From 36 reviews overall

Bruce Myer
Coldwell Banker Realty - Longboat Key

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Longboat Key
City Winner
ratemyagent award
Longboat Key2026From 20 reviews overall

Erica Smentowski
KELLER WILLIAMS ON THE WATER S

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Longboat Key
72 Twin Shores Boulevard Longboat Key
Erica represented me on a for-sale-by-owner purchase and was incredibly thorough from start to finish. The sellers had a strong emotional bond with the property and were reluctant to sell due to the family memories connected to this property. She kept every detail organized and ensured the deal was solid and ready for closing. The property was a post-hurricane renovation from the 2024 storms and located in a co-op, which added extra layers of complexity. Erica anticipated those challenges, connected us with a title company equipped to handle a co-op closing properly, and guided the process all the way through to a successful close.
61 Twin Shores Boulevard Longboat Key
Erica helped me purchase a storm-damaged unit and expertly guided me through the complexities of the process. She made sure the transaction was advantageous for me as a buyer while also being thoughtful and fair to the seller, who was navigating a difficult situation after the storms. Erica also walked me through the city’s rebuilding requirements, ensuring I was well informed and set up for the best possible outcome with my renovation. I highly recommend her.
From 94 reviews overall

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy - The Gillen McHardy Group
Coldwell Banker Global Luxury

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Longboat Key
206/4600 Gulf of Mexico Drive Longboat Key
Let me start by saying I come from a family of realtors in another state. Like any profession there are those that excel at what they do and the GILLEN/McHardy Group is one that outshines others. They all bring strong skill sets but their inherent traits are integrity and insightfulness which were most evident during negotiations. I appreciated their patience during the selling process and then purchase of my new home. Their resolve made it happen and for that, I am so grateful. Thank you!
5382 Sandhamn Place Longboat Key
Having worked with Brian and Eileen in the past (and being VERY satisfied with the experience), it was a pleasure to be introduced to Debbie and work with her as well this time around. The team knew exactly what we were looking for and remained patient with us, as we waited for the perfect property to become available. Once that was found, they managed the process with the utmost attention and provided us with excellent guidance. Needless to say, purchasing a new home is an extremely stressful situation but having the Gillen/McHardy Group by our side was instrumental in getting us through it!
202/4600 Gulf of Mexico Dr Longboat Key
Brian and Eileen did an amazing job selling our condo in Florida. We currently live out of state and they were very knowledgeable and professional from start to finish in handling the sale of our property. They were constantly in communication with us and worked diligently to market our property with multiple showings. I would highly recommend them to anyone looking for an agent!
From 18 reviews overall

Kathleen Magnus
FLORIDA GALLERY REAL ESTATE

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Longboat Key
202/3540 Gulf of Mexico Drive Longboat Key
We met Kathy through a friend. We started looking at properties on a Wednesday and found “the one” by Friday. She was able to answer many questions and if she didn’t know she was able to find the answer for us. She was available at any time through out the purchasing process. She is very knowledgeable about properties in the area and very easy to work with. We would highly recommend her to anyone looking for property in the area.