Pickaway County is home to 329 active real estate agents and 303 active real estate offices. There are 2 agents who are known for their trustworthiness, and 21 agents known for being pricing experts.
Over the past 12 months there have been 863 active and sold properties, with 38 reviews in total. This is a 5% decrease compared to the previous 12 months.
I'm a very critical person when it comes to doing the things You say you're going to do when i hire someone, Karen was the 3rd realtor I hired for this house, but the first to do what she said, and more. No empty promises just to hook me in, cared about the work I completed on the house, and would have became a friend had she not already been one. I understand why she and Rick are so busy, while others pay for leads she is swamped from word of mouth advertising. Couldn't have asked for more than she did. And we found the perfect buyer to boot. I took less than I wanted to, but because I ran out of time on my Land Contract, not because of anything she did. I believe if i would have chose correctly the first time we could have gotten 30 to 50k more for the place. Investors took a back seat because the housing market should be affordable for the average person, not a get rich quick scheme. Yes it is the one thing left to do so, but do we need a few rich and then renters, or do we need to have level playing ground like my grandpa had? Enough of my views on that, this is about my bada$$ realtor, and her nunchuck skills, I mean negotiation skills🤣. You're awesome Karen, I think the negative connotations to the name needs changed solely because of her awesomeness!
Me and my wife came to Jason needing to be in a house in 2 months. We sat down with him and his daughter and looked at listings that met our needs. That same week we saw 5 houses that had potential and narrowed it down to 2 houses very quickly. Jason gave his honest opinion on both options and helped us reach a verdict on what we wanted. When we went into contingent on our house Jason was on top of things when it came to having us sign all of the documents and keep us up to date on a daily basis with what was going on with the house. Jason also told us what everything meant that we were signing (because we were first time home buyers we were not sure what anything meant). He was very kind and always had a smile on his face throughout the entire process. Once closing day came on the house, Jason was just as excited as we were and it felt like he was part of this family that was looking for this house. Once closed, Jason handed us the keys and congratulated us with open arms. I have no negative things to say about Jason, he is an amazing realtor and an even better man.
Buyer Review • about 1 month ago

No surprises. All parts of the process was easy.
Had good communication with them and was very helpful and accurate on getting me in to look at listings. Was a great agent to deal with buying and selling both.
Dylan Parry was amazing at communicating throughout this process and was extremely knowledgeable on every single part of the home buying process. He also was great at holding the sellers agent responsible and making sure everyone was going through the process correctly. He was helpful and timely on all questions and responses. I highly recommend him for any and all of you homebuying needs!
Doug and Lisa were very personable realtor who made this process easy to understand as first time home buyers. They were always easy to get a hold of, even on vacation, and never made us feel like we were wasting their time by making them run around every weekend looking at homes.
Stacie isn't your typical realtor, she's top notch in every way. She leveraged her 30+ years of experience to help navigate a VERY complex situation that had many moving parts. She is a great communicator, she's driven and genuine. In the middle of the complexity and layers of details, she went above and beyond and helped get it across the finish line. Thank you, Stacie!
We truly cannot say enough amazing things about working with Molly. Buying a home is stressful enough, but we were purchasing completely out of state while moving from Florida back to Ohio, and Molly made the entire process feel effortless. We had to rely heavily on her judgment, and she went above and beyond in every way possible. She walked through homes for us, gave honest feedback, paid attention to every detail, and ultimately helped us confidently choose the perfect house for our family — without us even being there in person. That level of trust says everything. Her communication was outstanding, her knowledge of the market was invaluable, and she truly treated the process as if she were helping her own family find the right home. At every step she advocated for us, guided us, and made sure we felt comfortable with every decision. Because of Molly’s dedication and professionalism, what could have been a very stressful cross-state move turned into an exciting and smooth experience. We are incredibly grateful for her and would recommend her 1000 times over to anyone looking for a realtor who genuinely cares and delivers true 5-star service. We feel so lucky Molly was on our side through this journey.
I have bought and sold many homes with Stacey. She is honest, reliable and works hard for her clients. I appreciate her. Her expertise, experience and work ethic is unmatched. Thanks Stacey, YOU ROCK!!
Corey listened to what we were looking for, and never tried to sway us in any direction, leaving us to really feel out the houses we looked at. After many existing home tours he suggested looking at a new build, which we were very unsure of, but we agreed. Corey’s suggestion led us to getting a new, bigger, more modern home that we love. Once we decided on the new build he was in constant contact with us thru the whole process. I truly appreciate him and everything he did for us. Thank you Corey.
90% of sellers reported being happy with their sale price in the last 12 months.
Median sale prices for houses is up 3% YoY making it a great time to consult local agents about selling.
21 agents have earned the Price Expert badge - reflecting their ability to achieve a price that meets or exceeds their clients expectations.
Price and performance data by property type for Pickaway County.
The median sale price for single-family properties in Pickaway County is $359.98k, up 3% over the last 12 months. The number of single-family properties sold has decreased by 7% over the last 12 months.
Pickaway County stands out for consistently delivering exceptional satisfaction and strong market results for homeowners.
This is based on voluntary sentiment collected from 19 reviews in Pickaway County over the last 12 months.
Over the 12 months Coldwell Banker Realty have sold 190 properties, which accounts for 12% of the property sales in Pickaway County. This is followed by Red 1 Realty with 97 property sales (6%) and e-Merge Real Estate Excellence at 78 property sales (5%).

Every verified review on RateMyAgent is linked to a specific property transaction, ensuring that the feedback comes from real buyers and sellers. This also allows you to view key property details - such as location and number of bedrooms - so you can find reviews relevant to your own real estate journey. With our verification process, you can trust that the experiences shared are real, reliable, and helpful.
Integrity is at the core of what we do. We conduct rigorous daily integrity checks on all reviews, using multi-stage verification to analyze submission data and behavioral patterns for potential anomalies. Suspicious reviews may be rejected outright or escalated for further scrutiny by our internal team.
Transparency and fairness are core to how RateMyAgent works. While it’s sometimes assumed that only positive reviews appear on our platform, that’s not the case.
Only clients involved in an actual transaction with an agent can leave a review. This helps ensure authenticity and prevents fake or anonymous feedback. Agent's have no control over what’s written - every review, whether positive or critical, is published and remains visible.
Through verified reviews and price satisfaction insights, we highlight top-performing agents who consistently exceed client expectations. All agents can request and collect reviews for free, and subscription status has no impact on rankings or award eligibility. Our Agent of the Year Awards and platform rankings are based solely on verified client feedback and performance. By celebrating excellence fairly and transparently, we help consumers find the best agents with confidence.
Agents who request 100% of vendor reviews, ensuring transparency and a commitment to client satisfaction.
Awarded to agents whose clients report 90% or more of sales meeting price expectations, showcasing expertise in pricing accuracy.
Recognising agents with a strong Review/Sales Ratio, demonstrating consistent performance.
The only awards based purely on verified client reviews, celebrating agents with the most positive feedback combined with sales performance in a specific location.
Discover what sets an agent apart with our AI-powered summary of their verified reviews, available on their profile page.