Brenda Tinsley

Brenda Tinsley

REALTOR® / Broker at Highgarden Real Estate member of Tinsley Realty
(IN): RB22002213NAR: 396544210
  •   5   (42 reviews)

Brenda's sales performance at a glance

See how Brenda has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

10
Reviews
3
Properties for sale
34
Sold properties
$342k
Average sale price
$13.7m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

About Brenda

I have been a part of Real Estate since 1996 and am proud to be a member of the Tinsley Realty team at Highgarden Real Estate. Frank Tinsley (my partner in life and Real Estate) and I work together on all deals; so you receive two experts for the price of one! We've owned, renovated and sold more than 60 investment properties, owned our own brokerage for 16 years and have helped buyers, sellers and investors all over the state of Indiana. Our main focus areas are the fourteen Central Indiana counties, and we'll exceed $100 million in gross sales this year! With my certification in Real Estate Property Management, along with my extensive experience working with buyers, sellers and investors, I have the necessary skills to service my clients with exceptional expertise, passion and a true partnership to find them the best property at the best price to meet their unique needs. I can also tap into Frank's extensive knowledge and expertise with him having been the a CFO of a Major Commercial Real Estate Developer (22 years); and the COO for a wealth-management firm (9 years); while also being an expert in Residential Real Estate for over 35 years. On a personal level, Brenda and Frank Tinsley have been married for more than 39 years. They have four daughters (four son-in-laws), seven grandchildren (with #8 incoming) and two dogs. Together, they love Real Estate, traveling the roads and looking at all types of houses from 800 sq ft bungalows, to 1800s farm homes, mid-century modern; traditional american, craftsman, and everything in between. Our favorite past-time is our love for spending time with our extensive family, traveling, the outdoors swimming, hiking, and our true passion for helping others. Brenda graduated from Ball State University with Bachelors in Administration; majoring in Finance and Real Estate Property Management where she received her PM Certification. Designations/Certifications: Senior Real Estate Specialist (SRES®) Accredited Buyers Representative (ABR®) Real Estate Property Management Affiliations: Member of the National Association of Realtors (NAR) Member of the Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of Realtors (MIBOR) Member of Kiwanis Fishers and McCordsville UMC as Lay Leader

Brenda's reviews

  5  
Brenda has 42 reviewsacross 28 different locations, showing 6.
Review Brenda
Brenda's qualities as told by our client reviews: detail-oriented, stress-free process, reliable, honest, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Great agents!
30 days ago
Great agents!

I've sold 2 houses and purchased 1 house with Frank and Brenda as my agents. These 2 go above and beyond to make the process seamless! If you want an agent to work hard for you, explain the steps and give you open and honest opinions along the way, you cannot go wrong with Frank and Brenda.

Buyer review
They had my best interest first.
2 months ago
They had my best interest first.

They were, and continue to be, incredibly responsive throughout the process. They also did an excellent job accommodating my budget while still identifying high-quality properties. I especially appreciated Frank’s expertise in manufacturing and his deep knowledge of the Indianapolis area and its neighborhoods.

Seller review
Terrific Agent!
4 months ago
Terrific Agent!

Frank represented the sellers when we purchased our home and we were so impressed we asked him to represent us when we sold. He maintained excellent communication, had terrific contacts in the industry, negotiated well on our behalf, and ultimately brought off a successful transaction. 10/10, would hire again.

Buyer review
Great Service
5 months ago
Great Service

Frank was pleasant and very easy to work with. I had a great time having him show me the houses and help making the offer that resulted in me getting what I wanted.

Buyer review
The best realtors ever
6 months ago
The best realtors ever

Frank & Brenda were the best to work with. I'm a first time home buyer and they were so kind, knowledgeable, reassuring, and professional. I was very anxious at the start but they reassured me at every step of the process and were so helpful. They're great negotiators and made the whole process stress free.

Buyer review
Great Realtors
6 months ago
Great Realtors

Excellent knowledge, professionalism and people skills.

Show all 42 reviews
map

Brenda's properties

Brenda has 3 properties for sale and sold 34 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldJun 30, 2026
$316,495
15126 Swallow Falls Way
Fishers IN 46037
3
3
2
Townhouse
Listing courtesy of Compass Indiana, LLC and Highgarden Real Estate
SoldJun 26, 2026
$360,000
3680 North CR-950 East
Brownsburg IN 46112
4
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Sold It Realty Group and Highgarden Real Estate
SoldJun 22, 2026
$520,000
8415 Hidden Meadow Pass
McCordsville IN 46055
4
3
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Redfin Corporation and Highgarden Real Estate
For Sale
$248,000
9214 E 206th St
Noblesville IN 46062
3
1
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Highgarden Real Estate
Show all 37 properties

Brenda's sold properties

Brenda has sold 34 properties in the past 12 months, showing 4.

Enter your property details to filter

I'm selling a
bedroom
with
bathrooms in
Property imageAddressBedroomsBathroomsCarparksProperty TypeClosing PriceDate Sold
15126 Swallow Falls Way, Fishers, IN, 46037
15126 Swallow Falls Way
Fishers IN 46037
3
3
2
Townhouse$316,495Jun 30, 2026
3680 North CR-950 East, Brownsburg, IN, 46112
3680 North CR-950 East
Brownsburg IN 46112
4
3
2
Single-Family$360,000Jun 26, 2026
8415 Hidden Meadow Pass, McCordsville, IN, 46055
8415 Hidden Meadow Pass
McCordsville IN 46055
4
3
3
Single-Family$520,000Jun 22, 2026
11533 Sterrett Boulevard, Lawrence, IN, 46236
11533 Sterrett Boulevard
Lawrence IN 46236
3
3
2
Single-Family$325,000Jun 15, 2026

Browse nearby locations

SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent