Colleen's profile

Colleen's reviews

  5  
Colleen has 123 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Colleen's qualities as told by our client reviews: trustworthy, detail-oriented, dedicated, clear communication, well-prepared, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Colleen was an immense help in assisting my partner and I as we relocated to the Sunset Beach area a
over 2 years ago
Colleen was an immense help in assisting my partner and I as we relocated to the Sunset Beach area a

Colleen was an immense help in assisting my partner and I as we relocated to the Sunset Beach area and purchased a home. She was patient with our endless questions, responsive with communications, and even made herself available after closing to make sure our transition went smoothly. I would highly recommend her as an established realtor in the area who knows the market and values the comfort and success of her clients through every stage of the process.

Buyer review
We looked for a place at Sunset and OIB for close to two years
over 2 years ago
We looked for a place at Sunset and OIB for close to two years

We looked for a place at Sunset and OIB for close to two years. Colleen showed us +75 properties over that time period. We would come down usually on a day trip and see 5-7 properties at a time. Colleen was able to flawlessly arrange all of the requested visits. Colleen was punctual, professional and very knowledgable. My wife and I highly recommend Colleen.

Seller review
Colleen Teifer can bring results in an amazingly short period of time
over 2 years ago
Colleen Teifer can bring results in an amazingly short period of time

Colleen Teifer can bring results in an amazingly short period of time. She is quick to respond to questions and proactive about finding buyers and networking with colleagues. Colleen's professionalism and expertise generated a stress free process for the sale of my condo. If you're looking for a realtor with a positive and can-do attitude, I highly recommend working with Colleen Teifer.

Buyer review
You cannot go wrong when using Colleen Teifer as your Realtor
over 2 years ago
You cannot go wrong when using Colleen Teifer as your Realtor

You cannot go wrong when using Colleen Teifer as your Realtor. We have had the pleasure of using her three times. Twice when we purchased and once when we sold our home. When we listed our home with Colleen, she sold it the same day. Her listings stand apart from others. The attention to detail she put into the write-up of our home was amazing. The professional photographer she used to take photos was fantastic. The photos were magazine quality. It took us a long time to find the perfect home to purchase and Colleen was so patient and understanding. She did not rush us in anyway. She was there for us throughout the entire process. She is extremely knowledgeable and is very familiar with the area. We recommend her to all our friends. You are in the best hands when you use Colleen.

Buyer review
I first “met” Colleen Teifer over the phone while researching various coastal NC communities during
over 2 years ago
I first “met” Colleen Teifer over the phone while researching various coastal NC communities during

I first “met” Colleen Teifer over the phone while researching various coastal NC communities during Covid. My husband and I were planning on relocating from NJ to Coastal NC when he retired. Since she was from NJ, we realized we had a lot in common including some of the people we both knew! From that point on, we kept in touch via emails and phone calls. Colleen, (in addition to 2 other realtors), sent us listings everyday and she kept us abreast of the housing market. Whenever we had any questions whatsoever, Colleen responded quickly, with not just a sentence or two, but with many paragraphs!! In September 2022, we flew down and set up time to meet Colleen and see many of the communities in the area. She spent 4 days driving us through at least 20-25 different communities from the NC/SC border up to Leland and everywhere in between. She was very knowledgeable on every location and printed out literature for us. My husband and I decided that once we were ready to begin house hunting, we would definitely choose Colleen as our realtor. Months passed and in May 2023, we saw a listing in Ocean Ridge Plantation in Ocean Isle Beach. Because resale houses were going so quickly, we had to act fast. Colleen discussed the property with us and, since we were in NJ, she took detailed videos of the interior and exterior. We decided to put a bid on it. The offer was accepted and Colleen helped us every step of the way. She knew local resources regarding home inspections, mortgages, lawyers, insurance, etc…which made the long distance transition from start to finish much easier. Closing took place July 2023 and we moved down that September. We still reach out to Colleen when we have questions or need guidance and she is always happy to help us. We would highly recommend Colleen Teifer to anyone interested in relocating to the area and purchasing a home in southeast coastal NC!

Buyer review
Colleen was the key to us getting our forever home in OIB
over 2 years ago
Colleen was the key to us getting our forever home in OIB

Colleen was the key to us getting our forever home in OIB. We lived in the mid west and she did a complete video walk thru of the home for us. She was exceptional in keeping the lines of communication open during the entire process. She went above and beyond by meeting a car service that was transporting one of our vehicles - she had it waiting in garage for us upon our arrival. She even provided a recommendation for a great hair stylist by inquiring with former clients. We’ve known Colleen for three years and not only consider her a great realtor but a great friend.

Buyer review
Colleen is exceptional
over 2 years ago
Colleen is exceptional

Colleen is exceptional. We met her by chance when we were looking to move from the Midwest to North Carolina. We were interested in a specific area and were impressed with Colleen’s knowledge of it and the amount of data she had about the market. Colleen was an easy choice, and we are glad we chose her. Colleen was ALWAYS available for home tours. Since we were out of state, Colleen conducted numerous virtual house tours for us and provided great insight into houses, builders, etc. She was very responsive and always professional. Ultimately, we purchased a great home in our neighborhood built by one of the top builders in the state. Colleen gathered incredible information throughout the process and kept us well-informed. She will look out for you and keep your best interest in mind. Colleen's ability to navigate disagreements with other real estate agents was a testament to her professionalism and skill. She remained patient and composed, working through the entire process without breaking a sweat. Her cool, calm mindset kept our anxiety low and instilled in us a deep sense of trust and confidence that she would get the job done – and she did! Colleen's promptness, market knowledge, strategic mindset, kindness, and great energy all contributed to making what could have been a chaotic purchase process simple. Her professional demeanor and efficient approach reassured us and kept our anxiety at bay. We have already recommended her to two of our good friends. If you are looking to buy, we highly recommend Colleen. Don’t hesitate to give her a call.

Buyer review
Colleen came highly recommended by family and friends that were previous clients and she always went
over 2 years ago
Colleen came highly recommended by family and friends that were previous clients and she always went

Colleen came highly recommended by family and friends that were previous clients and she always went above and beyond to accommodate me since we did this long distance and made the whole transaction smooth she is a great contact for local business contractors to do work on my unit. We are looking forward to coming down to put our finishing touches on our Condo

Buyer review
Colleen was the best
over 2 years ago
Colleen was the best

Colleen was the best. We were not very familiar with the area so she helped us decide where we wanted to be and went above and beyond to help us get a place in our dream location. Even when we didn’t get the 1st couple we bid on she kept meeting us even when she was recovering from surgery. We cannot express how grateful we are for Colleen.

Seller review
We met Colleen via the internet while searching for a home in Brunswick county
about 3 years ago
We met Colleen via the internet while searching for a home in Brunswick county

We met Colleen via the internet while searching for a home in Brunswick county. Once we connected, she answered so many questions and led us to find a home. She is very knowledgeable with homes and certainly the area! After 4 years in our home we turned to Colleen to sell it, while we loved the area and our home, we really missed our friends and family back north. She did a great job selling our home and even helped out after we left the home with follow-up items. Highly recommend ****

Buyer review
Colleen helped us with the purchase of our second home in OIB
about 3 years ago
Colleen helped us with the purchase of our second home in OIB

Colleen helped us with the purchase of our second home in OIB. She was knowledgeable about new developments and the community. When we finally did settle in on a home, it was reassuring to know she checked in with the builder and addressed our concerns since we could. It be here on a daily basis. Highly recommend Colleen.

Buyer review
Colleen came highly recommended  by long-time friends who had used her with their relocation from Ne
about 3 years ago
Colleen came highly recommended by long-time friends who had used her with their relocation from Ne

Colleen came highly recommended by long-time friends who had used her with their relocation from New York to Ocean isle Beach. As soon as we reached out to Colleen, she got right back to us and the phone calls, texts and emails began. She really listened to what we were looking for and asked great questions! She was so knowledgeable about the area and extremely familiar with all of the communities we wanted to explore. We had a very limited amount of time during our visit and within the first day, Colleen found us our “Dream” Home. She took us through the offer process, recommended excellent local lawyers and insurance brokers, assisted with the inspection and we closed in less than a month. After we closed, Colleen kept in touch and recommended local service providers to help us with anything we needed. Colleen made an extremely important and stressful process efficient, easy and fun! She goes above and beyond in all she does. We highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a house in Brunswick County. Barbara and Gary Van Bergen

73 - 84 of 123
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent