Alison's profile

Alison's reviews

  5  
Alison has 77 reviewsacross 21 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Alison's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, pleasant, great negotiation, detail-oriented, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
A breath of fresh air.
about 4 years ago
A breath of fresh air.

Alison is delightful. She is positive, knowledgeable, and a great communicator. Alison listened to our requests and requirements. She nailed it out of the gate. She found a house we had not seen and it more than checked all the boxes. We made an offer same day and were under contract next day. Wonderful! We just moved in yesterday and are happy and exhausted.

Buyer review
Alison is a top notch realtor
about 4 years ago
Alison is a top notch realtor

Alison is a top notch realtor. Not only does she know the Sarasota market well, but she listens to her clients' needs, is responsive to requests for information, gives good advice, and is quick to offer a helping hand. I found Alison to be a joy to work with, and I recommend her highly.

Buyer review
Alison is Simply the Best!
over 4 years ago
Alison is Simply the Best!

Buying a house with Alison Stottlemeyer alongside as our realtor was seamless! We had been working with Alison for a year as she sent us listings to keep us aware of what was available. When the time was right, we met with her for 2 days as she patiently drove us around showing us multiple houses in Sarasota. This was so helpful for us to get a “lay of the land”. When we found our dream home she made it happen! From contract negotiations to referrals of local contractors, Alison was so professional & helpful. Her bubbly, contagious, caring personality and extreme knowledge of the real estate market in Sarasota was a huge bonus. We can’t recommend Alison enough & feel like we’ve also met a new lifelong friend as she helped us find our Florida dream home.

Seller review
Alison is the rockstar agent you want helping you navigate real estate
over 4 years ago
Alison is the rockstar agent you want helping you navigate real estate

Alison is the rockstar agent you want helping you navigate real estate. Not only is she savvy, attentive, creative and thoughtful, she has high integrity, which she displayed in a couple of ways while we worked with her. She had the challenge of selling our place during the beginning of the pandemic and was one of the first agents in the area to do launch virtual showings to try to create demand, which we very much appreciated. It was such a tough time, so when it became clear we wouldn't get market value, she helped us make the decision to pull it and wait, instead of pushing for us to sell for less. When conditions improved, Alison advised on the right investment areas to make sure we could get top dollar and have a quick close, both of which we accomplished. In between our two times on the market, my father unexpectedly passed. Alison, having recently experienced the same loss, was so incredibly kind, patient and understanding. My mom was anxious to make a real estate move following his passing, and Alison strongly advised she wait at least a year, knowing that was the best decision given the grieving process. You would be remiss in not choosing to have Alison in your corner.

Seller review
Very satisfied with our realtor
over 4 years ago
Very satisfied with our realtor

Of course Alison is a real dynamo and is extremely professional But what really impressed me was her reliability and dependability. She could be counted on to help my husband and myself accomplish all the myriad tasks and complicated coordination that is involved in selling a home and buying a new one. She was spot-on with all her recommendations and numbers. We felt nothing was left undone. Alison was right there with us with referrals for other professionals or to attend a meeting. We knew we were not her biggest client, but she made us feel as if we were.

Seller review
Real dynamo and is extremely professional
over 4 years ago
Real dynamo and is extremely professional

Of course Alison is a real dynamo and is extremely professional But what really impressed me was her reliability and dependability. She could be counted on to help my husband and myself accomplish all the myriad tasks and complicated coordination that is involved in selling a home and buying a new one. She was spot-on with all her recommendations and numbers. We felt nothing was left undone. Alison was right there with us with referrals for other professionals or to attend a meeting. We knew we were not her biggest client, but she made us feel as if we were.

Buyer review
Never knew a realtor could offer SO MUCH
over 4 years ago
Never knew a realtor could offer SO MUCH

(And, my parents and brother were realtors) Alison is so knowledgeable of the market, and the nuances of financing and mortgages. She finds out your needs and looks for ways to please. Through every step in the dificult process of buying one home and selling another, she was our confident guide leading us through it. We know that she genuinely cared about us and it was quite pleasant to see her get just as excited when she is pointing out features she knows we will love. I'm also certain you will have the same experience.

Buyer review
Simply an outstanding real estate agent!
almost 5 years ago
Simply an outstanding real estate agent!

Alison Stottlemyer is simply an outstanding real estate agent!. Her excellence as a realtor is evident in every facet of the home buying and selling process. My wife and I recently sold two properties to purchase our dream home and Alison was paramount to it. From start to finish she was communicative, transparent, prompt and facilitated every in person interaction and subsequent transactions in a most professional and courteous manner. As her clients, she seemingly catered to our every want and need and made the often daunting challenges of buying and selling a home the best of experiences. We could not be happier! We will always recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell property here in Sarasota or anywhere in the Tampa Bay area. Thank you Alison for everything you've done to give us a home we love!

Buyer review
I have no idea what magic she worked, but I’m so grateful to have had her in our corner.
over 5 years ago
I have no idea what magic she worked, but I’m so grateful to have had her in our corner.

My wife and I recently relocated to Sarasota from Chicago with our son. Alison helped us get to know Sarasota, learn the neighborhoods, and had recommendations for everything from the best parks for toddlers to contractors for renovations. She’s a one-stop-shop for relocation because she gets to know you and what you want, then knows exactly where to find it. We are going through an epic market rush at the moment and Alison always made time to squeeze us into “it just popped up!” showings. Alison is personable, friendly, the utmost professional and overall is just an amazing person to work with. When we found our dream house she transformed into a hard-hitting negotiator and landed us awesome deal. I have no idea what magic she worked, but I’m so grateful to have had her in our corner. You could not find a better realtor to work with in the Sarasota area!

49 - 60 of 77
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent