Back Pickaway County

329 real estate offices in Pickaway County

Sorted by most reviews for offices in Pickaway County over the past 12 months.
View Realistar's profile

Realistar

5.0

(21 reviews)

  • Reviews in Pickaway County 1
  • Sold 13
  • For Sale 5
  • Total sales value $4.4m
  • Avg. sale price $339k
Kade Brantley8 months ago

Buyer of 23 Main Street, Orient

Above and Beyond

Jill went above and beyond to help us buy our home! She responded promptly and kindly to all our questions and concerns. We appreciate her efforts to get us the best deal and will definitely use her again!

Accolades

View REMAX One | Pickerington's profile

REMAX One | Pickerington

N/A

(0 reviews)

  • Reviews in Pickaway County 1
  • Sold 8
  • For Sale 0
  • Total sales value $3m
  • Avg. sale price $381k

No reviews in Pickaway County yet

Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Accolades

View Cutler Real Estate | Westerville's profile

Cutler Real Estate | Westerville

5.0

(89 reviews)

Meet the team

Donna JacksonJennifer BlatzKaren Newbanks
+22
  • Reviews in Pickaway County 1
  • Sold 2
  • For Sale 0
  • Total sales value $550k
  • Avg. sale price $275k
Michael Shreck6 days ago

Seller of 207 East Mill Street, Circleville

3rd time is a Charm

I'm a very critical person when it comes to doing the things You say you're going to do when i hire someone, Karen was the 3rd realtor I hired for this house, but the first to do what she said, and more. No empty promises just to hook me in, cared about the work I completed on the house, and would have became a friend had she not already been one. I understand why she and Rick are so busy, while others pay for leads she is swamped from word of mouth advertising. Couldn't have asked for more than she did. And we found the perfect buyer to boot. I took less than I wanted to, but because I ran out of time on my Land Contract, not because of anything she did. I believe if i would have chose correctly the first time we could have gotten 30 to 50k more for the place. Investors took a back seat because the housing market should be affordable for the average person, not a get rich quick scheme. Yes it is the one thing left to do so, but do we need a few rich and then renters, or do we need to have level playing ground like my grandpa had? Enough of my views on that, this is about my bada$$ realtor, and her nunchuck skills, I mean negotiation skills🤣. You're awesome Karen, I think the negative connotations to the name needs changed solely because of her awesomeness!

Accolades

View Coldwell Banker Realty's profile

Coldwell Banker Realty

5.0

(8 reviews)

  • Reviews in Pickaway County 0
  • Sold 158
  • For Sale 45
  • Total sales value $49.3m
  • Avg. sale price $312k
Johnnessa Justicealmost 2 years ago

Buyer of 159 Chestnut Estates Dr, Commercial Point

Best realtor around!

Ryan was amazing throughout the whole process! This is our second home purchase using Ryan as our realtor and he always goes above and beyond to make sure we’re happy & in the home of our dreams!

Accolades

View Red 1 Realty's profile

Red 1 Realty

5.0

(75 reviews)

  • Reviews in Pickaway County 0
  • Sold 88
  • For Sale 37
  • Total sales value $27.7m
  • Avg. sale price $315k
Charlene Bettsalmost 2 years ago

Seller of 539 East Mound Street, Circleville

Very Knowledgeable

She was very patient and listened to every concern that we had. She was Very knowledgeable. Helped us also to purchase a house.

Accolades

View e-Merge Real Estate Crossroads' profile

e-Merge Real Estate Crossroads

5.0

(1 review)

  • Reviews in Pickaway County 0
  • Sold 70
  • For Sale 27
  • Total sales value $18.7m
  • Avg. sale price $267k

No reviews in Pickaway County yet

Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Accolades

View M3K Real Estate Network Inc.'s profile

M3K Real Estate Network Inc.

N/A

(0 reviews)

  • Reviews in Pickaway County 0
  • Sold 55
  • For Sale 21
  • Total sales value $16.8m
  • Avg. sale price $306k

No reviews in Pickaway County yet

Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Accolades

View D.R. Horton Realty of Ohio, In's profile

D.R. Horton Realty of Ohio, In

N/A

(0 reviews)

  • Reviews in Pickaway County 0
  • Sold 51
  • For Sale 30
  • Total sales value $19.4m
  • Avg. sale price $381k

No reviews in Pickaway County yet

Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Accolades

View Keller Williams Consultants' profile

Keller Williams Consultants

5.0

(174 reviews)

  • Reviews in Pickaway County 0
  • Sold 51
  • For Sale 8
  • Total sales value $19.8m
  • Avg. sale price $389k
Mark Childsover 1 year ago

Buyer of Lot 416/313 Dowler Drive, South Bloomfield

Wonderful agent

Melinda was wonderful. She's very knowledgeable of what was going on in the market and kept us up to date. We had several bumps in the road as we navigated the housing market trying to sell our home and she was always there with a solution and strategies to help us sell our home. With her help we were able to sell our home and buy a new home with a seamless transition.

Accolades

10 - 18 of 296

Cities in Pickaway County

Suburbs in Pickaway County

View nearby Counties

© 2026 RateMyAgent