
(81 reviews)



Reviews in Columbus
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Buyer of 204 Jackson Street, Columbus
I haven't bought a home in decades. And, this transaction was particularly personal. Jeff guided me through every step. He was smart, patient and always had time to answer every one of my questions. When it comes to German Village, there is simply no one who knows the market better. I am grateful to have had the very best agent at my side for this entire process.
Seller of 294 East Stewart Avenue, Columbus
We sincerely appreciated Marilyn and her staff.. they were very responsive and helpful through all our complications. Our buying expereince was very smooth - and our selling experience was bumpy, but with Marilyn's help we got through it all! Would recommend this agency to others selling - especially an old house!

(20 reviews)


Reviews in Columbus
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Seller of 387 West 2nd Avenue, Columbus
Stephen was fun and serious to work with on selling our home. He was always available to answer questions and make pertinent suggestions. And at the crux of deal he was savvy and sensible. Greatly appreciate him! Thank you, Stephen!
Seller of 674 Park Street, Columbus
Jim Meyer helped us sell our condo in the Short North on Goodale Park. He went above and beyond in meeting with other agents who were showing the property so he could explain the parking and show them the private gym. He thoroughly knows the neighborhood and community, we would highly recommend working with him for any of your real estate needs!
Buyer of 387 West 2nd Avenue, Columbus
While buying my first home, I was not represented by a buyer’s agent. Stephen was the seller’s agent, but he was so kind, helpful, and patient with me throughout the whole purchase process. Any questions I had, he was quick to respond. When the sale went through, I felt genuinely supported and that he was happy for me. If/when I go to sell my property, Stephen will be my first phone call!
National Top 100
United States2026
(163 reviews)

Reviews in Columbus
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Buyer of 1121 Afton Road, Columbus
I was a first-time home buyer with some pretty specific priorities for my first house. Chris worked well with me to identify a number of houses that met my criteria. Once I found a house I liked, he offered a lot of useful advice for putting together a bid that would win in a competitive market without overspending. Throughout the closing process, he explained each step and made sure I was clear on what to expect and what I needed to do. From start to finish, Chris was incredibly responsive and helpful, responding quickly to messages with answers to questions and solutions to problems. I'll be recommending him to anyone looking for a house in the Columbus area and wouldn't hesitate to work with him again.
Buyer of 11/4625 Wenham Park, Columbus
Tiffany is very professional, quick to set up showings, and responded quickly to all my questions very thoroughly and went above and beyond for all issues. She was very patient in helping me find my current condo. I highly recommend her and would work with her again.
State Top 3
Ohio2026National Top 100
United States2026Region Top 10
Midwest Region2026
(17 reviews)

Reviews in Columbus
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Buyer of 6886 Lakebrook Boulevard, Columbus
Was extremely helpful in making the right decision with my home purchase. I had been looking in a particular area for a few years without any luck. Neil made sure that we found the right home for me. His knowledge of the market is unmatched, and he has all the right insights that any buyer or seller would be looking for. His attention to detail, his responsiveness and his insight is something that is seemingly more and more rare in today's market. You are in the best hands with the Mathias Team! I cannot recommend the team enough!
Buyer of 4459 Amwood St, Columbus
Jackson from day one was making sure my home was everything I asked for he checked in often always answered when I called for questions he is friendly and helped me find my home and was with me for every step
National Top 100
United States2026
(38 reviews)


Reviews in Columbus
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Seller of 376 Galloway Ridge Drive, Columbus
They provided great communication and were very responsive to our needs and questions. Conner went above the call of his duties in my opinion. Due to the fact that we now live out of Ohio, when we encounter a problem (i.e. Broken pipe, Mold in basement) he helped us by getting someone to come and fix the problem. Conner and Stacy are a valuble asset to the Company in my eyes. If we ever move back to Ohio they will be my first point of contact for a Realtor.
Buyer of 3766 Dunlane Ct, Columbus
Conner is a great realtor. He is not pushy like some. He understands client needs and has excellent connections with different lenders and insurance agents. I used some of his connections when purchasing my property. I would love to do business with him again.
Seller of C/2357 Woodbrook Circle South, Columbus
Stacy helped me with the sale of my aunts condo after she experienced a traumatic brain bleed which left her unable to care for herself. Stacy was knowledgeable and extremely helpful in every aspect. I would not have anyone but her as a realtor.
National Top 100
United States2026Region Top 10
Midwest Region2026
(16 reviews)
Reviews in Columbus
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Seller of 311 Chatham Rd, Columbus
We’ve worked with Jorie for years, and she recently handled the sale of our home with absolute expertise. She put together a brilliant strategy that generated a massive amount of traffic right away—we started showings on Thursday and Friday, hosted an open house on Saturday, and had multiple offers on the table by Sunday. Jorie managed all the offers seamlessly and kept the entire process completely stress-free. She made what could have been a chaotic weekend feel incredibly easy, organized, and successful. We cannot recommend her enough!
Buyer of 518 East Royal Forest Boulevard, Columbus
I've had the pleasure to work with Kirsten on multiple housing transactions over the years, both as a buyer and seller. I've found her to be easy to work with, very responsive and a true advocate for my needs with the transaction. When I find myself in need of an agent again, she'll be the person I reach out to without hesitation.

(7 reviews)
Reviews in Columbus
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Seller of 227 South Chesterfield Road, Columbus
When I first met with Mark to discuss the selling of my home I felt immediately comfortable with his knowledge and expertise in this task. There wasn't a question too simple or difficult that he couldn't answer. He was spot on with the asking price and the open houses where we were ask to be out of town. He was always available with any questions we had and made this such a smooth experience. Mark's guidance and help to resolve some emergencies we had before going on the market were quick and calmly resolved.

(9 reviews)

Reviews in Columbus
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Buyer of 1076 Rendezvous Lane, Columbus
An absolutely wonderful duo that makes the extremely difficult process of purchasing a home seem effortless. Their expertise and insight were invaluable to the negotiations, which ended up being a very favorable and fair outcome for both sides. Highly, highly recommend, especially for first-time buyers.

(4 reviews)
Reviews in Columbus
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Buyer of 171 Clinton Heights Avenue, Columbus
John made the process so much easier. I wanted a sewer line inspection done and the company I hired never showed up. He found someone to come out immediately and conducted the inspection on my behalf. Found a local mowing service and had a list of contacts for other jobs. Highly recommend him!