Colleen's profile

Colleen's reviews

  5  
Colleen has 121 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Colleen's qualities as told by our client reviews: trustworthy, detail-oriented, dedicated, clear communication, well-prepared, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Knowledgeable and Professional Real Estate Agent
3 days ago
Knowledgeable and Professional Real Estate Agent

We interviewed three candidates to help sell and market our home. Colleen arrived at our meeting very well prepared on the current market conditions, the general area and, in particular, our neighborhood. Colleen's professionalism and plan to sell gave us a roadmap to successfully sell our house. She is personable, responsive and knowledgeable. Our house sold in 4 days. She was on top of the entire process. We couldn't recommend Colleen highly enough to either buy or sell a home.

Buyer review
Colleen made our beach home dream come true!
3 days ago
Colleen made our beach home dream come true!

Colleen provided us a fantastic experience in finding our dream home in Sunset Beach, NC. Her skill at listening carefully and determining what we were looking for, her deep experience in the market, and her enthusiastic support at every step really made her outstanding. Colleen’s demonstrated knowledge of the area and the characteristics of each of its communities pointed us in the right direction. During our first call with her, she guided us through a series of questions that led her to make some concrete recommendations and focused our search on places that would best fit what we were looking for. When we walked into a model home, we knew instantly it had all the characteristics that we wanted. Throughout the process, Colleen’s responsive support and guidance were immensely helpful, especially since we were living several hours away from the area. As soon as we returned home from our first trip, she visited properties in our desired community and sent us information, photos, and her take on them. This level of responsiveness was invaluable, as we did not have time to do so on our first trip. The depth and speed of her follow-ups allowed us to make another quick trip to the area, where she took us through the most promising properties. The process went very fast for us, with Colleen helping us to make an offer and get on contract that same day. She walked us through the entire process of the purchase and setting up utilities until we were settled in our new home. We are so thankful that someone recommended Colleen to us, and we highly recommend her to anyone who is looking to purchase their dream property in the coastal Brunswick County area.

Buyer review
Colleen has a excellent way of understanding what criteria her clients are looking for
7 days ago
Colleen has a excellent way of understanding what criteria her clients are looking for

To start with my purchase was a second home and coming from the New England area meant I had limited time while visiting the area . After a introductory conversation of what I was looking for I emailed her some listing . She replied quickly with some more listings Some were eliminated and a list of prospective properties was created. Every property that she had setup for a viewing for met all my criteria One I liked just a little more. A very productive trip No time wasted Colleen Helped me find the right bank for a mortgage which made the process pretty easy . And a Closing that could have not have gone any better. Always retuned my calls or text quickly and ALWAYS went extra mile to see this Purchase through. Cant say I know to many real-estate agents . But I do know she is one of the best. Thank you Colleen

Seller review
Great realtor.
7 days ago
Great realtor.

Colleen was a pleasure to work with throughout the sale of our home. She has a strong understanding of the local community and was professional, responsive, and always quick to answer our questions. We especially appreciated how available and helpful she was throughout the process. She offered useful suggestions on things we could do to prepare the house for sale and connected us with reliable local handymen and repair professionals when needed. Having someone who knew the area and had trusted contacts made everything so much easier. Colleen was friendly, knowledgeable, and genuinely helpful from beginning to end. We would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Seller review
You won't be disappointed!
8 days ago
You won't be disappointed!

Faced with the monumental task of moving my 97-year-old mom from Sunset Beach, North Carolina to Colorado Springs, Colorado for her care, I sought Colleen's help. We were interested in getting the most money we could for the home to help with the cost of my mom's assisted living expenses in Colorado. Colleen was honest and a real go-getter. She laid out the steps we needed to take to achieve our goal. If you decide to work with Colleen, you will not be disappointed. She keeps in touch in a timely manner and never fails to cross her t's and dot her i's!

Buyer review
Five-star experience from start to finish
8 days ago
Five-star experience from start to finish

Working with Collen was amazing! She did a phenomenal job of guiding me through the process of buying my first home from start to finish. She was always very responsive when any questions or issues came up and was quick to find a solution. I look forward to working with her again and would highly recommend!

Buyer review
Colleen is the definition of resilient!
15 days ago
Colleen is the definition of resilient!

From the very beginning our realtor Colleen Teifer was able to overcome obstacles handling them with expert and calm problem solving. Locking in on our first home offer without ever backing down Colleen gained our confidence and deep trust as a top agent who always made time to fulfill our needs. Unfortunately the home failed in the inspection process to meet our expectations. We continued our search and when we found the home we were looking for (online mind you, crazy) because of our deep trust, Colleen was just a phone call away. In short order she made contact with the sellers agent, evaluated the home for us and we made an appropriate offer. We now own the home! After a recent debacle of a closing we observed with one of my daughters it really opened our eyes of how smooth our entire transaction was including Colleen always being there, her choice of Law Firm, home inspectors and her knowledge of the sometimes complicated paperwork she made so easy! And she is still there and ready to help when needed! Thank you, John and Janice F.

Buyer review
Great Realtor
22 days ago
Great Realtor

Colleen was one of the best agents we have ever had and we have been buying and selling for 45 years. She very knowledgeable and takes care of all the details making it stress free.We would highly recommend her 100%

Seller review
Colleen exemplified the epitome of excellence.
23 days ago
Colleen exemplified the epitome of excellence.

Colleen Teifer represented with professionalism, promptness, knowledge, compassion and respect from inception and even post closing. We would absolutely utilize her again and recommend her to anyone in need of exemplary service. Colleen Teifer most importantly became a friend we will forever cherish.

Seller review
CarolinaColleen is a true professional
23 days ago
CarolinaColleen is a true professional

I first met Colleen through a recommendation of a friend. She came to my house, took a walk through, and shared her credentials and some of her previous work. A couple days later she came back with some suggested minor revisions to the house and a recommended sales price which was more than I had expected but turned out to be reasonable. Colleen sent her team of cleaners and photographers in to get my house ready to present. Her photo and internet presentation was outstanding and we put the house on the market. We had no open houses (per Carolina Colleen, "those are for snoopy folks who want to get some free snacks and see what the inside of the house looked like". ) We had a reasonable offer in 4 days, The prospective buyers had a house inspection which raised some issues, but those were settled through Colleen's negotiations with the buyer. 3-4 weeks after the offer we had a pain free closing. Colleen helped with the painful task of moving and getting rid of "stuff", and I am now comfortably settled in my new house. Moving from a home with a lot of memories is a very stressful thing to do. Colleen made it so much easier than I was expecting. If you are looking for a partner in selling a house, I strongly recommend Carolina Colleen!!!

1 - 12 of 121
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent