Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
577 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
about 2 years ago
Andrew Is The Best

My wife and I used Andrew to purchase a second home in SWFL. He was funny, kind, and professional. He knows people and knows real estate. We couldn't recommend him and his team enough. I have used many agents through the years and there is no doubt that Andrew soars above the rest. Thank you Andrew for helping us get the right deal at the right time. We appreciate you, sir!

Andrew M Pepper

Andrew M Pepper

  5   (21 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Excellent experience

We interviewed several realtors and Andrew stood out, especially based on the number of houses sold in the last few years and his knowledge of the market. Once hired, Andrew was able to get the house listed within just a couple of days, and less than a week later we had a cash offer for just under asking price. His advice on price was spot on, he told us up front what to expect and then met those expectations, and he was very responsive and respectful throughout the process. His help was also invaluable working through the results of the inspection and resolving the related issues. In short, if I had another house to sell, I would hire him again.

Andrew M Pepper

Andrew M Pepper

  5   (21 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Experience and knowledgeable

Very easy to work with and continues to stay in touch after closing. Andrew had a good understanding of the market and helped us select the right area that made the most sense for our family.

Andrew M Pepper

Andrew M Pepper

  5   (21 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Andrew gets it done!!

Andrew is hands down the agent you want on your side. He went above and beyond to make my out of state move a success!

Andrew M Pepper

Andrew M Pepper

  5   (21 reviews)
about 2 years ago
BEST SERVICE EVER!

We are from Ohio and have never required the assistance of a Real Estate Agent in Florida. Consequently, we needed to use the internet to search for an agent. We did review Andrew Martell's qualifications immediately. After reviewing the experience of several others, we chose to contact Andrew. We set up a meeting and from that one-time interview, Andrew took the lead. He advised us on the listing price and how to show the property. Once the property was on the MLS, prospective buyers started to line up. Thanks to Andrew, we had several qualified buyers and the property sold within a week. But that is not all, the buyers are from Indiana and all of the details were finished via telephone and emails. From start to finish, everything went without a hitch. We are pleased to have worked with a quality, well informed and highly professional agent in Andrew Martell.

Andrew Martell

Andrew Martell

  5   (42 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Exceptional Results!

Andrew is a very knowledgeable and professional agent. He was a pleasure to work with.

Andrew Martell

Andrew Martell

  5   (42 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Outstanding Ageny

We had an amazing experience working with Celine when purchasing our home in Florida this past week. As “out of towners,” Celine set up weekly updates, pictures, and videos of the progress being made on the new build. She was so personable and thorough that we felt confident in purchasing this new home from afar. Celine worked with the builder all along the way concentrated on small details that are often overlooked. She really made our experience a breeze. I would highly recommend Celine to anyone looking for a home to purchase. She is not only knowledgeable in what she does, but extremely efficient and professional. Thanks again Celine!!!

Celine Charleson

Celine Charleson

  5   (34 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Outstanding Agent

I can’t say enough about Andrew. He went above and beyond for us, as we were still in Indiana. He has even offered his assistance any time.

Andrew Martell

Andrew Martell

  5   (42 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Consistent

He did a great job on staying on tasks follow up’s and driving results.

Jessica Bell

Jessica Bell

  4.8   (16 reviews)
about 2 years ago
The Most Knowledgeable, Dedicated, and Trusted Agent We Have Ever Worked With!

Our experience with Andy Scherer was truly exceptional. Our two-year new-construction journey began with Andy helping us to find exactly the right community to match our interests and ended with our great satisfaction, two years later (due to some construction challenges along the way.) His knowledge of the Sarasota area guided our search, saved us a great deal of time, helped us make an informed decision, and placed us in exactly the right location for us. Despite the extended time that it took to complete the construction and transaction, Andy remained enthusiastic and dedicated to the success of our project. Andy was always very responsive, eagerly acted on our behalf numerous times, and skillfully and tactfully provided excellent advice and counsel. He closely monitored the construction process (applying his extensive new construction experience) since we were coming from out-of-state, and conscientiously worked with us and the developer to make sure that our new home was delivered in excellent condition and that we had the best experience possible. His tact, demeanor, and professionalism set him apart from any agent we have ever worked with. Without any hesitation, we will immediately call on him again when we need an agent in the area!

Andy Scherer

Andy Scherer

  5   (32 reviews)
over 2 years ago
The Absolute Best in the Business

Hard to put into a few sentences the gratitude and appreciate my wife and I have for Andy. We've now completed 3 home purchases with him and it seems to get easier every time. His market knowledge, resources and even keeled professionalism makes the home buying process a breeze and you would be hard pressed to find someone more dedicated and attentive than Andy. Whether you are looking for your first-home or an investment property, Andy is there throughout every step of the process and is more of a partner than just a real estate agent. He has always had our best interests at the forefront of his work and it's apparent to anyone that does business with him that he has put in the time, effort and care to be the absolute best at what he does. For as long as Andy is in the business, we will never look elsewhere. Thank you

Andy Scherer

Andy Scherer

  5   (32 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Celine Charleson is the definition of a go-getter! Since the moment we began working together, we fe

Celine Charleson is the definition of a go-getter! Since the moment we began working together, we felt at ease. Celine has a way of making you feel like more than just a client. She has made the entire home buying process stress free. She was on top of any issues arising with builders, and didn't rest until everything had been addressed. Celine regularly checked up on our home for us, keeping us updated on changes. She ensured sales office was in touch as well. If we were to do this process all over, there is no doubt in my mind Celine would be the first person we'd call. I already have family waiting to get her number once they move down to Florida! An awesome experience through and through - I can't recommend her enough

Celine Charleson

Celine Charleson

  5   (34 reviews)
193 - 204 of 577
KELLER WILLIAMS ON THE WATER S
Contact KELLER WILLIAMS ON THE WATER S
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent