Colleen Teifer

Colleen Teifer

NC: 293942SC: 110287
  •   5   (122 reviews)

Colleen's sales performance at a glance

See how Colleen has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

64
Reviews
25
Properties for sale
73
Sold properties
$500k
Average sale price
$34.5m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

  • priceExpertbadge

    Consistently meets client expectations for property purchase price.

  • aotybadge

    Recognized for going above & beyond for their clients.

Colleen's customer service award

See the RateMyAgent award Colleen has won

  • County Top 5Brunswick County

About Colleen

I moved to North Carolina from New Jersey in 2014 after retiring early from a career as a high school administrator. Real estate has always been in my blood, as other family members were agents, builders and investors. I began investing in property myself many years ago, as I knew it would be a means to a planned early retirement and relocation. As such, I have the benefit of many years of experience buying, selling, renovating, and managing my own properties. This enables me to look with a critical eye at properties for my clients, and help educate them throughout their search for property. As I relocated to this area myself, it also offers my clients the additional benefit of my experience and understanding of this process. I can help clients streamline their search, and offer them the options that appear to best match their preferences. I cover the entire area from Wilmington to Myrtle Beach, so can assist clients with any communities or properties. I am licensed in both NC and SC as well. My background as a public servant gives me a perspective that other traditional salespeople do not have. I truly have my clients' best interests at heart, and will work for their benefit alone. This has served me well as I am one of the top producing brokers in my region. My sales volume for 2022 was in excess of 20M, 2023 was in excess of 21M, and 2024 was in excess of 25M.

Colleen's reviews

  5  
Colleen has 122 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 6.
Review Colleen
Colleen's qualities as told by our client reviews: trustworthy, detail-oriented, dedicated, clear communication, well-prepared, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
The highest level of performance with exceptional results.
4 days ago
The highest level of performance with exceptional results.

Choosing the wrong agent initially cost us eight precious weeks. Once we enlisted advanced AI platforms to analyze local market performance, however, the path forward became remarkably clear. We quickly identified the handful of agents operating at the highest level in our area, and after interviewing several of them, the choice for us became obvious. Colleen Tiefer is exceptionally results-oriented, combining extensive experience with a highly focused strategy and, equally important, disciplined execution. From our very first conversation, she understood exactly what we expected and immediately put a comprehensive marketing plan into motion. The marketing materials she and her team developed were well above the norm, presenting our home exceptionally well while demonstrating a clear understanding of the importance of positioning, exposure, and time to market. Her ability to reach buyers beyond the immediate local market was also evident from the outset. Even in challenging market conditions, Colleen’s expertise, persistence, and attention to detail resulted in our home going under contract within days rather than weeks or months. She and her team made what could have been an extremely stressful process remarkably smooth and virtually painless. Putting our trust in Colleen was, without question, one of the best decisions we made. If results, professionalism, strategic thinking, and execution matter to you, we recommend Colleen without hesitation.

Seller review
Knowledgeable and Professional Real Estate Agent
9 days ago
Knowledgeable and Professional Real Estate Agent

We interviewed three candidates to help sell and market our home. Colleen arrived at our meeting very well prepared on the current market conditions, the general area and, in particular, our neighborhood. Colleen's professionalism and plan to sell gave us a roadmap to successfully sell our house. She is personable, responsive and knowledgeable. Our house sold in 4 days. She was on top of the entire process. We couldn't recommend Colleen highly enough to either buy or sell a home.

Buyer review
Colleen made our beach home dream come true!
9 days ago
Colleen made our beach home dream come true!

Colleen provided us a fantastic experience in finding our dream home in Sunset Beach, NC. Her skill at listening carefully and determining what we were looking for, her deep experience in the market, and her enthusiastic support at every step really made her outstanding. Colleen’s demonstrated knowledge of the area and the characteristics of each of its communities pointed us in the right direction. During our first call with her, she guided us through a series of questions that led her to make some concrete recommendations and focused our search on places that would best fit what we were looking for. When we walked into a model home, we knew instantly it had all the characteristics that we wanted. Throughout the process, Colleen’s responsive support and guidance were immensely helpful, especially since we were living several hours away from the area. As soon as we returned home from our first trip, she visited properties in our desired community and sent us information, photos, and her take on them. This level of responsiveness was invaluable, as we did not have time to do so on our first trip. The depth and speed of her follow-ups allowed us to make another quick trip to the area, where she took us through the most promising properties. The process went very fast for us, with Colleen helping us to make an offer and get on contract that same day. She walked us through the entire process of the purchase and setting up utilities until we were settled in our new home. We are so thankful that someone recommended Colleen to us, and we highly recommend her to anyone who is looking to purchase their dream property in the coastal Brunswick County area.

Buyer review
Colleen has a excellent way of understanding what criteria her clients are looking for
13 days ago
Colleen has a excellent way of understanding what criteria her clients are looking for

To start with my purchase was a second home and coming from the New England area meant I had limited time while visiting the area . After a introductory conversation of what I was looking for I emailed her some listing . She replied quickly with some more listings Some were eliminated and a list of prospective properties was created. Every property that she had setup for a viewing for met all my criteria One I liked just a little more. A very productive trip No time wasted Colleen Helped me find the right bank for a mortgage which made the process pretty easy . And a Closing that could have not have gone any better. Always retuned my calls or text quickly and ALWAYS went extra mile to see this Purchase through. Cant say I know to many real-estate agents . But I do know she is one of the best. Thank you Colleen

Seller review
Great realtor.
14 days ago
Great realtor.

Colleen was a pleasure to work with throughout the sale of our home. She has a strong understanding of the local community and was professional, responsive, and always quick to answer our questions. We especially appreciated how available and helpful she was throughout the process. She offered useful suggestions on things we could do to prepare the house for sale and connected us with reliable local handymen and repair professionals when needed. Having someone who knew the area and had trusted contacts made everything so much easier. Colleen was friendly, knowledgeable, and genuinely helpful from beginning to end. We would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Show all 122 reviews
map

Colleen's properties

Colleen has 25 properties for sale and sold 73 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$749,900
169 Staffordshire Pl SW
Ocean Isle Beach NC 28469
3
3
4
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Silver Coast Properties
For Sale
$1,399,900
9295 River Terrace SW
Calabash NC 28467
4
5
4
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Silver Coast Properties
SoldSep 23, 2026
$443,000
676 Boundary Loop Rd NW
Calabash NC 28467
3
2
6
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of NorthGroup Real Estate Inc. and Silver Coast Properties
SoldSep 22, 2026
$367,000
1335 Sunny Slope Circle
Carolina Shores NC 28467
4
3
4
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Silver Coast Properties and Coldwell Banker Sea Coast Advantage - South Brunswick
Show all 98 properties

Colleen's sold properties

Colleen has sold 73 properties in the past 12 months, showing 4.

Enter your property details to filter

I'm selling a
bedroom
with
bathrooms in
Property imageAddressBedroomsBathroomsCarparksProperty TypeClosing PriceDate Sold
676 Boundary Loop Rd NW, Calabash, NC, 28467
676 Boundary Loop Rd NW
Calabash NC 28467
3
2
6
Single-Family$443,000Sep 23, 2026
1335 Sunny Slope Circle, Carolina Shores, NC, 28467
1335 Sunny Slope Circle
Carolina Shores NC 28467
4
3
4
Single-Family$367,000Sep 22, 2026
312 Crooked Gulley Cir, Sunset Beach, NC, 28468
312 Crooked Gulley Cir
Sunset Beach NC 28468
Land$140,000Sep 21, 2026
6991 Ascension Drive Southwest, Ocean Isle Beach, NC, 28469
6991 Ascension Drive Southwest
Ocean Isle Beach NC 28469
3
3
4
Single-Family$525,000Sep 14, 2026

Browse nearby locations

SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent