Colleen's profile

Colleen's reviews

  5  
Colleen has 101 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Colleen's qualities as told by our client reviews: trustworthy, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Colleen has been a fantastic realtor for us, first getting us acquainted with the various developmen
about 4 years ago
Colleen has been a fantastic realtor for us, first getting us acquainted with the various developmen

Colleen has been a fantastic realtor for us, first getting us acquainted with the various developments along the coast, helping us to focus in on the two developments that best met our wish list, then working tirelessly over the past 3 months personally visiting the several houses that we considered making offers on that very same day (based on the online photos , as there was no time for us to quickly visit North Carolina in this fast track housing market), evaluating the positives and negatives of each home or property with us, providing guidance on structuring our offers, then following thru on the necessary details with us until we closed. She is not just a realtor, we consider her a friend. Paul & Phyllis

Buyer review
We would like to thank Colleen for all of her hard work and effort on our behalf
about 4 years ago
We would like to thank Colleen for all of her hard work and effort on our behalf

We would like to thank Colleen for all of her hard work and effort on our behalf. We can't say enough about her skills and talent , but hope the following will do- She is very hard working ,focused and organized. She took the time out to know what we did and did not need to make us happy, she was available to help and advise on short notice and always made sure our needs were addressed . Her experience was essential to the success of our home purchase, she was always on top of any topic and was ready for the " next step" due to her experience. She is well connected to home inspectors , pest control company's, lenders, local utility's and a competent and user friendly local settlement company/ attorney. All of these connections saved us time, money and stress. Her focus was on finding us what we wanted and we appreciate it. We would recommend Colleen to anyone who is home shopping.

Buyer review
When we were thinking about moving to the North Carolina coast from out-of-state, we knew it would b
about 4 years ago
When we were thinking about moving to the North Carolina coast from out-of-state, we knew it would b

When we were thinking about moving to the North Carolina coast from out-of-state, we knew it would be a great adventure, but also potentially problematic. From the time we made our first inquiries about the move to closing, having Colleen Teifer as our realtor was the best decision we could've made. Colleen is not only very professional, but was sincerely attentive to our needs and concerns. We had moved many times, but never out-of-state. There were many things to consider, and she communicated with us long before we made the actual decision to move. During our search for a home and through the entire process through closing, Colleen was always available, went the extra mile and was absolutely indispensable to us. Colleen has an engaging personality and is extremely knowledgeable about real estate and the area. She made everything fall into place. We are so happy that we found her and very highly recommend her to all who need a quality, expert real estate agent. -Jeff and Linda Williams

Buyer review
Colleen was great to work with from start to finish!  She listened to our wants and needs and found
about 4 years ago
Colleen was great to work with from start to finish! She listened to our wants and needs and found

Colleen was great to work with from start to finish! She listened to our wants and needs and found properties that were fitting. We purchased a vacation property in NC and did so while being entirely remote, in another State. Colleen was extremely helpful and went the extra mile for all the showings we had. She even went over to the property we ended up purchasing on Sunday evening, the same day in which it hit the market, to FaceTime a walkthrough showing for us which helped us make an expedited decision in a crazy market. She provided her opinions, which I trusted immediately, on various properties throughout our search. Colleen’s communications and responses to my questions were spot on and timely. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking for real estate. She became a friend through the process, not just a real estate agent! I will use her again for any real estate needs in North Carolina.

Buyer review
My spouse and I were referred to Colleen by friends close to 18 months ago
about 4 years ago
My spouse and I were referred to Colleen by friends close to 18 months ago

My spouse and I were referred to Colleen by friends close to 18 months ago. Her professionalism and patience in guiding us to our new neighborhood, lot and home model selection was unparalleled. She is detail oriented, asks questions that are pertinent in getting to know you, and has a genuine interest in helping others find a home that suits both their needs and their budget. While working with Colleen, it became evident that she is an expert at her craft. We became more and more comfortable with her as she helped us navigate our way unrushed around multiple neighborhoods and construction sites. Her knowledge and expertise extends beyond what "typical" realtors bring to the table. She actually assisted us with changing the design configuration of our home which provided us with optimal sunlight opportunity and increased privacy with our neighbors. Finally, Colleen was very helpful during our final walk-thru as she helped us with discovering minor aesthetic imperfections that the builder listed for correction. Our buying experience with Colleen couldn't have been better and we've been happy and confident to recommend her to several friends and family members. Our recommendation for future homebuyers? Call Colleen FIRST! She's the best!!

