Alison is the best realtor we’ve ever worked with. Her communication is proactive and clear. She’s incredibly responsive, extremely knowledgeable, and if there was ever a question she didn’t immediately have the answer to, she found it quickly and thoroughly for us. She kept everything organized and made the entire transaction feel seamless. Three weeks later, we closed on our dream beach condo — and we truly couldn’t have done it without her.

Alison was so very patient with us as we hadn't been through the process of buying a home in 30 years! She understood what our requirements were and helped us navigate through all of the options on the market. She was very knowledgeable about what was available and, once we found "the one", she walked us through the process, step by step. She was, most certainly, our advocate and helped us get a fair price (for both parties) for our dream retirement home. Her negotiation skills came into play when a leak was found in one of the bathrooms during inspection. She went above and beyond, getting several contractors to get estimates so she could effectively negotiate with the seller for a fair credit. Because we were in another state, Alison would volunteer to video a walkthrough for us anytime we found a place we wanted to see. She always kept us in the loop and communicated often and was always available if we needed to talk to her. We are loving our new place and couldn't have done it without Alison's guidance! We would not hesitate to recommend Alison to others in need of a knowledgeable Real Estate agent in Sarasota or Longboat Key

I have had a number of real estate agents, including a very duplicitous one. Whereas most have been pleasant, they have not been outstanding or remarkable. I am not the sort of individual who brags about anyone who has provided a service for me...with one exception: Alison Stottlemyer is Outstanding!! I have referred her to several friends who have also been equally impressed with her & her abilities in selling their homes & with very good reasons. I have a partner who had never met her. He too now is not only equally impressed with her skills, dedication & attention to the most minute details, that he too is going to have her list his house. She is one in a million & no one who enlists Alison to sell or buy a home, will be very satisfied at how incredibly smooth she makes things flow & lowers the stress level by many, many degrees. And she's an incredible delight deal with, to boot!

Alison is market savvy, super professional, and communicating with her is quick, easy and thorough because she is very personable. She does everything possible to buy and sell. Alison works hard, not letting up even in the frozen housing market of 2025, her marketing ideas are never-ending. Her patience working with a client is impressive and humbling to the client. Alison was recommended to me by another of her clients and I can't thank the other client enough. Alison aims to provide concierge level service, which is lucky for her clients. I highly recommend her. Thank you, Alison

If you want an A-rated interaction when purchasing a home, Alison is my go to. She was thoughtful to my needs and expectations, she was patient when I needed to go back to the same address multiple times. She helped to alleviate any questions or concerns that came up during the entire purchase process. Thank you for how friendly and helpful you were in making this a smooth and exciting process!!

We cannot say enough great things about Alison Stottlemyer — a true super agent in every sense. From the moment we listed, she approached the sale of our home as if it were her own, pouring her heart into every decision and detail. In a difficult market, Alison still managed to get us top dollar — thanks to her strategic mindset, tireless work ethic, and incredible eye for presentation. She was always one step ahead, anticipating every angle before we even had to ask. She personally invested in staging and brought a creative lens that helped our home shine. She coordinated top-tier photography and videography, and used her own voice and vision to craft a compelling story across social media — giving our home the kind of attention that made it stand out. Alison truly goes above and beyond. She doesn’t just list a home — she elevates it. If you’re looking for a dedicated, passionate, and results-driven real estate expert in Sarasota, Alison is the one you want in your corner.

Allison is very professional and knowledgable. She is very kind and was understanding to my situation. Always in contact and kept me updated to every step of the process. Very organized and easy closing.

Alison's goal was to find a house that "makes your toes tingle" - and she achieved that goal for us! She's a very experienced and trustworthy Realtor who provided us with accurate insight and advice throughout the home purchasing process. She was NEVER pushy and was consistently patient as we visited homes. She's delightful to be around and genuinely had our best interests at heart. We were very fortunate to work with her and can't recommend her highly enough.

We cannot say enough great things about Alison Stottlemyer — a true super agent in every sense. From the moment we listed, she approached the sale of our home as if it were her own, pouring her heart into every decision and detail. In a difficult market, Alison still managed to get us top dollar — thanks to her strategic mindset, tireless work ethic, and incredible eye for presentation. She was always one step ahead, anticipating every angle before we even had to ask. She personally invested in staging and brought a creative lens that helped our home shine. She coordinated top-tier photography and videography, and used her own voice and vision to craft a compelling story across social media — giving our home the kind of attention that made it stand out. Alison truly goes above and beyond. She doesn’t just list a home — she elevates it. If you’re looking for a dedicated, passionate, and results-driven real estate expert in Sarasota, Alison is the one you want in your corner.

Alison's goal was to find a house that "makes your toes tingle" - and she absolutely achieved that goal for us! She's exceptional at her job! She's an experienced and trustworthy Realtor who provided us with accurate insight and advice throughout the home purchasing process. She was NEVER pushy and was consistently patient as we visited homes. She's delightful to be around and genuinely had our best interests at heart. We were very fortunate to work with her and can't recommend her highly enough.

Alison Stottlemyer is an extremely knowledgeable and effective realtor. If you are serious about selling your property or buying a new one, don’t mess around with anyone else and hire the best. When watching Alison work, you immediately notice that she pays relentless attention to every detail. You then notice that she has extensive knowledge of every aspect of buying and selling homes and the procedures that will need to be performed. Alison will also connect you to her extensive network of fellow realtors and you can expect that she will find a buyer for you as well as find that perfect new house for you whether it is on the market or not. Her abilities as a negotiator is one more thing that you will appreciate as you work out a top price for your home or a low price for your next home. Allow Alison to make a video for your home and be sure to check out one of her videos to see how amazing she can make your hime look. We had Alison find us our perfect home to buy as well as hired her to sell our home in record time. Within the same week, she had a buyer for our home and found us our perfect home to buy and successfully get an accepted offer by the sellers. Alison knows exactly how to get a home seller top dollar even in a buyer’s market. With her rare combination of industry knowledge, personal attention to every detail, personal care for her clients, her ability to promote your home and make great videos, and her aggressive abilities to work 24/7 on getting you where you need to go, Alison is a very rare talent that you should hire immediately if you are serious about buying or selling a home.

Alison provided the patience and guidance to support a cross-country relocation that was a journey, not a sprint. Timing is key and Alison "brought it" when it came time to close. I appreciate her so much for delivering on many requests for viewings and accommodating our unique needs. She delivered on closing activities with experience and professionalism. Highly recommend for your next relocation!