
(83 reviews)



Reviews in Franklin County
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Seller of 7652 North Goodrich Square, New Albany
Jeff is so knowledgeable and experienced. He gave us great advice and found us the perfect house in German Village before it even hit the market. Jeff’s connections and knowledge are invaluable, particularly if you are selling or buying in German Village.
Buyer of 204 Jackson Street, Columbus
I haven't bought a home in decades. And, this transaction was particularly personal. Jeff guided me through every step. He was smart, patient and always had time to answer every one of my questions. When it comes to German Village, there is simply no one who knows the market better. I am grateful to have had the very best agent at my side for this entire process.

(25 reviews)


Reviews in Franklin County
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Buyer of 153 North 22nd Street, Columbus
Stephen was top notch at every step of the home buying process. He is very knowledgeable about the city and always had great recommendations and advice. His dedication and commitment made the purchase a breeze. I would highly recommend him.
Buyer of 6100 Reno Road, Huber Ridge
We couldn’t recommend Stephen enough! He stuck with us for months through several hurdles and never stopped being supportive, patient, and helpful. He truly went above and beyond and fought for our dream home every step of the way. He was kind, knowledgeable, and always had our best interests in mind. We are so grateful for everything he did for us and would highly recommend Stephen to anyone looking to buy a home!
Buyer of 361 E Dunedin Rd, Columbus
Jim was a pleasure to work with from start to finish on our purchase in the Clintonville neighborhood. His patient but down to earth style was perfect for navigating the complexities of our home search. His replies to our many inquiries, questions, and concerns were all prompt, thorough, and very professional. We found it easy to schedule house showings with him and to talk about strategies for preparing offers. We quickly learned to trust his opinions as information or suggestions he provided ultimately checked out to be consistent and accurate time and time again. One of the things I most appreciated in my experience working with Jim was his ability to provide clear, concise explanations while giving us the space we needed to ultimately make our own decisions. Throughout the process I felt that Jim cares deeply about his work. And I’m happy to report I’m loving my new home!
National Top 100
United States2026
(19 reviews)

Reviews in Franklin County
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Buyer of 3302 Scioto Bluff Avenue, Dublin
We had such a great experience working with Neil and his team! He was incredibly helpful, easy to work with, and always quick to respond whenever we had questions. He kept everything moving and made the whole process feel easy and stress-free. We really appreciated everything he did for us and would absolutely recommend Neil and his team!
Buyer of 6886 Lakebrook Boulevard, Columbus
Was extremely helpful in making the right decision with my home purchase. I had been looking in a particular area for a few years without any luck. Neil made sure that we found the right home for me. His knowledge of the market is unmatched, and he has all the right insights that any buyer or seller would be looking for. His attention to detail, his responsiveness and his insight is something that is seemingly more and more rare in today's market. You are in the best hands with the Mathias Team! I cannot recommend the team enough!
National Top 100
United States2026
(167 reviews)

Reviews in Franklin County
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Seller of 1529 Fahlander Drive South, Columbus
We had such a great experience working with Chris as our seller’s agent during our relocation. Selling a home while going through a move can be stressful, but Chris made the process so much easier for us. From the start, we really appreciated how honest and straightforward he was. He gave us realistic advice about pricing and put together a strategy focused on getting our home sold, rather than just telling us what we wanted to hear or suggesting an unrealistic price. We were under contract within 24 hours of listing, so his strategy clearly worked! Chris was also great about communicating with us. He was always responsive when we had questions and made sure we had the information we needed in a timely manner. We never felt like we were left wondering what was happening or what we needed to do next. We’re really grateful for Chris’s guidance and honesty throughout the process. We felt like he genuinely had our best interests in mind, and we would absolutely recommend him to anyone looking for an agent they can trust.
Seller of 2732 Minerva Lake Road, Minerva Park
Chris called every play in this game of selling right on track. From timing of the listing, to pricing & presentation. He completely had our best interest and explained any inquiries we had to detail and either an example or reason. This guy is absolutely stellar at his profession & made it a bearable activity
Seller of 5011 Smothers Road, Westerville
Tiffany Bafford is what I think all Real Estate Agents should be. She took a very unique property like ours and found the right solution. She brought in the right partners and gave us many options to help US make the right decision for our personal situation. That was an auction. If you know me I am not a risk taker! This felt risky! That said she brought us the experts to tell us why it was a GOOD RISK! She struck while the iron was hot and the timing was good. We put it on the market and went through the pain staking steps to prep our house of 14 year and get it ready to show. She also took us to see a few houses. At this time if you did not make and offer at the point of seeing the house you lost the opportunity. She found us a great home in the right community that kept us in the same school district and met our unique needs. She suggested a financing person that could talk us though selling an buying a house in this crazy market. He was great. We have now been in our new place for 3 months. We sold prior to the auction and did not have to under go the stress of the actual auction. I believe this was due to Tiffany's Marketing and connections in the market with other realtors! She was able to vet out the right interest and find us the right buyer. She navigated this like a pro and stepped us through it. I was a nervous wreck. This is not a reflection of Tiffany's support it is just my personality on big life decisions and purchases. Tiff got us through it and put us in a great spot. I will be forever grateful for her professionalism and support. In my opinion she was able to thread the needle on the sale of our old home and the purchase of our new home. I don't easily endorse sales people especially Realtors!!! Tiffany Bafford has my full endorsement!!! She is the gold standard for what a great realtor should be!
State Top 3
Ohio2026National Top 100
United States2026Region Top 10
Midwest Region2026
(20 reviews)
Reviews in Franklin County
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Buyer of 3111 Grange Hill Place, Columbus
Rion done a great job finding the houses that meet our requirements and found us a great home in Dublin. We appreciate all the work that Cutler Realty did and I would definitely recommend them to anyone in the market for looking for a house.
Buyer of 242 East 4th Avenue, Columbus
We had a great experience as first time home buyers. Jorie is very knowledgeable and genuine. She helped us every step of the way which made a huge difference during the closing process. I will recommend her to my friends and family!

(40 reviews)


Reviews in Franklin County
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
National Top 100
United States2026Region Top 10
Midwest Region2026
(13 reviews)
Reviews in Franklin County
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Seller of 6188 Michaelkenney Lane, Columbus
Working with Eric was hands down the best decision we made during our move. From day one, he was organized, responsive, and genuinely invested in helping us find the right fit. Every time we had a question about a property, neighborhood, or inspection detail, Eric gave us a clear, honest answer right away. What stood out most was how smoothly he handled the entire process. Negotiations were firm and professional, the paperwork was straightforward, and we never felt rushed into making a decision. Having someone like Eric in your corner who knows the local market inside and out takes a massive amount of stress off your shoulders. We closed on time, felt great about the final price, and could not be happier with the outcome. If you are buying or selling, do yourself a favor and work with Eric.
Seller of 3236 Yellow Finch Way, Columbus
We honestly couldn’t have asked for a better realtor than Eric! From day one, he was incredibly easy to work with, always available when we had questions, and never made us feel like we were bothering him. He gave us honest, sound advice throughout the entire process and really took the time to understand what was important to us. One of the things we appreciated most was how well Eric helped us narrow in on what we actually wanted. He listened to us, understood our priorities, and made the whole process feel much less overwhelming. He was also fantastic when it came time to negotiate and helped us get an amazing deal on our new home. We truly felt like he was in our corner and looking out for our best interests every step of the way. Buying a home can be stressful, but having Eric on our side made such a huge difference. We’re extremely grateful for everything he did for us and would 100% recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. 10/10!

(5 reviews)
Reviews in Franklin County
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Buyer of 651 Hibbs Road, Lockbourne
Kay is a phenomenal real estate agent! We have used her services multiple times and she never fails to impress. She is knowledgeable, professional, and very diligent. Never a detail missed! We would highly recommend her for all of your real estate needs!
Buyer of 651 Hibbs Road, Lockbourne
Kay is always so knowledgeable and on top of all of the details! She has now helped us with multiple purchases and sales. She professionally represents her clients as both buyers and sellers. She’s your agent if you want everything to go smoothly and quickly! She has all of our future business.
Buyer of 6145 Honey Farm Way, Grove City
My husband and I had a great experience working with Nora to buy and sell our homes in Central Ohio. Nora was always very professional and she is extremely knowledgeable about the market. She made the process of buying and selling our homes very easy. Nora has contacts with fantastic professionals in all areas of real estate that make the process of buying and selling a home go smoothly from start to finish. If you're looking to buy or sell a home, I highly recommend that you contact Nora Van Cleave.
National Top 100
United States2026
(10 reviews)
Reviews in Franklin County
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Buyer of 1151 Scarlet Court, Westerville
Rosalyn was so great throughout this process. She was very easy to get ahold of and fast to respond. She was also very understanding of us needing to manage our small children with us during all of our tours. We toured several homes over the course of months to finally find the right fit and are so excited about our new home!
Buyer of 3616 Glenbar Drive, Columbus
Rosalyn has represented me for the purchase of three properties. She has decades of experience and knowledge which are priceless. Her ability to negotiate and quickly calculate renovation costs have helped me make informed real estate decisions. Choose Rosalyn.
National Top 100
United States2026