Colleen's profile

Colleen's reviews

  5  
Colleen has 101 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Colleen's qualities as told by our client reviews: trustworthy, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Knowledge, Professional Realtor with excellent response time
11 days ago
Knowledge, Professional Realtor with excellent response time

We had been looking for a place at Sunset Beach for about two years. We had worked with a couple of other realtors and were disappointed. Colleen responded promptly to our request to view a property, showed it to us twice, answered out questioned or found out the answers for us, and within two days we put in an offer and it was accepted. We made our offer in December and moved into our vacation home in January. The whole process was seamless and stress free. In one word, we would describe Collen Teifer as Amazing !

Seller review
Has a passion for helping clients and is very knowledgeable and responsive.
22 days ago
Has a passion for helping clients and is very knowledgeable and responsive.

Colleen is knowledgeable about the area, particularly Sea Trail where I was buying & selling my property. Since these actions were remote, both were smooth, fast and efficient. She is trustworthy to get actions done as needed. Colleen was recommended to me and I have recommended her to others.

Buyer review
Exceptional on all accounts
23 days ago
Exceptional on all accounts

Our experience with Colleen was exceptional - she is an excellent communicator, has extraordinary depth of knowledge on the market and neighborhoods in Brunswick County, and was extremely attentive and responsive at every turn. We feel so fortunate to have had the opportunity to work with her on this purchase. She was clear, direct, and her negotiation approach and skills were impeccable. She holds herself to a very high standard and consistently delivers.

Buyer review
Colleen is an excellent Realtor!
24 days ago
Colleen is an excellent Realtor!

Colleen has worked with family members, and they have always spoken highly of her, so I was happy to work with her on the purchase of my new home. She is very knowledgeable about the market and very direct and opened with that knowledge. I was not from the area, so this was very helpful. She made the negotiations and the process very easy for me and I greatly appreciated that. I would highly recommend her !

Seller review
Best you can get
24 days ago
Best you can get

Great agent. On top off everything.

Buyer review
New to Area
25 days ago
New to Area

We can’t recommend Colleen highly enough! As newcomers to the area, we were looking for someone with deep local expertise, and Colleen delivered. She guided us seamlessly through the entire process, providing invaluable support during the search and even staying involved after closing to ensure we were settled. If you’re looking for a dedicated and knowledgeable agent, Colleen is the one to call

Seller review
Excellent knowledge of the area and a great communicator!
25 days ago
Excellent knowledge of the area and a great communicator!

My wife and I needed to leave the Sunset Beach area to get closer to family especially because my mom was sick. We were referred to Colleen by a friend we knew that had recently retired from the real estate business. Colleen was a blessing in disguise for us, we were trying to quickly sell our home during the worst time of the year to sell properties near the beach. Colleen was instrumental in getting our home sold even with two other homes in our neighborhood for sale at the same time. A contact of hers helped us get our home ready for sale and Colleen was extremely helpful on price strategy and stayed in communication with us throughout the whole process. We were able to get a good price for our property and had it closed in time for us to get our new home in another city all within 4 1/2 months from the time we decided to move. If you are looking for a realtor in the southeastern part of Brunswick County NC to assist you in selling or buying property, there’s no one more qualified than Colleen Teifer.

Buyer review
Truly Exceptional Home Buying Experience!
25 days ago
Truly Exceptional Home Buying Experience!

Colleen is without question the very best Realtor we've ever worked with - The entire home buying experience (from start to finish) was exceptional! We could not have been happier! Two of Colleen's strongest assets are her knowledge and her communication. She is thoroughly knowledgeable in all areas of the realty process, is well acquainted with area builders, sellers, etc., and has valuable insights into the specific nuances for any type of realty transaction (new builds, resell homes, etc.)! She also provided us with excellent recommendations for local services (handyman, etc.). Colleen's communication is unparallel - She kept us informed throughout the home buying process with clear/detailed correspondence. Knowing that she was bringing her expertise to bear in every aspect of the process and that she was keeping us informed at every step along the way brought a welcomed peace of mind and settled assurance that we were in good hands! I have already recommended Colleen to several friends and family - And we'll continue to do so without hesitation!

Buyer review
Enthusiastic, very knowledgeable, attention to detail and great communicator!
25 days ago
Enthusiastic, very knowledgeable, attention to detail and great communicator!

Colleen was very outgoing, easy to communicate with and very thorough in assisting me with my search for a new home. She knew all the ins and outs of the area that I wanted to settle in. She has a very strong market knowledge and was instrumental in helping me with my decisions from start to finish. She was very attentive to all details and stayed in touch with me throughout the entire process from beginning the search to closing day! Excellent Realtor

Seller review
Exceptional Experience
4 months ago
Exceptional Experience

We have used Colleen multiple times and every experience has been greet. Colleen is very knowledgeable of the area and will not misguide you. Colleen listens and communicates clearly, she takes the time to listen to your preferences. Colleen is very personable and works hard to deliver for you, just a great person to be around and an excellent choice for all your real estate needs.

Seller review
Outstanding Realtor
4 months ago
Outstanding Realtor

We were referred to Colleen by friends that were happy with the work Colleen had done for them. We are so grateful. From the moment Colleen walked in our door, we could tell she was the "it" Realtor. She provided detailed knowledge of the market and helped us determine a price to sell. She did not waste time, we had a photographer taking pictures within a few days. She stopped by with fliers that represented our place beautifully. She is personable and very professional. We were extremely pleased with Colleen and would recommend her to anyone looking for a Realtor that works with you to get your home sold quickly and at a fair price.

Seller review
A pleasure to work with!
4 months ago
A pleasure to work with!

I have had several transactions with Colleen over the past few years. She is easy to work with, communication is fantastic and she knows what she is doing. She is in tune with the market and its trends and knows how to adjust. She does everything she can to make the process as seamless as possible for her clients, which is appreciated. Don't hesitate, just call Colleen!

1 - 12 of 101
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent