Back Shelby County

167 real estate agents in Shelby County

Sorted by most reviews for agents in Shelby County over the past 12 months.
View Amy Limpus' profileAmy Limpus

Amy Limpus

5.0 (8 reviews)
  • Avg. sale price $241k
  • Sold (as lead agent) 23
  • Properties for sale 13

Accolades

Contact
View Trish Meier's profileTrish Meier

Trish Meier

5.0 (56 reviews)
  • Avg. sale price N/A
  • Sold (as lead agent) 1
  • Properties for sale 0
Anonymous5 months ago

Seller of 1008 Balto Drive, Shelbyville

Excellent

Trish has been excellent and very helpful with the selling process. She continues to answer questions and calls even after the sale.

Accolades

Price Expert
Price Expert

State Winner

Indiana2026

National Top 100

United States2026

Region Top 20

Midwest Region2026

County Winner

Bartholomew County2026

County Winner

Johnson County2026

City Winner

Columbus2026
Contact
Takes 40 seconds No address needed yet

Selling in Shelby County? Pick the agents you want to hear from — we'll call you first.

Start with my neighborhood
View Crystal Anderson's profileCrystal Anderson

Crystal Anderson

5.0 (51 reviews)
  • Avg. sale price N/A
  • Sold (as lead agent) 1
  • Properties for sale 0
Shasta4 months ago

Buyer of 120 1st Street, Shelbyville

Great experience!

Crystal was great to work with. Rain or shine (or in this case snow) she showed up and was very knowledgeable about the houses we were checking out and the process itself. She communicated every change, every document and answered every question we had. I truly appreciate her for making this experience so much smoother than I had anticipated.

Accolades

Price Expert
Price Expert
Trusted Agent
Trusted Agent
Top 20%
Top 20%

State Top 10

Indiana2026

County Top 5

Bartholomew County2026

County Winner

Jefferson County2026

City Winner

Madison2026
Contact
View Carol Bullock-Puckett's profileCarol Bullock-Puckett

Carol Bullock-Puckett

5.0 (19 reviews)
  • Avg. sale price N/A
  • Sold (as lead agent) 1
  • Properties for sale 0
Duane Bowden7 months ago

Buyer of 2293 Marjorie Way, Shelbyville

Five star performance

Carol was amazing . She was especially helpful and knowledgeable in answering all of my concerns, and always followed up on all of my questions as well as suggesting ideas on how I could proceed in deciding on different styles of houses and discussing the pros and cons on each locations and giving me good advice which she had learned over her many years as an agent. Thank you Carol for all your help.

Accolades

Contact
1 - 9 of 167

Cities in Shelby County

Suburbs in Shelby County

View nearby Counties

© 2026 RateMyAgent