Alison's profile

Alison's reviews

  5  
Alison has 77 reviewsacross 21 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Alison's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, pleasant, great negotiation, detail-oriented, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Alison is a person that cares, and goes way past the "extra mile" for her clients
almost 3 years ago
Alison is a person that cares, and goes way past the "extra mile" for her clients

I have worked with Alison to both purchase and sell home properties in Sarasota. She is a complete professional whom is extremely informed and knowledgeable of all market factors, very responsive, always "there" to answer questions and provide guidance, is excellent at seeing and addressing all the details and next steps in the sale or purchase of a home, and is a very strong negotiator of contract details. I've always felt that Alison has "been in my court" to advantage my position as both a buyer and a seller, and I would highly recommend her as an agent that every client would be very glad they partnered with Alison. Whether it be an early morning or late evening question, Alison has always been available and prepared to answer and address any questions or concerns. I am so very thankful that I have her not only as my agent, but also as a dear friend who is a true professional, but also as a person that cares for, and goes way past the "extra mile" to ensure successful transactions for her clients. Alison is absolutely the very best agent I've ever worked with, and I'm so thankful and fortunate for the very positive experiences I've had working with Alison.

Buyer review
She is a wealth of information and most importantly, she is honest
almost 3 years ago
She is a wealth of information and most importantly, she is honest

My husband’s job brought us to Florida. Having lived in Iowa our whole lives, it was a completely new adventure for us and completely daunting. We knew no one and nothing about the area. Alison took us under her wing, answered all of our questions, really listened to our needs/wants, and drove us all over various towns. Having lived here for years, she is a wealth of information, most importantly, honest and if she didn’t know an answer, responded quickly with an answer! She is so dang efficient and forthcoming with information. I absolutely love her! Alison is involved in her community and is always giving back, just another reason to love her! I can’t recommend her enough for all of your realtor needs!

Seller review
Alison was great to work with
almost 3 years ago
Alison was great to work with

Alison was great to work with. Professional, thorough with marketing skills above average and well versed in all the necessary steps involved. Did we encounter any issues in the process? Yes, as you can imagine when selling a house, however, she was quick to discuss any issues and develop next steps in selling the property. She was a pleasure to work with and we would highly recommend her to anyone interested in selling their house.

Buyer review
From start to finish, Alison's professionalism, expertise, and dedication were truly outstanding
about 3 years ago
From start to finish, Alison's professionalism, expertise, and dedication were truly outstanding

We had the absolute pleasure of working with Alison Stottlemyer, an outstanding realtor who went above and beyond to make our home buying experience smooth and enjoyable. From start to finish, Alison's professionalism, expertise, and dedication were truly outstanding. First and foremost, Alison's knowledge of the local real estate market was unparalleled. She has a deep understanding of the neighborhood we were interested in and provided invaluable insights into the current market trends, pricing, and available properties. Alison's guidance helped us make informed decisions throughout the process. What truly sets Alison apart is her exceptional communication skills. She was always available to answer any questions, address any concerns, and provide regular updates. Her promptness in responding to emails, calls, and texts demonstrated her commitment to keeping us informed every step of the way. Alison's attention to detail is remarkable, taking time to understand our preferences, needs, and budget, and meticulously curating a list of properties that matched our criteria was amazing. Alison also has a keen eye for spotting both the potential and flaws of a property which was invaluable during our house tours. We truly felt that Alison had our best interests at heart, guiding us towards the right home rather than just closing a deal. Finally, Alison's network of professionals, including mortgage brokers, home inspectors, and lawyers, was top-notch. She provided recommendations for reliable and trustworthy service providers, which made the entire home buying process seamless and stress-free. Overall, we cannot recommend Alison highly enough. Her dedication and expertise made a significant impact on our home buying journey. If you're in need of a realtor who will go the extra mile to ensure you find the right home for you and your family, look no further. Alison is simply the best in the business!

Buyer review
I absolutely loved working with Alison
about 3 years ago
I absolutely loved working with Alison

I absolutely loved working with Alison. I was looking for a home long distance and I can certainly say that she went above and beyond to help me in finding the perfect property. I will definitely use her again and recommend her to others as I already have;-)

Buyer review
Alison was very professional and extremely well-prepared
over 3 years ago
Alison was very professional and extremely well-prepared

We recently had the pleasure of working with Alison while looking for a second home in Sarasota. Alison was very professional and extremely well-prepared about each house we chose to preview. Alison was very knowledgeable and very flexible with her schedule to accommodate us, as we were only in town for the weekend and had to make the most of our short time there. She is a Sarasota native and shared valuable insight about Sarasota and the surrounding areas. We would highly recommend Alison for all of your Sarasota real estate needs without hesitation!

Buyer review
Alison has become much more than just my realtor!
over 3 years ago
Alison has become much more than just my realtor!

Alison never hesitates to accomplish any of my requests. She has become much more than just my realtor! Her knowledge of this area is amazing and her professionalism is unparalleled. From selling my Florida home in 2018 to welcoming me back to the area in 2023 and finalizing all the details of my return. I couldn’t have done it without her.

Seller review
I cannot say enough good things about Alison
over 3 years ago
I cannot say enough good things about Alison

I cannot say enough good things about Alison. We worked with her during the sale of our home in summer/fall of 2022. We initially thought our home would sell quickly, but the combination of a changing market and lots of plot twists with buyers made it a more complicated process than we anticipated. Through it all, Alison remained positive and always had solutions. We felt as though we were her only clients, though I am sure she was quite busy with others as well. She always went to bat for us in negotiations and gave us good advice. When the house sold, it was so bittersweet to say goodbye, as we feel we had even made a friend. I would highly recommend her to anyone selling their home in Sarasota!

Buyer review
Alison is an excellent professional patient agent
almost 4 years ago
Alison is an excellent professional patient agent

Alison did an exemplary job. her knowledge of the area was excellent. She managed our ever changing price ideas will aplomb. i highly recommend her, Keith Durocher

Seller review
You won't find a better realtor than Alison. From start to finish, she takes care of every detail.
almost 4 years ago
You won't find a better realtor than Alison. From start to finish, she takes care of every detail.

I needed to sell my home in Bradenton while living a thousand miles away. Alison made it so easy and proactively took on responsibilities well beyond those of an agent. For several months, as the property was made ready for sale, she personally took care of its upkeep and security. She responded quickly to every email and her advice on staging and pricing the property was spot on. It sold very quickly. I could not be happier with the full service provided by Alison and her team. I will recommend her to any friend in the Tampa-Sarasota area. If you need a realtor, give her a shout.

Seller review
You won't find a better Realtor than Alison
almost 4 years ago
You won't find a better Realtor than Alison

You won't find a better realtor than Alison. From start to finish, she takes care of every detail. I needed to sell my home in Bradenton while living a thousand miles away. Alison made it so easy and proactively took on responsibilities well beyond those of an agent. For several months, as the property was made ready for sale, she personally took care of its upkeep and security. She responded quickly to every email and her advice on staging and pricing the property was spot on. It sold very quickly. I could not be happier with the full service provided by Alison and her team. I will recommend her to any friend in the Tampa-Sarasota area. If you need a realtor, give her a shout.

Buyer review
Above & Beyond.....
almost 4 years ago
Above & Beyond.....

The prospect of purchasing a new home in Sarasota while living in CT, was overwhelming. Alison handled all the details that arose, always offering problem resolution, and brilliant negotiating skills with a good sense of humor. She was my "stand in" when I could not be present. Her knowledge of the market and local resources has been invaluable as I begin the relocation process, always with consistent communication! I cannot express how easy Alison has made the entire purchase period, and how grateful I am for her experienced attention to detail, and her support.

37 - 48 of 77
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent