From 76 reviews overall

Melissa Connell

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Sumter County
4773 Southwest 47th Boulevard Bushnell
We have worked with Melissa for many sale of many properties now and she never disappoints. She will fight for you and go to bat when needed all to make sure she gets you the best deal. You won’t regret choosing her for your realtor!
City Winner
ratemyagent award
Plant City2026From 7 reviews overall

Pauline Crain
Keller Williams of Port St Lucie

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Sumter County
1561 Loris Loop The Villages
Our experience in purchasing our home in The Villages , with Pauline’s professional leadership , through the closing of escrow was seamless. Her followup after the closing of escrow has become personal as well as professional and we would recommend her to anyone seeking to buy or sell a home.
76/2469 Morven Park Way The Villages
As a first time home buyer I couldn’t have asked for a more knowledgeable, Honest and Professional agent. Pauline was always right there for any questions or concerns. It has been a pleasure working with her. Highly recommended Thank you Pauline for going above and beyond !
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Sumter County
12160 NE 51st Cir Sumter County
I live in Ohio and was buying this house in Florida. They were on top of every little detail and handled it such as finding information on warranties, looking at every detail of the inspection and either finding the information or getting in touch with the other realtor so she could get the information. Anything I needed to do from long distance they made sure I knew about it and helped me through it. I could go on and on but they are amazing besides being such nice people. They really went above and beyond what I expected. Thank you.
From 115 reviews overall

Jaylene Sheldon
RE/MAX PREMIER REALTY LADY LK

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Sumter County
1913 Augustine Drive The Villages
Made It Happen !!! Going far and wide to get the traffic at our Open House showings. VERY PUNCTUAL at all our meetings. What a professional!!! Working day and night with the Buyers and we, The Sellers. Not just a Realty Agent...But a Friend Always.
5549 Millican Avenue Wildwood
From the beginning I felt like I was in good hands. Once we identified what we were looking for she was great about getting us listing that matched. We were extremely picky and she stayed patient throughout the 4 months it took to find the perfect house for us. She was able to answer all of our questions and did a great job of helping make sure we made a good decision. She was very helpful in negotiating the price and handheld us through the closing. Jaylene will be the agent I use anytime I have real estate needs.