builder differences/buyer fit, future resale value-add decisions being made, and insights to local businesses offering the best product fits for our particular needs. We would highly recommend Alison as your real estate professional in the Sarasota market! A+ service & response time.

Seller review
Thrilled with Alison's exceptional service, market expertise and commitment
almost 2 years ago
Thrilled with Alison's exceptional service, market expertise and commitment

To say Alison went "above and beyond" would be an understatement. From the staging, marketing, follow-up with prospective buyers, constant communication with us, checking on the house and meeting with various third parties after we moved out of state, she was exceptionally resourceful and helpful. What could have been a very stressful process for us was honestly seamless thanks to her involvement. It honestly felt like we we were her only client even though we knew she had many others she was helping at the same time. Her market expertise was spot on and her deep connection in the community and with many local contacts made a big difference as well in ensuring we had steady interest, despite going through two major hurricanes during the listing process! Plus I truly believe that her sunny personality, kindness and honesty encouraged potential buyers and agents to want to work with her. All around a great experience and we are so thankful she got our house sold for a good price and within our desired timeframe!

Buyer review
Great Experience!
about 2 years ago
Great Experience!

Alison goes the extra mile for her clients to make deals. She is thorough and takes the time to listen, look and think outside the box to make deals happen. We could not have closed a deal without her expertise! She knows all things Sarasota and has been super helpful with our move and getting connected here! I would highly recommend giving Alison a call when buying your next home!

Buyer review
My wife and I had a tremendous experience with Alison.
about 2 years ago
My wife and I had a tremendous experience with Alison.

Well the above review headline tells most of the story. We did not know Alison before our experience with her on the house we purchased and the house that we sold. She had come very highly recommended and she was even better than advertised. Alison was extremely helpful in finalizing the purchase price we paid and the sale price that we received. She was extremely knowledgeable about the market values in both our new neighborhood and our old one. She was always very available for any questions we might have and returned calls or texts almost immediately. She is definitely there for her clients. It was obvious by the seemingly instantaneous replies we got to even the most mundane questions. I could write numerous anecdotes of the extra lengths to which Alison went to help us with both the purchase and sale, but they would get kind of boring. So, for brevities sake let me just finish by repeating myself when I say that Alison was fantastic in every aspect of the real estate agent's job. I can't imagine a better agent and we would recommend her to anyone and everyone. Thanks. Carlisle Peet

Seller review
The Green Acre
over 2 years ago
The Green Acre

Saying goodbye to our childhood home was an emotionally difficult process and Alison was a gift from above to help our family navigate each tough step. An intuitive communicator, Alison patiently waited for our right timing, then swiftly guided us toward every best next move. We were inspired by the unexpected artistry of the experience. Who knew real estate could be such an art form! Alison wisely highlighted our property’s best qualities with effective branding, vivid descriptions, and creative, detail-oriented focus. Our property was owned by four people, so Alison needed to collaboratively support the whole through inevitable problems while getting us to the finish line. Her integrity, real estate knowledge, extensive local network, and experience were of critical necessity to the success of our first offer becoming our best and final. Thanks Alison, for sharing your talents with our crazy crew. We are forever grateful.

Buyer review
Alison is efficient, detail oriented and driven!
over 2 years ago
Alison is efficient, detail oriented and driven!

Alison was delightful to work with! She is efficient, detail oriented and driven! Alison made both buying and selling our homes, stress free. We feel grateful to have had Alison as our realtor!!!

Seller review
Wonderful!
over 2 years ago
Wonderful!

Alison is everything that we could have wanted in a realtor. She is attentive, responsive, and diligent. Alison was in our corner from the very start and always looked out for our best interests. Her confidence and knowledge made the process as smooth as possible. We couldn't have done it without her!

25 - 36 of 82
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent