Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Hancock County
3756 North Forest Lane Greenfield
Frank and Brenda Tinsley demonstrated exceptional market knowledge from start to finish. They understood the local trends, guided us toward realistic options that matched our priorities, and helped us navigate the competitive landscape with confidence. Their communication was one of their greatest strengths—clear, prompt, and steady, often checking in daily so we always knew what was happening and what to expect next. Their professionalism set them apart. They handled every detail with care, arranged additional showings when we needed them, walked us through the paperwork step by step, and offered thoughtful suggestions based on years of experience. At no point did they make us feel rushed or like our questions were a burden. Patient, dependable, and genuinely committed to making the process smooth, they provided exactly the level of support every buyer hopes for. Because of the outstanding experience we had with them, there’s no question who we will call when it’s time to sell our previous home. The Tinsley Team has earned our trust for every step ahead.
764 Oak Drive Spring Lake
Frank is an excellent realtor. His background is impressive. He is very knowledgeable and answered all my questions. Very interpersonal. Definitely recommend. I am a first time home owner and even though I was clueless and my anxiety was high...Frank Definitely calm my nerves and told me exactly play by play what to expect. He is one of those realtors that you will appreciate forever.
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Hancock County
2203 South CR-800 West New Palestine
I have know Charlene for over 13 years! She is an awesome agent both times I have worked with. We sold our house in just 2 days even before our open house. Thank you Charlene for all your hard work and being a terrific agent!
From 4 reviews overall

Erica Mayfield
Keller Williams Indpls Metro N
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Hancock County
6467 Deer Crossing Boulevard McCordsville
We recently sold our home with Erica Mayfield, and we couldn’t be happier with the experience. Erica was actually our realtor when we first purchased the home, so it meant a lot to work with her again when it came time to sell due to a work relocation. She truly saw our vision and helped bring it to life throughout the entire process. One of the things we appreciated most about Erica is that she always showed up for us—whether it was answering questions, guiding us through decisions, or being there when we needed her most. Her knowledge, dedication, and genuine care made what could have been a stressful process feel smooth and manageable. We’re so grateful for everything she’s done for us and would highly recommend Erica to anyone looking to buy or sell a home!
From 9 reviews overall
Teresa Ott
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Indiana Realty (Indianapolis, 46240)
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Hancock County
6532 West Silverthorne Drive McCordsville
Teresa helped us buy our home in Carmel last year, and we called her right away when we were contemplating to sell our home in McCordsville. She did a comprehensive market analysis that helped us prioritize our renovation projects, and guided us throughout the process of getting it listed and sold. In addition to her professionalism and expertise, Teresa has a heart to serve her clients and it is a joy to work with her!