Colleen's profile

Colleen's reviews

  5  
Colleen has 121 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Colleen's qualities as told by our client reviews: trustworthy, detail-oriented, dedicated, clear communication, well-prepared, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Honest, Trustworthy, Responsible Realtor
24 days ago
Honest, Trustworthy, Responsible Realtor

Working with Colleen was a great experience. She was very upfront about the current market and worked with us to set a reasonable sale price to move the house. She provided accurate estimates on what to expect from closing. She utilized digital communication tools for scheduling all showings. She was excellent in setting up inspections and resolving issues with no added costs to us. She was very accommodating to our requests and was very quick to respond to any questions or concerns we had. We were able to accept an offer in 3 weeks for exactly what we had agreed that we wanted to get for the house.

Buyer review
Dedicated and a pleasure to work with
24 days ago
Dedicated and a pleasure to work with

I highly recommend Colleen as a real estate agent. This is the second time she has helped us with a purchase of a home. Her dedication, expertise and friendly approach made our home buying experience enjoyable. She responds very quickly to any questions we had along the way. In addition, she provides referrals for any type of service you need such as inspectors, attorneys, and movers. We will be using her to also sell our current home. She has excellent knowledge of the local market. Carol & Bill Flynn

Seller review
 Excellant experience.
25 days ago
Excellant experience.

Colleen was extremely helpful in prepairing our house for market. We had several conversations and she was very attentive to our wants and needs. She was very good and detailed which resulted in our house selling in 1 day.

Buyer review
Above and Beyond Every Time!
25 days ago
Above and Beyond Every Time!

We have worked with Colleen Teifer on several home purchases over the past several years, and she has consistently gone above and beyond to make every home-buying experience exceptional. One of Colleen’s greatest strengths is her communication. She is always responsive, knowledgeable, and incredibly helpful when exploring different real estate opportunities. She takes the time to understand what we’re looking for and makes the entire process feel smooth and stress-free. What really sets Colleen apart, though, is that her support doesn’t end when the sale is completed. She has an incredible wealth of knowledge and a wonderful network of trusted contacts and connections. When we’ve needed help with repairs, contractors, or other issues after closing, Colleen has always been there to point us in the right direction. We truly appreciate Colleen’s professionalism, dedication, and personal attention, and we would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell real estate. She is someone you can trust to have your best interests at heart from start to finish—and even long after the closing!

Buyer review
Stellar service that by far  exceeded any expectations....
25 days ago
Stellar service that by far exceeded any expectations....

Colleen's attention to detail and a thorough understanding of the Brunswick beach market is all anyone could need to purchase a property. In the moments I would have given up, she soldiered on I am so very pleased with my new home in an area that she fully endorsed. Questions answered, problems solved and obstacles overcome....Collen should be your agent of choice.

Buyer review
Friendly, experienced and attentive.
25 days ago
Friendly, experienced and attentive.

Very knowledgeable about the area and very accessible to all my questions. She was professional and responsive. She really assists you in all areas of need to find the best people for you when it is necessary. We used her for selling and buying.

Seller review
Displayed excellent experience in all aspects of listing and selling our home .
25 days ago
Displayed excellent experience in all aspects of listing and selling our home .

Nobody knows the Sunset Beach market better than Colleen. She gave excellent advice on what we needed to do to make the house more appealing and gave valuable information for pricing the home correctly in a tight market. She was very good at finding truly interested buyers to view our listing.

Seller review
Results oriented broker with excellent market knowledge
26 days ago
Results oriented broker with excellent market knowledge

Colleen is a top performing broker with market knowledge and contacts to get the job done. It is evident that Colleen enjoys her profession and helping customers sell and find a home. Colleen priced our home correctly for the market which helped it sell faster. She also has extensive contacts for contractors that were able to complete the small jobs needed after the inspection. If you're looking for a dedicated professional with a great personality, look no further.

Buyer review
Knowledge, Professional Realtor with excellent response time
5 months ago
Knowledge, Professional Realtor with excellent response time

We had been looking for a place at Sunset Beach for about two years. We had worked with a couple of other realtors and were disappointed. Colleen responded promptly to our request to view a property, showed it to us twice, answered out questioned or found out the answers for us, and within two days we put in an offer and it was accepted. We made our offer in December and moved into our vacation home in January. The whole process was seamless and stress free. In one word, we would describe Collen Teifer as Amazing !

Seller review
Has a passion for helping clients and is very knowledgeable and responsive.
5 months ago
Has a passion for helping clients and is very knowledgeable and responsive.

Colleen is knowledgeable about the area, particularly Sea Trail where I was buying & selling my property. Since these actions were remote, both were smooth, fast and efficient. She is trustworthy to get actions done as needed. Colleen was recommended to me and I have recommended her to others.

Buyer review
Exceptional on all accounts
5 months ago
Exceptional on all accounts

Our experience with Colleen was exceptional - she is an excellent communicator, has extraordinary depth of knowledge on the market and neighborhoods in Brunswick County, and was extremely attentive and responsive at every turn. We feel so fortunate to have had the opportunity to work with her on this purchase. She was clear, direct, and her negotiation approach and skills were impeccable. She holds herself to a very high standard and consistently delivers.

Buyer review
Colleen is an excellent Realtor!
5 months ago
Colleen is an excellent Realtor!

Colleen has worked with family members, and they have always spoken highly of her, so I was happy to work with her on the purchase of my new home. She is very knowledgeable about the market and very direct and opened with that knowledge. I was not from the area, so this was very helpful. She made the negotiations and the process very easy for me and I greatly appreciated that. I would highly recommend her !

13 - 24 of 121
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent