From 128 reviews overall

Patrick Murphy
Keller Williams Consultants

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Westerville
6456 Goldfinch Drive Westerville
Patrick was extremely communicative and made the stressful process of selling my house so much easier to handle. He was professional, supportive, knowledgeable and kept me informed every step of the way. I would highly recommend him to anyone looking for someone to partner with on buying or selling a home.
7969 Linksview Cir Westerville
I worked with Patrick Murphy to help me find a new home and then sell my existing home. His professionalism and knowledge of the Westerville market helped me accomplish both in a very short time. After helping me find the right new home, I worked with Patrick to sell my existing home by getting it into contract in just 15 days. In an ever-changing real estate market, this helped take the stress out of this whole process. Patrick is a true professional that guided me through this entire home selling process every step of the way. He has been a pleasure to work with, and I highly recommend him for all of your own real estate needs centered around buying a new home and selling your existing home.
State Top 10
ratemyagent award
Ohio2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Westerville2026County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Delaware County2026County Winner
ratemyagent award
Franklin County2026From 10 reviews overall

Karen Newbanks
Cutler Real Estate | Westerville

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Westerville
133 Illinois Avenue Westerville
Karen went above and beyond to help me find a unicorn of a home. She is creative and personable, quick to respond, patient in explaining things I didn’t understand. She makes great suggestions and had excellent referrals for every little thing that popped up during the process. I appreciate how invested she is in the community and admire the relationships she has cultivated with her clients and colleagues in the field. Karen made this overwhelming process smooth and fast!
144 Fairdale Ave Westerville
Working with Karen was a dream! She was extremely responsive, on top of things and extremely helpful. We already moved out of the house we were selling and knowing she was close by to check on the property, stage and make any final touches just took a lot of pressure off of us. This was our first time selling a house and I owe it all to Karen for it going so smoothly. I would highly recommend Karen to anyone looking for a friendly, go-getter and practical realtor.
1015 Swanton Court Westerville
Karen was great in giving us advice on paint colors, bathroom and kitchen upgrades, and flooring choices. She informed us on places to go for great, reasonable priced kitchen cabinets and carpeting. She did an excellent job on the "light staging" of our house before pictures were taken. Also took care of everything for the open house so that it had many visitors, which resulted in us receiving an offer. We didn't have to worry much, because she gets things done! Thanks, Karen!
From 43 reviews overall

Leah & Lyss, I Care Home Group
Cutler Real Estate | I Care Home Group

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Westerville
8430 Schleppi Road Westerville
Leah helped us sell our home. Her team did a fantastic job advising us on prepping the house for sale. We ended up selling the home off market which made it much easier for us. Leah knows the market and gave very sound advice. Selling a home can be very stressful but Leah and Lyss are extremely knowledgeable, responsive and professional. I would hire them again and highly recommend!
383 Belle Haven Parkway Westerville
Leah and Lyss of Cutler Real Estate are truly excepcional agents. Their expertise in the Westerville market was evident from our first meeting. They guided us through the selling process of our parents' estate with excellent knowledge, transparency, and a marketing strategy that is second to none. They also kept us informed of every development and answered all calls and emails promptly. They are truly the best in their field not only for their professionalism and reliability, but for their genuine care and support throughout the entire process. We recommend Leah and Lyss without reservation and look forward to keeping in touch for all our future realtor needs.
5741 Ridgewood Ave Westerville
Leah and Lyss were amazing from the very beginning. They were extremely clear in laying out the process and what it would take to get our house on the market in time. They were very open in communication and constantly giving us feedback. In what can be seemingly a stressful circumstance, Leah and Lyss were always optimistic and kept such a calming perspective. We were so thankful we chose these two to help sell our home!
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Westerville
338 Gentlewind Drive Westerville
I’m a repeat customer of Martha’s and she never disappoints. Martha goes above and beyond as your agent. She knew right away the home style and areas of Columbus that would fit our needs and provided us with several options. She walked us through numerous homes, always making sure we knew she had our needs at the forefront of her mind. When working with Martha, you immediately feel like family. She was always available for a call or a showing, and we consistently felt like she had our best interest at heart. I will work with Martha anytime I buy or sell a house.