Colleen's profile

Colleen's reviews

  5  
Colleen has 101 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Colleen's qualities as told by our client reviews: trustworthy, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Colleen Teifer is the best and most honest realtor we have ever worked with.
4 months ago
Colleen Teifer is the best and most honest realtor we have ever worked with.

Re-locating to another state is one of the most difficult decisions one can ever make. It is of the utmost importance to partner with a realtor who really understands what you are looking for, is honest and reliable, knowledgable and professional. It gave us a peace of mind how well Colleen really knew the area. She was so good at communicating with us throughout the process whether it be via email, phone and even by facetime or video which completely helped guide us in the right direction. My husband and I went through 3-5 realtors (2 in person, 3 online) before finding Colleen. Colleen was incredibly helpful and went out of her way to make sure we found a home that checked all our boxes and that we loved.

Seller review
Always a Great Listener!
4 months ago
Always a Great Listener!

This was our second time to have Colleen as our Real Estate Agent. Once again she listened to our needs and helped us to get the job done. Excellent Job!!!

Buyer review
Moved from New York to North Carolina
4 months ago
Moved from New York to North Carolina

Colleen evaluated our wants and needs. Found us our dream home.Assisted with paperwork, financing and’ any questions we had. Excellent communication. Thank you Colleen

Buyer review
Trusted, Knowledgeable, and Incredibly Helpful
4 months ago
Trusted, Knowledgeable, and Incredibly Helpful

In a market with plenty of listings but very few homes that truly met my specific criteria at my price point, Colleen was outstanding. Since this was a long-distance move, I especially appreciated how she helped me understand the community and guided me toward areas where the lifestyle I was looking for really made sense. She negotiated effectively on my behalf, made sure every detail was in order for closing, and even made the utility transfers incredibly simple. Colleen was knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely had my best interests in mind throughout the process. I highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy a home. Given her attention to detail, I can't imagine it being any different with any real estate transaction.

Seller review
Best Realtor in Brunswick County
4 months ago
Best Realtor in Brunswick County

If you are looking for a realtor in Brunswick County (buying or selling)…look no further than Colleen Teifer. She is extremely knowledgeable, detail oriented and thorough which made the entire process seamless and stress free. Her communication skills and knowledge of the area is exemplary. We were extremely grateful to have her as our partner in selling the home and have referred her to many of our friends that are looking to relocate to this area. Colleen….again many thanks….for being you and doing such an outstanding job…we will be forever grateful!

Buyer review
Best Realtor
4 months ago
Best Realtor

If you’re looking for the best realtor, we highly recommend Colleen Teifer. From the first day and to the closing of our house she was there for us as we were moving from Rhode Island. Colleen also met us at our new home to welcome us to North Carolina. Have to say she will go above and beyond to help you find your new home. So if your looking for the best, contact her asap.

Seller review
Save Time Vetting Other Realtors and Just Pick Colleen!
4 months ago
Save Time Vetting Other Realtors and Just Pick Colleen!

I've worked with several realtors over the years, and Colleen was by far the best out of the bunch (even though she was selling my in-laws home and not my own 😊). She listened to our needs and thoroughly explained the process and potential hiccups on selling the in-laws home in Brunswick County. She was extremely knowledgeable in the housing market and even understood tactics that other realtors use which helped us in making informed decisions at the negotiating table. She is detailed-oriented, straight shooter and presented information based on facts and not dreams. She also gives you complete and undivided attention and always returns calls or email quickly if she is unavailable. She was extremely transparent in all areas which became very helpful when my in-laws moved out of Brunswick County. When my in-laws left Brunswick County, Colleen was able list their home, handle tasks associated with getting the home ready and selling their home without them being physically present. When you select Colleen as your realtor you get someone who advocates for you, works hard for you and isn’t just in it for the commission.

Buyer review
Buying my how was so easy with Colleen Teifer help!
4 months ago
Buying my how was so easy with Colleen Teifer help!

Colleen listened to what I wanted in a house and followed through to help me find my perfect home. I had very many questions and concerns along the way. She was there to help me and answer them all. She did a lot of the work for me so that I could be stress . If anyone is looking to buy or sell I would definitely suggest Colleen . You will not regret it.. thank you Colleen Teifer!

Buyer review
Excellent Support!
4 months ago
Excellent Support!

My wife and I moved from Maryland and relocated to Ocean Isle Beach NC. Colleen was referred to us as the best to work with. Colleen got to know us and our needs. She found several excellent properties for us that exceeded our expectations. We bought a wonderful new home and are so thankful to her! She took care of so many details with our move and truly made it much easier and a smooth process. I highly recommend her as your realtor!

Buyer review
 Very knowledgeable, experienced, dedicated to her job and very patient
4 months ago
Very knowledgeable, experienced, dedicated to her job and very patient

Mary and I met Colleen in 2024. I told her that we weren’t buying at this time and we just wanted to see different developments in different areas. We told her what we were and weren’t looking for. Colleen had patience with us, returned calls, kept us updated on different places, gave us her opinion with the negatives and positives in different areas. We felt very comfortable working with her as she listened to all our needs (and there were plenty) Colleen will definitely work hard and do her best to assist. Needless to say, she found us the perfect place to call home.

Seller review
Exceptional Realtor Who Goes Above and Beyond—Truly the Best in NC Coastal Area
4 months ago
Exceptional Realtor Who Goes Above and Beyond—Truly the Best in NC Coastal Area

Working with Colleen has been the best real estate experience we’ve had in over 25 years. She took the time to truly understand me, my family, and what we were looking for in a home. Her goal was never just to help us buy a house — she wanted us to love where we landed and feel completely confident in our decision. Her knowledge of the North Carolina coastal area is extraordinary. Colleen gave us a thoughtful, detailed overview of the region, introduced us to neighborhoods that aligned with our lifestyle, and helped us understand the nuances of each coastal community. She knew which areas would fit our needs, which areas were up‑and‑coming, and how each location would feel day‑to‑day - helping us find the right fit for our family. Because we were six hours away, we relied heavily on her guidance, and she went above and beyond. She visited homes on our behalf, sent thorough videos, and provided honest, insightful feedback so we never felt distant from the process. Her dedication, communication, and genuine care made everything smooth and stress‑free. I truly can’t say enough about her. Her expertise in the NC coastal market and her commitment to her clients truly set her apart.

Buyer review
Highly-Recommended Knowledgeable Professional
4 months ago
Highly-Recommended Knowledgeable Professional

Colleen has extensive knowledge of the area and neighborhoods, which we appreciated as we planned our move from out of state. She was thorough in her preparation to review properties within our parameters, mapped out the properties for showings, and maximized our schedule. She was flexible, even giving up some of her personal time, when we needed to see a property again on short notice. When the time came to do so, she provided all the information we needed to make an informed offer to get us the best possible deal on our new home. But she didn't stop there - she was excellent in her communication from offer to to closing, helping us with getting the inspection, having work done (at the expense of the seller) to correct some things found on the inspection, and so much more. She was always quick to respond to our questions, very pleasant to work with, and so very helpful. She really made our experience a breeze - even from 500 miles away! We highly recommend Colleen for your buying or selling needs - you won't be disappointed!

25 - 36 of 101
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent