Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
577 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
over 2 years ago
Exceptional

Pleasant and always available when I needed her. Promptly responded to all aspects of the transaction. Return customer. Thx

Cusie Garcia Urgelles

Cusie Garcia Urgelles

  5   (7 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Above & Beyond

We had the pleasure of working with Andy Scherer throughout our recent home-buying experience in Sarasota. Andy was professional, knowledgeable, and showed a genuine care for us, taking the time to understand our preferences and needs. What set Andy apart was his dedication to our satisfaction. He was always available to answer our questions, address any concerns, and provide reassurance during moments of uncertainty. His responsiveness and attention to detail made us feel supported and empowered throughout our decision-making process. We are grateful for Andy’s expertise, professionalism, and commitment to helping us with our recent purchase. We found Andy to be extremely personable, warm, caring, and fun to work with. We have no reservations in highly recommending Andy to anyone in search of a reliable, trustworthy, and dedicated real estate partner.

Andy Scherer

Andy Scherer

  5   (32 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Deb was nothing short of knowledgeable and professional when it came to helping us find our new home

Deb was nothing short of knowledgeable and professional when it came to helping us find our new home. She went above and beyond to meet our requests throughout the process, answered calls promptly, and always kept us in the loop. This was very reassuring as we were working with her out of state. I would highly recommend Deb for your house hunting needs and wouldn't hesitate to use her in the future.

Deb Petritsch

Deb Petritsch

  5   (55 reviews)
over 2 years ago
The Quintessential Professional

Andrew is on top of his game. He knows the market and helped move a vacant lot quickly. I am confident that he will move two more properties in the near future. I am sold with, Andrew.

Andrew Martell

Andrew Martell

  5   (42 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Excellence every step of process.

Professional, caring, knowledgeable about market and area, patience…these are just a few of the many qualities of Rania Dargham. I would recommend her without reservation or hesitation.

Rania Dargham

Rania Dargham

  5   (15 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Andy Scherer stands above all others!

Wow! What a ride this sale was with Andy Scherer! In short, it would not have been possible without his experience and expertise. We first met Andy in 2016 when he supported us with a buy/sell transaction. That experience was so smooth that he was our obvious first choice when we decided to buy/sell again. Andy listed our home and within 10 days we had 8 showings and 2 offers. A primary and a back up! Both offers were 98% of ask as well. Less than 1 month to close and we lost our primary buyer! With a significant deposit put on a new build, we were very tense to say the least. Andy sprung into action with the back up offer that had expired. The backup buyers were moving on another property but due to Andys experience in real estate transactions, he was pivotal in re-engaging the buyers agent and buyers and after a tense 24 hours, negotiating a new contract for the sale of our home. By the numbers; 1 listing, 8 showings in 10 days and 2 near full price offers. 45 days later a successful settlement on the sale of our home. If you are looking to sell your home and want the benefit of comfort from partnering with a true expert in real estate, look no further than Andy Scherer. Oh, and he is also a super nice guy.

Andy Scherer

Andy Scherer

  5   (32 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Professional

Andrew and Iris were always available to answer our questions and give detailed information about all of the properties that we looked at. When we found the property we wanted they walked us through the whole process from start to finish. They were completely professional.

Andrew Martell

Andrew Martell

  5   (42 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Best in class

My husband and I have had the pleasure of working with Andy over the last ten years. Andy has helped us buy and sell multiple properties over the years and has become someone we can call a friend. Our latest purchase was so easy to find and every aspect of the purchase was seamless. Andy is not only an excellent communicator but his expert level knowledge of the buying and selling process helped us navigate what could have been a difficult transaction. Andy has always supported us in the most professional manner and has guided us well beyond the call of duty. Without Andy, I’m not sure we would have been able to achieve what we did. We are beyond thankful for his support and highly recommend him.

Andy Scherer

Andy Scherer

  5   (32 reviews)
over 2 years ago
TOP NOTCH!

We believe that buying a home for retirement is as important as buying your first home. We have worked hard for the money that we are now putting into what will be our forever home. The research in the area where we will live out our lives was of the utmost importance. Deb took all the stress out of the buying process. Deb listened to what we wanted and went to work to find the perfect location. She works 24-7, tirelessly and you can tell Real Estate is her passion and helping buyers and sellers is her calling! We were purchasing a home out of state and a new build as well. Deb was involved every step of the new build process and was our eyes and ears in our absence. We inundated her with questions and concerns for months during each phase of the building stage. She was with us through the almost 2 year process, so trust me when I tell you that she works for her clients! We do not recommend just anyone and we cannot recommend her enough!!

Deb Petritsch

Deb Petritsch

  5   (55 reviews)
over 2 years ago
What an experience!!!!!!

Debra wasn’t just a professional; she felt like a trusted friend throughout my home-buying journey. Her genuine care, attention to detail, and unwavering support made the process not only successful but also enjoyable. I couldn’t have asked for a better partner in finding my dream home. Five stars without a doubt!

Deb Petritsch

Deb Petritsch

  5   (55 reviews)
217 - 228 of 577
KELLER WILLIAMS ON THE WATER S
Contact KELLER WILLIAMS ON THE WATER S
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent