From 92 reviews overall

The Cheek Team
The Cheek Team - A Boutique Brokerage

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Calabash
UNIT 23/221 Woodlands Way Calabash
Over the years I have dealt with a few realtors. The dozen or so from buying and selling or renting can’t even come close to the professional and true concerns for the customer as the whole Cheek Team! From the first encounter with Carlo I knew that he was the guy that I most likely would used. The other realtors couldn’t even come close to trying to understand what I wanted not what they thought I should want in this market at this time. Met one of the owners at the second meeting and smooth sailing from there on. Back office as nice if not nicer. Quick response to questions and concerns. I only wish I had more properties to sell!!
From 100 reviews overall

Colleen Teifer
Silver Coast Properties

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Calabash
Lot 142/703 E Chatman Dr NW Calabash
I have had several transactions with Colleen over the past few years. She is easy to work with, communication is fantastic and she knows what she is doing. She is in tune with the market and its trends and knows how to adjust. She does everything she can to make the process as seamless as possible for her clients, which is appreciated. Don't hesitate, just call Colleen!
1227 Hayworth Lane Northwest Calabash
Mary and I met Colleen in 2024. I told her that we weren’t buying at this time and we just wanted to see different developments in different areas. We told her what we were and weren’t looking for. Colleen had patience with us, returned calls, kept us updated on different places, gave us her opinion with the negatives and positives in different areas. We felt very comfortable working with her as she listened to all our needs (and there were plenty) Colleen will definitely work hard and do her best to assist. Needless to say, she found us the perfect place to call home.
764 Heather Glen Lane Calabash
Colleen has extensive knowledge of the area and neighborhoods, which we appreciated as we planned our move from out of state. She was thorough in her preparation to review properties within our parameters, mapped out the properties for showings, and maximized our schedule. She was flexible, even giving up some of her personal time, when we needed to see a property again on short notice. When the time came to do so, she provided all the information we needed to make an informed offer to get us the best possible deal on our new home. But she didn't stop there - she was excellent in her communication from offer to to closing, helping us with getting the inspection, having work done (at the expense of the seller) to correct some things found on the inspection, and so much more. She was always quick to respond to our questions, very pleasant to work with, and so very helpful. She really made our experience a breeze - even from 500 miles away! We highly recommend Colleen for your buying or selling needs - you won't be disappointed!
County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Brunswick County2026Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Calabash
966 Parelli Way Northwest Calabash
Carlo was outstanding to work with from start to finish. He is incredibly knowledgeable, professional, and truly dedicated to his clients. What stood out most to me was his responsiveness and attention to detail. He was always available to answer questions, provide guidance, and make sure everything stayed on track. Since we live in New Jersey and were purchasing a home in North Carolina, we relied on Carlo even more than usual, and he absolutely delivered. He consistently went out of his way to keep us informed, even sending photos of the house throughout the different phases so we could feel connected and confident every step of the way. He made what can often be a stressful process feel smooth and manageable. Carlo took the time to understand exactly what we were looking for and worked hard to make it happen. His experience and insight were invaluable, and we always felt like we were in good hands. I would highly recommend Carlo to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. He truly goes above and beyond and genuinely cares about his clients.
966 Parelli Way Northwest Calabash
Carlo was absolutely exceptional to work with from start to finish. He is not only an incredible realtor, but a genuinely wonderful person who truly cares about his clients. From day one, he took his time with us, never rushing the process, and patiently showed us numerous properties until we found the perfect piece of land. His knowledge, insight, and recommendations were spot-on and made such a difference in helping us make the right decisions. Carlo is extremely personable and easy to talk to, which made the entire experience enjoyable and stress-free. No matter the time or question, he was always available, responsive, and thorough with his follow-up. Thanks to Carlo, we found a location in Calabash that we absolutely love, and we just closed on our property this Monday. We couldn’t be happier. If you are looking for a realtor who is dedicated, attentive, knowledgeable, and truly goes above and beyond, Carlo is simply the best. We are so grateful for everything he did for us and would recommend him without hesitation to anyone!
UNIT 23/221 Woodlands Way Calabash
Over the years I have dealt with a few realtors. The dozen or so from buying and selling or renting can’t even come close to the professional and true concerns for the customer as the whole Cheek Team! From the first encounter with Carlo I knew that he was the guy that I most likely would used. The other realtors couldn’t even come close to trying to understand what I wanted not what they thought I should want in this market at this time. Met one of the owners at the second meeting and smooth sailing from there on. Back office as nice if not nicer. Quick response to questions and concerns. I only wish I had more properties to sell!!
From 18 reviews overall

Suzanne M Polino
ASAP Realty

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Calabash
468 Goldenrod Terrace Northwest Calabash
Suzanne is not only an amazing agent but also an awesome lady. Her attention to details is amazing even to someone like me who notices everything. She goes above and beyond to make sure your home is in A+ condition prior to your closing date down to the most miniscule detail. We highly recommend enlisting Suzanne if you are considering a new build or an existing dwelling. SHE'S AWESOME!!!
801 Marsh Rose Path Northwest Calabash
We thoroughly enjoyed working with Suzanne. She was extremely knowledgeable of the area, super responsive, and very friendly. We were referred to her by a local gentleman, and we couldn't be happier we called her. Thank you Suzanne for everything!
L-14/2039 Manor Parc Drive Calabash
We cannot recommend Suzanne enough! From start to finish, Suzy did an outstanding job helping us navigate the exciting process of building our new home in Coastal North Carolina from out of state. Suzy went above and beyond to find us the perfect location and was incredibly knowledgeable about the local market and new construction opportunities. Her expertise was invaluable in identifying the ideal plot and connecting us with reputable builders. What truly set her apart was her unwavering support throughout the entire paperwork process. Building a new home involves a significant amount of documentation, and she made it seamless, explaining every step, answering all our questions, and ensuring everything was handled efficiently and accurately. Her proactive communication and picture updates of the build kept us informed and reassured, making the building process a little less stressful! Thanks to Suzy, we are now settling into our dream home, and we are so grateful for her professionalism, dedication, and genuine care. If you're looking for a realtor who will truly go the extra mile, especially for a new build, look no further than Suzanne M. Polino!
County Winner
ratemyagent award
Brunswick County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Calabash2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Carolina Shores2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Ocean Isle Beach2026