From 68 reviews overall

Chad Beasley
Chad and Jen Beasley - eXp Realty

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Shelby County
495 Oxford Way Pelham
Chad and Jen are very attentive and communication was excellent. Their knowledge of the real estate market and strategies to advertise property is state of the art. They are successful and impressive!!
229 Chesser Loop Road Chelsea
We reached out to Chad and Jen Beasley after speaking with a few other agents as we were looking for a partner to walk with us through the process of selling an inherited property. After meeting with them, we knew they would be our teammates for the process. They were professional and honest through the entire process. It had been over 20 years since we had a real estate transaction; Chad and Jen were there with us for each step. The communication was strong and concise and we knew what was happening in every step. We will not hesitate to use them on our next real estate transaction.
1207 Highland Lakes Trail Highland Lakes
Chad and Jen were great to work with. Their market knowledge and suggestions were very valuable, but the most valuable service they provided was their availability to answer even the most off the wall questions we asked at the most inconvenient times! Selling a home during the last two weeks of the year resulted in a lot of angst but they were able to reassure us and make the sale in a short period of time. Their input on pricing and negotiating was very helpful. They did an excellent job of advising us on which things needed to be done to the house and which things would not add value. We have bought and sold six homes over 40 years and Chad and Jen were the best agents we have worked with by far!
County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Shelby County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Chelsea2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Pelham2026From 118 reviews overall

Susan Lehman
Team Lehman Realty LLC

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Shelby County
1098 Emerald Ridge Drive Calera
Susan was a dream to work with. Her knowledge of the real estate market is second to none. She puts in the work and the results follow. Our home was under contract in just four days and for full asking price. Susan is an excellent communicator who truly cares about her clients. She has our strongest recommendation. If you want the best, just call Susan Lehman. You’ll be happy you did. Robert & Vonda Magill
166 Cedar Grove Pkwy Alabaster
Susan just helped us sell our home and we had a great experience working with her. She was very professional and gave us excellent pre-listing advice that helped us position the home well before listing. Her knowledge of the local market gave us confidence in the pricing and overall strategy, and communication was always clear and timely. I would definitely recommend her and her team to anyone looking to buy or sell.
1251 Hedgerow Drive Montevallo
I just had the greatest experience in helping to sell my neighbor’s house with Susan Lehman at Team Lehman Realty. Susan made everything easy and fun! Be sure and think about her for your real estate needs.
County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Shelby County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Alabaster2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Montevallo2026From 97 reviews overall

Penny Miller
RE/MAX Advantage South

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Shelby County
246 North River Drive Shelby
To sell my home on beautiful Lay Lake after the death of my husband of 53 years was the most heart wrenching decision. Penny jumped right in and handled everything with patience, humor, compassion, understanding, a lot of much needed hand holding, guidance and advise. As a result, the house sold in 3 days for full asking price and closed in 4 weeks. With that same energy, she helped me find a perfect home mere blocks from my son and daughter-in-law. Both houses closed and I was able to move from one house to the next on the same day. She was God sent and I will always, always be grateful for her.
1008 Ashley Brook Lane Helena
We have used Penny for both buying and selling during different times. Recently we were the purchaser. Penny will always make you feel like you are her first priority. When actually she is a great juggler. She hears what you are saying and attends to your wants. She will jump through hoops to make it happen for you. I am happy to call her my friend and realtor! She will always be our first choice in a realtor. There are good realtors and there are GREAT realtors and Penny is the BEST of the BEST.
3438 Indian Lake Drive Pelham
Penny did a masterful job. She was very professional and thorough and followed up on every detail at every point in the process. Her experience and market knowledge was obvious from the outset, and she quickly became our trusted adviser. The preparation she put in to marketing our house and how she presented it online was extremely impressive, including professional photography and aerial video footage. She did an excellent job in designing the sale process, scheduling and managing many dozens of showings within a short time, and generating multiple offers that were at or above our expectations. She is a dealmaker, the best I’ve worked with.
County Winner
ratemyagent award
Shelby County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Shelby2026From 21 reviews overall

Brooke Handley
EXIT Realty Cahaba
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Shelby County
424 Acer Trail Alabaster
Brooke is the best real estate agent I have ever dealt with - bar none. She stayed out front of our needs, communicated throughout the process and went above and beyond her call of duty. Overall wonderful experience. Thank you Brooke!