Colleen's profile

Colleen's reviews

  5  
Colleen has 101 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Colleen's qualities as told by our client reviews: trustworthy, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Colleen helped us with the purchase of our second home in OIB
over 2 years ago
Colleen helped us with the purchase of our second home in OIB

Colleen helped us with the purchase of our second home in OIB. She was knowledgeable about new developments and the community. When we finally did settle in on a home, it was reassuring to know she checked in with the builder and addressed our concerns since we could. It be here on a daily basis. Highly recommend Colleen.

Buyer review
Colleen came highly recommended  by long-time friends who had used her with their relocation from Ne
over 2 years ago
Colleen came highly recommended by long-time friends who had used her with their relocation from Ne

Colleen came highly recommended by long-time friends who had used her with their relocation from New York to Ocean isle Beach. As soon as we reached out to Colleen, she got right back to us and the phone calls, texts and emails began. She really listened to what we were looking for and asked great questions! She was so knowledgeable about the area and extremely familiar with all of the communities we wanted to explore. We had a very limited amount of time during our visit and within the first day, Colleen found us our “Dream” Home. She took us through the offer process, recommended excellent local lawyers and insurance brokers, assisted with the inspection and we closed in less than a month. After we closed, Colleen kept in touch and recommended local service providers to help us with anything we needed. Colleen made an extremely important and stressful process efficient, easy and fun! She goes above and beyond in all she does. We highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a house in Brunswick County. Barbara and Gary Van Bergen

Buyer review
We can honestly say that we were thrilled to work with Colleen
almost 3 years ago
We can honestly say that we were thrilled to work with Colleen

We can honestly say that we were thrilled to work with Colleen. We wanted to move from Cincinnati, Ohio but we were not sure where. We came upon a house in Sunset Beach NC and decided to take a drive down to see it. Not knowing anything about the area nor knowing anyone down here, it was such a pleasure to speak with Colleen. We immediately felt very comfortable, and she made us feel very welcomed, willing to share her time with us. Colleen was always there, a text and a phone call away. She even went out of her way to take care of a few things that she clearly did not have to do and she continues to keep in contact with us making sure we are taken care of.

Seller review
Colleen Teifer represented us at the seller's agent in the sale of our Calabash Lakes, Carolina Shor
almost 3 years ago
Colleen Teifer represented us at the seller's agent in the sale of our Calabash Lakes, Carolina Shor

Colleen Teifer represented us at the seller's agent in the sale of our Calabash Lakes, Carolina Shores home. Her knowledge on many levels - national, regional and local - is without a doubt A++. Her coaching, observations of the property, patience with market trends, and communication across the board were all demonstrated consistently throughout the sales process. Colleen is highly invested in a positive customer experience. Colleen listens, offers logical options to resolving issues or questions, is honest and open, and is always timely in her responses when contacted. She is eager to understand the customers' perspectives and goals from the outset and as the process evolves. Colleen is a true partner in the relationship and in every transactional activity from beginning to the end. We met our goals in a real estate environment that requires quality, professional attention and flexibility. We are thankful that Colleen was our partner, and that she came into our lives at just the right moment in time!

Buyer review
Colleen was invaluable in my home search! Her knowledge, professionalism, and tenacity helped me fin
about 3 years ago
Colleen was invaluable in my home search! Her knowledge, professionalism, and tenacity helped me fin

Colleen was invaluable in my home search! Her knowledge, professionalism, and tenacity helped me find the perfect home. There is no question too small or problem too large that she isn't there with answers and references to aid in both the buying and settling in processes. Having a realtor that truly cares about you and your search is priceless and Colleen proved that to me at every turn. I couldn't imagine working with anyone else!

Seller review
Colleen was great to work with on the sale of our lot
about 3 years ago
Colleen was great to work with on the sale of our lot

Colleen was great to work with on the sale of our lot. She was always available to answer our questions and did a great job negotiating the sale for us. We’ve had the pleasure of working with her before this and we will be sure to contact her for any future real estate needs.

Seller review
Colleen handled all aspects of my condo sale in Little River
about 3 years ago
Colleen handled all aspects of my condo sale in Little River

Colleen handled all aspects of my condo sale in Little River. I believe her expertise was instrumental in getting offers above our asking price. She was so helpful in our sale, I asked her to represent me in a purchase in Sunset Beach. What had been a bit of a rocky, unsettled rode, quickly proceeded until the purchase was completed.

Buyer review
Colleen is amazing!  She has a thorough knowledge of all the surrounding areas, and a comprehensive
over 3 years ago
Colleen is amazing! She has a thorough knowledge of all the surrounding areas, and a comprehensive

Colleen is amazing! She has a thorough knowledge of all the surrounding areas, and a comprehensive knowledge of each builder and their respective communities. She pays great attention to every detail of the build and the community. She asked all the right questions to ensure that we were comfortable with our decisions in the purchase and build of our home, that we had an in-depth understanding of the process, and that we were satisfied and happy. She was present at closing and assisted us with following through on all the necessary paperwork, including connecting with all the utility companies. If we had a question or concern, we could contact her any time, any day. Even on a holiday! She responded almost immediately and helped to resolve the issue and answered questions to our satisfaction. We felt greatly supported. She told us that she would be there for us every step of the way and she was. We had not one worry. My husband and I have built 4 homes together, and never have we worked with someone so dedicated to her profession. She is the best!!

Buyer review
My husband , Jeff, and I were introduced to Colleen via a friend, whom she also helped find their ne
over 3 years ago
My husband , Jeff, and I were introduced to Colleen via a friend, whom she also helped find their ne

My husband , Jeff, and I were introduced to Colleen via a friend, whom she also helped find their new home. From the beginning Colleen patiently listened to our needs and wants for a home in the Sunset Beach area. She was very professional, yet listened as a friend would, confirming what we said, answering questions, and making us feel at ease with this big step we were taking. We began emailing and she would check in with us and communicate at our comfort level. She never tried to talk us into or out of anything, and when she showed us our home and we knew it was “the one” Colleen facilitated the sale efficiently and went above and beyond to help us with places to shop, a painter who was able to paint right away, and a mortgage broker. We would highly recommend Colleen to help anyone fill any of their real estate needs!

Seller review
From the time of our initial contact with Colleen until closing the entire process worked like a wel
over 3 years ago
From the time of our initial contact with Colleen until closing the entire process worked like a wel

From the time of our initial contact with Colleen until closing the entire process worked like a well oiled machine. Her professionalism and upbeat personality gave us confidence in her ability and she proved us correct in our belief we had chosen the right realtor. Colleen kept us informed and was always quick to respond to any of our questions. We have commented many times since our experience with Colleen what a pleasure it was and how fortunate we were to have her sell our home.

61 - 72 of 101
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent