Colleen's profile

Colleen's reviews

  5  
Colleen has 121 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Colleen's qualities as told by our client reviews: trustworthy, detail-oriented, dedicated, clear communication, well-prepared, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Colleen made the whole process of buying our condo super easy!
9 months ago
Colleen made the whole process of buying our condo super easy!

Colleen is very knowledgeable of the area and was very responsive with any questions we had about specific condos. She was very accommodating and helped us set up tours when we were in the area which was helpful since we do not live in North Carolina. When we chose the condo we planned to buy, Colleen streamlined the whole process, again super helpful since we were not always able to be in the area to take care of things in person. She came highly recommended from friends who had used her when they were looking to purchase in the area and we have in turn recommended her to a family member who is considering purchasing in the Sunset Beach area. Can’t go wrong with Colleen!

Seller review
Outstanding
9 months ago
Outstanding

Colleen is a testament of a true top notch real estate agent. We definitely gave her a run for her money, which in her true professionalism, & extreme patience never wavered. She answered all of our questions, knew what we were looking for & put us at the homes that would best suit us. She handled my brother & sister in laws real estate needs & found a beautiful home for them. Then came finding a home for my father in law, I thought this was where we were going to lose her. But the true professional that she is, she was able to find quite a few homes to look at. And finally after dealing with the whole family's input she highly recommended a brand new home, and it was within his budget. And that was what he settled on. If you are in the market for a new home, we highly recommend Colleen. True Real Estate Professional with deep knowledge of the area, & has your best interest in mind.

Buyer review
Beyond Expectations
9 months ago
Beyond Expectations

Living out of the area, Colleen was great to give us thoughts on her experience with different builders and house plans. She helped us navigate pros/cons of different locations. She even helped us get new furniture in house when we couldn't be there. Would definitely recommend!

Seller review
A Great Home Sale Experience
9 months ago
A Great Home Sale Experience

When we decided to sell our home of 30 years, it was important to choose the best realtor. We interviewed several and one stood out as the best fit for us--Colleen Tiefer. She was professional, honest and realistic in helping us arrive at the listing price so we could get the maximum proceeds and yet have it sold in as short a time possible. Her photographer took great pictures of the interior and exterior, and she produced a beautiful brochure which was placed on the sign in the front yard. She was diligent in booking showings, and gave us adequate notice of them so we could present the house at its best. She was quite easy to work with. Her professionality and experience made the sale of our home as stress free as possible. We highly recommend Colleen to anyone selling their home. She gives 100%

Seller review
Great selling experience
9 months ago
Great selling experience

Colleen helped us sell our condo. She was professional, pleasant , and easy to work with. We appreciated that she was able to list our condo on various platforms. When offers came in she was invaluable in helping us attain the very best offer. If you’re selling, go with Colleen.

Seller review
Best Realtor in Sunset Beach
9 months ago
Best Realtor in Sunset Beach

Colleen is easily the best Realtor we have ever worked with. After 17 amazing years in Sunset Beach we felt the pull to move closer to our children and grandchildren. We did some research and decided to interview several top sellers. We began with Colleen and the rest is history! She is incredibly kind, patient and wicked smart! She has great knowledge of the local market, is very professional, provides immediate response to any question, and is always available. Her photographer is incredible and took beautiful pictures of our home. Our home sold quickly and every part of the negotiations went smoothly! Colleen truly is a shining star and we are grateful to have worked with her!

Seller review
Best Real Estate experience ever
9 months ago
Best Real Estate experience ever

Colleen was so great to work with. Very knowledgeable about the market, what was available and the real estate laws. We spent a few days together but did most of our search from afar and Colleen was great.

Buyer review
Colleen is a Wonderful Realtor
9 months ago
Colleen is a Wonderful Realtor

Colleen is an excellent real estate agent. We used her both for selling a property and for purchasing land and purchasing a home that was built for us. She is very knowledgeable about different developments, builders, and areas in North Carolina. Her experience and professionalism helped us with all our real estate transactions. It is a pleasure to work with Colleen!

Buyer review
Colleen Teifer is the best and most honest realtor we have ever worked with.
9 months ago
Colleen Teifer is the best and most honest realtor we have ever worked with.

Re-locating to another state is one of the most difficult decisions one can ever make. It is of the utmost importance to partner with a realtor who really understands what you are looking for, is honest and reliable, knowledgable and professional. It gave us a peace of mind how well Colleen really knew the area. She was so good at communicating with us throughout the process whether it be via email, phone and even by facetime or video which completely helped guide us in the right direction. My husband and I went through 3-5 realtors (2 in person, 3 online) before finding Colleen. Colleen was incredibly helpful and went out of her way to make sure we found a home that checked all our boxes and that we loved.

Seller review
Always a Great Listener!
9 months ago
Always a Great Listener!

This was our second time to have Colleen as our Real Estate Agent. Once again she listened to our needs and helped us to get the job done. Excellent Job!!!

Buyer review
Moved from New York to North Carolina
9 months ago
Moved from New York to North Carolina

Colleen evaluated our wants and needs. Found us our dream home.Assisted with paperwork, financing and’ any questions we had. Excellent communication. Thank you Colleen

Buyer review
Trusted, Knowledgeable, and Incredibly Helpful
9 months ago
Trusted, Knowledgeable, and Incredibly Helpful

In a market with plenty of listings but very few homes that truly met my specific criteria at my price point, Colleen was outstanding. Since this was a long-distance move, I especially appreciated how she helped me understand the community and guided me toward areas where the lifestyle I was looking for really made sense. She negotiated effectively on my behalf, made sure every detail was in order for closing, and even made the utility transfers incredibly simple. Colleen was knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely had my best interests in mind throughout the process. I highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy a home. Given her attention to detail, I can't imagine it being any different with any real estate transaction.

37 - 48 of 121
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent