From 134 reviews overall

Patrick Murphy
Keller Williams Consultants

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Westerville
6456 Goldfinch Drive Westerville
Patrick was extremely communicative and made the stressful process of selling my house so much easier to handle. He was professional, supportive, knowledgeable and kept me informed every step of the way. I would highly recommend him to anyone looking for someone to partner with on buying or selling a home.
State Top 10
ratemyagent award
Ohio2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Westerville2026County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Delaware County2026County Winner
ratemyagent award
Franklin County2026From 12 reviews overall

Karen Newbanks
Cutler Real Estate | Westerville

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Westerville
1120 East College Avenue Westerville
Karen brings the perfect balance of skills, insight, and energy to the selling process. Not only was she able to sell my house for more than expected, she also sold it faster than expected. Her communication was thorough, timely, and fact-based; I had a good understanding of what was going on at all times. There were no unpleasant surprises. Karen's understanding of the market is impeccable, she knew the best time to put the house up for sale, she knew which updates would help sell the house, and she set a pricing strategy that balanced my price requirements with my desire to move quickly. Karen collected offers and helped me evaluate them not only on price but in terms of risk and timing. When I accepted the offer, I was confident I was not leaving anything on the table. Lastly and most importantly, I was never alone in the process; I felt like I was on a team focused on a successful sale and positive experience rather than working with someone that just wanted to complete the transaction.
133 Illinois Avenue Westerville
Karen went above and beyond to help me find a unicorn of a home. She is creative and personable, quick to respond, patient in explaining things I didn’t understand. She makes great suggestions and had excellent referrals for every little thing that popped up during the process. I appreciate how invested she is in the community and admire the relationships she has cultivated with her clients and colleagues in the field. Karen made this overwhelming process smooth and fast!
144 Fairdale Ave Westerville
Working with Karen was a dream! She was extremely responsive, on top of things and extremely helpful. We already moved out of the house we were selling and knowing she was close by to check on the property, stage and make any final touches just took a lot of pressure off of us. This was our first time selling a house and I owe it all to Karen for it going so smoothly. I would highly recommend Karen to anyone looking for a friendly, go-getter and practical realtor.
From 47 reviews overall

Leah & Lyss, I Care Home Group
Cutler Real Estate | I Care Home Group

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Westerville
6701 Miller Paul Road Westerville
Leah and Lyss are just an absolutely amazing team! They managed the sale of our large horse property from ideation to closing with an incredible level of support and guidance. We had a very complex sale that included dealing with the county for potential lot split, navigating a death in our family that delayed our listing timeline, and managing through contract needs with time to move our livestock across country and manage buyer expectations with a farm. We ended up with the perfect buyers for our farm who already love it as much as we have! I cannot imagine how challenging this would have been if we hadn't had the support of these amazing women! Their team consistently delivered excellent service and support. I think the absolute best aspect is the way they truly listen and respond to your needs as an owner at any given time. Stressed about cleaning? No worries, we've got someone who can help with that. Exhausted by minor repairs? Here's an easy path forward. Decision paralysis? Take a breath, we've got you. Leah and Lyss aren't just realtors, they're family, and they make you feel like a protected member of their family. My only regret is that we're moving our life across the country and we won't be able to use them out West! Thank you, Team!
8430 Schleppi Road Westerville
Leah helped us sell our home. Her team did a fantastic job advising us on prepping the house for sale. We ended up selling the home off market which made it much easier for us. Leah knows the market and gave very sound advice. Selling a home can be very stressful but Leah and Lyss are extremely knowledgeable, responsive and professional. I would hire them again and highly recommend!
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Westerville
338 Gentlewind Drive Westerville
I’m a repeat customer of Martha’s and she never disappoints. Martha goes above and beyond as your agent. She knew right away the home style and areas of Columbus that would fit our needs and provided us with several options. She walked us through numerous homes, always making sure we knew she had our needs at the forefront of her mind. When working with Martha, you immediately feel like family. She was always available for a call or a showing, and we consistently felt like she had our best interest at heart. I will work with Martha anytime I buy or sell a house.