Alison's profile

Alison's reviews

  5  
Alison has 82 reviewsacross 21 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Alison's qualities as told by our client reviews: dedicated, attentive, great negotiation, detail-oriented, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Amazing Realtor
5 days ago
Amazing Realtor

Alison is an exceptional real estate agent and an amazing person. This was an emotional sale for our family and Alison knew how to communicate in a way that made everyone comfortable and could deal with any question that we threw her way. Her follow up with us and other realtors made this process very pain free. We would highly recommend her to anyone that wants to make a complicated process a smooth one.

Buyer review
We had such a great experience working with Alison Stottlemyer! We were relocating from Chicago, whi
about 1 month ago
We had such a great experience working with Alison Stottlemyer! We were relocating from Chicago, whi

We had such a great experience working with Alison Stottlemyer! We were relocating from Chicago, which can be really stressful, but she made the whole process so much easier. She was incredibly flexible with our schedule and always available when we had questions, even with us being out of state for a lot of it. Alison really listened to what we were looking for and helped us find a home we absolutely love — it's beautiful and exactly what we wanted. She went above and beyond during the inspection and final walkthrough, making sure everything was taken care of and that we felt confident every step of the way. On top of being knowledgeable and on top of every detail, she's just genuinely kind and friendly. It felt like working with a friend who really had our best interests at heart. Our experience was so positive I referred her to my mother and grandmother in their search for a home in Sarasota. We can't recommend her enough!

Buyer review
Alison is amazing
3 months ago
Alison is amazing

We called Alison after seeing a property online. She immediately got to work and not only showed us the one we saw online, but offered several suggestions for other similar properties including the one we ended up purchasing, which hadn’t even hit the market yet. She was very thorough, getting any questions we had answered within hours. The entire process was actually enjoyable and she got us exactly what we wanted for the price we wanted to pay. I would definitely recommend Alison and would use her again in a heartbeat.

Buyer review
11 out of 10 = Alison Stottlemyer
3 months ago
11 out of 10 = Alison Stottlemyer

We have purchased two homes and are in the process of selling another home with Alison. She always goes the extra mile for you. As out of state buyers, this has been really critical for us. Alison follows up on things that you may have forgotten about, has been willing to meet with inspectors and others when we couldn’t be at the home, has prepared all documents professionally and promptly. She offers great suggestions on things that we didn’t even think of. She’s always in touch. She even helped with my garage door, which wouldn’t stay closed. She’s pleasant. She’s kind. She’s very hard-working. Totally recommend Alison.

Buyer review
Uniquely Qualified and Exceptionally Personable
3 months ago
Uniquely Qualified and Exceptionally Personable

Alison is an extremely competent real estate agent. I couldn't be more pleased with my experience working with her. She definitely goes the extra mile and makes things happen that truly impressed me. Alison is also an absolute delight to work with. She's far more polished than the average realtor, yet completely down to earth. In such a competitive industry, excellent customer service, knowledge of the local market and a wonderful and warm personality make all the difference. Alison is also a very impressive person. Ask her about her first career and education when you work with her. I think you'll be impressed, too.

Buyer review
Alison is an extremely competent real estate agent
6 months ago
Alison is an extremely competent real estate agent

Alison is an extremely competent real estate agent. I couldn't be more pleased with my experience working with her. She definitely goes the extra mile and makes things happen that truly impressed me. Alison is also an absolute delight to work with. She's far more polished than the average realtor, yet completely down to earth. In such a competitive industry, excellent customer service, knowledge of the local market and a wonderful and warm personality make all the difference. Alison is also a very impressive person. Ask her about her first career and education when you work with her. I think you'll be impressed too.

Buyer review
Looking for a realtor?
8 months ago
Looking for a realtor?

I want to wholeheartedly recommend Alison Stottlemeyer for your next real estate transaction! If you decide to hire her you will be met with a friendly and approachable personality who makes everyone involved feel comfortable! Alison is an outstanding real estate professional who grew up in the area and is exceptionally knowledgeable about the local market trends, comparable sales & neighborhood insights that helped us make a confident, well-informed decision concerning our new home in Bradenton. We never doubted that she was looking out for us. Whether navigating inspections, negotiations, or the complexities of financing and contracts, she demonstrated expertise and a calm, professional approach that made the entire process smooth and stress-free. Well that last part isn't true. It was extrememly stressful but Alison helped steer the process to a satisfying close despite various land mines. Her presence was critical to us closing on our dream home! So to sum up....If you don't hire Alison Stottlemeyer you will have bypassed someone from whom you would have received dedication, expertise, and genuine care and with it the excellent results you should expect.

Buyer review
An agent with integrity and empathy
8 months ago
An agent with integrity and empathy

Alison is very knowledgeable and professional agent. Alison did a great job working with us evaluating the pros and cons of the properties that we toured. We were under a time pressure and ran into hurdles throughout the process - bad lender, outbid on 2 homes and an arrogant seller’s agent. We ended up in our dream home and I am listening to the waves hit the shore and we are absolutely thrilled. Alison got us here - we highly recommend her services.

Seller review
A Final Sale in Sarasota
8 months ago
A Final Sale in Sarasota

We've had the pleasure of working with Alison to buy or sell six times in Sarasota, which says everything about how much we love her grace, her professionalism, her extensive information base on both the legalities and the neighborhoods, and her incredible optimism. She is the master of the deal but also the master at closing with everything as it should be. She has the patience to wait until you see the home that makes your toes tingle, and the eye to know when an offer can be pushed to a better level. On numerous occasions, she reminded us when to push and when to pull back, when to let go and when to let her work her magic. We highly recommend Alison to anyone who needs a realtor, and in fact have done so several times. We know that her excellence isn't a one-time thing but a lifetime of honing her skills and working with hundreds of clients. We know, with absolute certainty, that she will be as good for you as she was for us. Our realtor relationship is at an end as we move to another state, but our friendship will last for a lifetime. Thank you, Alison.

Seller review
Seamless & Professional: Alison Made Our Home Sale Stress-Free!
8 months ago
Seamless & Professional: Alison Made Our Home Sale Stress-Free!

We recently worked with Alison to sell our home, and we couldn't be happier with the experience. From the initial consultation to the final closing, Alison was professional, proactive, and incredibly knowledgeable about the local market. They handled every detail with precision, making what could have been a stressful process feel completely seamless. If you’re looking for a dedicated professional who gets results, we highly recommend Alison!

1 - 12 of 82
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent