Alison Stottlemyer

Alison Stottlemyer

REALTOR® / Certified Waterfront Specialist / Global Luxury at COLDWELL BANKER REALTY
NAR: 281526000
  •   5   (80 reviews)

Alison's sales performance at a glance

See how Alison has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

12
Reviews
6
Properties for sale
17
Sold properties
$764k
Average sale price
$16.7m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

  • trustedbadge

    Asks all customers for reviews whether positive or negative which may result in a more representative star rating.

  • priceExpertbadge

    Consistently meets client expectations for property purchase price.

About Alison

Alison Stottlemyer is a Sarasota native who brings her marketing background and love for providing customer service to her role as a top Realtor in the Sarasota area. She attributes much of this success to her first-hand knowledge of the Sarasota lifestyle from the Gulf to the Golf (course), and deep local roots within the community. Whether helping a customer understand depth restrictions within a certain waterway, or sharing which are the best golf clubs and communities, Alison approaches every customer experience with approachable expertise. Prior to becoming a Realtor, Alison Stottlemyer was a Product Developer for Victoria’s Secret (corporate), where she created new fragrance and beauty brands, a job that integrated left-brain scientific and market analysis with right-brained creativity and innovation, all combined with having the skill of working with cross-functional teams and managing people. Her creative and analytical spirit has pivoted seamlessly to the real estate industry, where she works to provide the highest level of professional service and guidance to those considering selling or purchasing a home or condominium. Alison Stottlemyer's background, combined with her in-depth understanding of the Sarasota market, is an incredible asset to her customers. She successfully utilizes both traditional and digital marketing to maximize exposure for sellers, and to provide comprehensive information for buyers. Always staying ahead of real estate trends and keeping on top of market fluctuations, while maintaining a strong business network, give Alison a competitive edge that is invaluable to her customers. Locally, Alison Aidlin Stottlemyer attended Pine View School for the Gifted and Riverview High School before she received her Bachelor's degree at the University of Florida; in Strasbourg, France; and received her Master’s at FIT in New York. In her free time, Alison enjoys spending time with her family, being on the water, catching the latest play, watching live music, and trying to improve her pickleball and golf skills. Go to www.GulfToGolfRealEstate.com for more information and to start your search today!

Social profiles

Alison's reviews

  5  
Alison has 80 reviewsacross 21 different locations, showing 6.
Review Alison
Alison's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, pleasant, great negotiation, detail-oriented, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
We had such a great experience working with Alison Stottlemyer! We were relocating from Chicago, whi
29 days ago
We had such a great experience working with Alison Stottlemyer! We were relocating from Chicago, whi

We had such a great experience working with Alison Stottlemyer! We were relocating from Chicago, which can be really stressful, but she made the whole process so much easier. She was incredibly flexible with our schedule and always available when we had questions, even with us being out of state for a lot of it. Alison really listened to what we were looking for and helped us find a home we absolutely love — it's beautiful and exactly what we wanted. She went above and beyond during the inspection and final walkthrough, making sure everything was taken care of and that we felt confident every step of the way. On top of being knowledgeable and on top of every detail, she's just genuinely kind and friendly. It felt like working with a friend who really had our best interests at heart. Our experience was so positive I referred her to my mother and grandmother in their search for a home in Sarasota. We can't recommend her enough!

Buyer review
Alison is amazing
2 months ago
Alison is amazing

We called Alison after seeing a property online. She immediately got to work and not only showed us the one we saw online, but offered several suggestions for other similar properties including the one we ended up purchasing, which hadn’t even hit the market yet. She was very thorough, getting any questions we had answered within hours. The entire process was actually enjoyable and she got us exactly what we wanted for the price we wanted to pay. I would definitely recommend Alison and would use her again in a heartbeat.

Buyer review
11 out of 10 = Alison Stottlemyer
3 months ago
11 out of 10 = Alison Stottlemyer

We have purchased two homes and are in the process of selling another home with Alison. She always goes the extra mile for you. As out of state buyers, this has been really critical for us. Alison follows up on things that you may have forgotten about, has been willing to meet with inspectors and others when we couldn’t be at the home, has prepared all documents professionally and promptly. She offers great suggestions on things that we didn’t even think of. She’s always in touch. She even helped with my garage door, which wouldn’t stay closed. She’s pleasant. She’s kind. She’s very hard-working. Totally recommend Alison.

Buyer review
Uniquely Qualified and Exceptionally Personable
3 months ago
Uniquely Qualified and Exceptionally Personable

Alison is an extremely competent real estate agent. I couldn't be more pleased with my experience working with her. She definitely goes the extra mile and makes things happen that truly impressed me. Alison is also an absolute delight to work with. She's far more polished than the average realtor, yet completely down to earth. In such a competitive industry, excellent customer service, knowledge of the local market and a wonderful and warm personality make all the difference. Alison is also a very impressive person. Ask her about her first career and education when you work with her. I think you'll be impressed, too.

Buyer review
Alison is an extremely competent real estate agent
5 months ago
Alison is an extremely competent real estate agent

Alison is an extremely competent real estate agent. I couldn't be more pleased with my experience working with her. She definitely goes the extra mile and makes things happen that truly impressed me. Alison is also an absolute delight to work with. She's far more polished than the average realtor, yet completely down to earth. In such a competitive industry, excellent customer service, knowledge of the local market and a wonderful and warm personality make all the difference. Alison is also a very impressive person. Ask her about her first career and education when you work with her. I think you'll be impressed too.

Show all 80 reviews
map

Alison's properties

Alison has 6 properties for sale and sold 17 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldNov 2, 2026
$678,000
7818 Troon Court
Bradenton FL 34202
2
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY and COLDWELL BANKER REALTY
SoldOct 28, 2026
$490,000
3911 77th Place East
Sarasota FL 34243
4
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER REALTY and PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY
For Sale
$958,000
9113 Luna Lane
Sarasota FL 34241
4
4
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER REALTY
SoldOct 15, 2026
$665,000
264 Woods Point Road
Osprey FL 34229
3
3
2
Condo
Listing courtesy of MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY and COLDWELL BANKER REALTY
Show all 23 properties

Alison's sold properties

Alison has sold 17 properties in the past 12 months, showing 4.

Enter your property details to filter

I'm selling a
bedroom
with
bathrooms in
Property imageAddressBedroomsBathroomsCarparksProperty TypeClosing PriceDate Sold
7818 Troon Court, Bradenton, FL, 34202
7818 Troon Court
Bradenton FL 34202
2
2
2
Single-Family$678,000Nov 2, 2026
3911 77th Place East, Sarasota, FL, 34243
3911 77th Place East
Sarasota FL 34243
4
2
2
Single-Family$490,000Oct 28, 2026
264 Woods Point Road, Osprey, FL, 34229
264 Woods Point Road
Osprey FL 34229
3
3
2
Condo$665,000Oct 15, 2026
10192 Milky Way Circle, Sarasota, FL, 34241
10192 Milky Way Circle
Sarasota FL 34241
5
5
3
Single-Family$1,170,000Aug 18, 2026

Browse nearby locations

SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent