

Andrea K Mace
REALTOR®
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 35605 9th Street, Nehalem
Andrea was professional from beginning to end of our search for a coastal home. She was extremely knowledgeable of all the coastal towns, their pro’s and con’s, and fair market values. Most importantly, she was reliable and there was never any pressure or sales-y feeling to her approach. We would recommend Andrea to anyone searching for a home along the Oregon coast!
Seller of 12785 B St, Nehalem
Andrea listed and sold my house in Nehalem. She kept me well informed throughout the process. The first offer did not result in a sale. This was not because of anything that Andrea did, but because the FHA appraiser did not submit a report. The second offer came quickly after we placed the house back on the market. She had a very helpful network of resources, e.g., repair people from whom to get estimates, engineering reports, etc. I also appreciated the fact that she got a second opinion when we were trying to decide on a selling price. Since the house needed fairly extensive repairs, it was difficult to use other comps in the area. I would highly recommend Andrea to anyone who wishes to sell a house in the Nehalem area.
County Winner
Tillamook County2026

Hilary Herman
Licensed Real Estate Agent
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 12/13150 D Street, Nehalem
Anytime we had a question, Hilary answered right away. She is extreamely thorough and knows a great amount of details pertaining to the area as well. We are first time buyers, so having Hilary walk us step by step was invaluable. She made us comfortable all along the way and explained the process and all details in a way that was clear for us to understand. When issues came to light she helped us get them straightened out and moving forward. We met all our deadlines and moved in when we planned to. Hilary was incredible in every step of the process and unbelievably easy to work with. I doubt we could have gotten this house without her.
Buyer of 13005 I Street, Nehalem
Hilary is amazing! She was always looking out for our family and making sure that any house we looked at fit all our needs. She is outstanding with communication and checking in on us. She went above and beyond to make sure we were taken care of. Her knowledge of options for mortgages and the market around the area is unmatched. We were so delighted to work with her, and if we have any needs in the future, we will be calling her first! She will be our top recommendation for anybody looking in the area for housing. She is very patient and kind which was so needed during a huge move, which is always a bit stressful and she made it as smooth as possible!
State Top 10
Oregon2026County Winner
Clatsop County2026City Winner
Astoria2026City Winner
Seaside2026City Winner
Warrenton2026

Jim Gestautas
Licensed Real Estate Agent | REALTOR® | Broker
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Seller of 26440 Miami River Road, Nehalem
Being we were novices at selling property we needed an agent that we could trust, knew the ropes and would listen to our concerns/desires with an open mind. Jim met and exceeded our expectations for those qualities more. His expertise brought forth questions, that we hadn't even considered to our attention, which we were then able to address. He did this all without being pushy or impatient. We would trust Jim again, in a heartbeat and are grateful for his kind help.
Buyer of 9370 Sandpiper Lane, Nehalem
Working with Jim was a pleasure from start to finish. He is very personable and knowledgable, but was never pushy, allowing us to take our time before submitting our offer. Most importantly though, we had our offer accepted on a great property where there were multiple other offers in play. I believe this partially to be due to his strong negotiation skills when working with the seller's broker. I really enjoyed getting to know Jim during this process and hope to remain in contact in the future. Thanks for everything Jim!
Buyer of 9370 Sandpiper Lane, Nehalem
Jim Gestautas is amazing- five stars are not enough! My husband and I had been looking along the coast for months for a vacation home. When a house we liked came on the market we were excited but our realtor was out town. Our realtor connected us with Jim in their absence and I am so glad they did. Jim is extremely attentive, has amazing follow through, attention to detail and knowledge. He was one step ahead of process at all times, so nothing every felt overwhelming. He attended every inspection even when we couldn't and was always on hand with great recommendations or observations. I honestly feel we got the house because he was so engaged with the sellers agent and helped guide us correctly. We have purchased more than a few houses in our lives and his representation was the best. I highly recommend using Jim for your home purchase!
Pop in your address and we'll show you local sales, agent performance, and what buyers are paying nearby.


Kenna Maltman Walker
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here