Buyer review
We've never had such a great experience with a realtor
about 4 years ago
We've never had such a great experience with a realtor

We've never had such a great experience with a realtor. Nor did we ever expect the efforts made by one individual to go way beyond what you could ever imagine. Professional. Knowledgeable. Never pushy. Gets to know her clients, their personal needs. Does her job so well and makes sure that everything that needs to get done, is done! Don't bother with the rest of the agents out there that are just interested in closing and making a buck. Colleen is hands down, the Realtor you need to work with! Because she works for you! Not for herself!

Buyer review
Colleen was our agent as we made the move from New York to North Carolina
about 4 years ago
Colleen was our agent as we made the move from New York to North Carolina

Colleen was our agent as we made the move from New York to North Carolina. From the very start, she proved her deep knowledge of the area, developments and builders, helping us identify the perfect opportunity. This was our first time with a new build and Colleen was there every step of the way with her guidance and support. If you are looking for a realtor that is a true professional with high integrity, deep connections and an absolute pleasure to work with, give Colleen a ring!

Buyer review
Wow!!!  Carolina Colleen really hit the mark helping us
over 4 years ago
Wow!!! Carolina Colleen really hit the mark helping us

Wow!!! Carolina Colleen really hit the mark helping us. We took a chance on her since she was referred by someone we know. We were looking to move from the Orlando, FL area to Leland, NC area near Wilmington. We were able to buy sight unseen with her competent help... she walked us through a showing with Facetime. She found out what we wanted and was able to steer us into just what we wanted. She even pointed out a few things we couldn't see on facetime that might have been problematic. She was honest and forthcoming, answering all questions and gave honest opinions when we asked. We soon gained a trust in her and her professional knowledge. We bought the first one she found. She put us in touch with a team very competent financial and legal folks to make it happen. We were on a tight time schedule. They made it happen. We moved in and were delighted with the results. If I mention anxiety, apprehension and fright about committing money on something we had not seen... it would have been a gross understatement. The way she managed us through the entire process from viewing to closing with mortgage company, insurance agency, inspections and being so totally responsive is worthy of our time to share this with those who care about getting the right result. She's in it for you!!!

Buyer review
Colleen is all you want in a real estate agent
over 4 years ago
Colleen is all you want in a real estate agent

Colleen is all you want in a real estate agent. She is very professional and very knowledgeable about the real estate in the area. She never tried to push one property over another. Colleen was very helpful with all details related to the purchase of the home, and with the names of service people in the area we might need. She was just great to work with.

Buyer review
I can't recommend Colleen highly enough
over 4 years ago
I can't recommend Colleen highly enough

I can't recommend Colleen highly enough. This is my third (and hopefully final) home and Colleen is far and away the most professional, hard working & knowledgeable real estate agent I have ever worked with. We discussed the type of house and property we were looking for and she found it almost immediately. She is wonderful to work with and also has a ton of contacts, so she was able to set us up with reputable contractors, painters & landscapers which is invaluable. Especially for those like us that are new to the Brunswick county area. She also hooked us up with a great local law firm & an insurance agent which we used for our closing. The closing was done in under 2 months & Colleen made the process incredibly easy and painless. I give Colleen my highest recommendation for anyone looking to buy or sell their home.

Buyer review
Colleen Teifer is a totally fantastic realtor
over 4 years ago
Colleen Teifer is a totally fantastic realtor

Colleen Teifer is a totally fantastic realtor. Colleen worked tirelessly and effectively with us in locating, purchasing and even assisting us after our move into our new home in Ocean Isle Beach. Colleen is a true expert in her field and is extremely effective in explaining all the complexities associated with purchasing a home. Time and time again, Colleen responded to our numerous questions and followed through with each and every question and need we had during the home buying process. Colleen is also very personable and professional in her demeanor and makes her client very comfortable. We highly recommend Colleen and her company!!! Paul and Linda Turnau

85 - 96 of 101
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent