

Frank W. Tinsley
REALTOR® | Broker | Team Leader
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 3756 North Forest Lane, Greenfield
Frank and Brenda Tinsley demonstrated exceptional market knowledge from start to finish. They understood the local trends, guided us toward realistic options that matched our priorities, and helped us navigate the competitive landscape with confidence. Their communication was one of their greatest strengths—clear, prompt, and steady, often checking in daily so we always knew what was happening and what to expect next. Their professionalism set them apart. They handled every detail with care, arranged additional showings when we needed them, walked us through the paperwork step by step, and offered thoughtful suggestions based on years of experience. At no point did they make us feel rushed or like our questions were a burden. Patient, dependable, and genuinely committed to making the process smooth, they provided exactly the level of support every buyer hopes for. Because of the outstanding experience we had with them, there’s no question who we will call when it’s time to sell our previous home. The Tinsley Team has earned our trust for every step ahead.
Buyer of 764 Oak Drive, Spring Lake
Frank is an excellent realtor. His background is impressive. He is very knowledgeable and answered all my questions. Very interpersonal. Definitely recommend. I am a first time home owner and even though I was clueless and my anxiety was high...Frank Definitely calm my nerves and told me exactly play by play what to expect. He is one of those realtors that you will appreciate forever.


Brenda Tinsley
REALTOR® | Broker
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 3756 North Forest Lane, Greenfield
Frank and Brenda Tinsley demonstrated exceptional market knowledge from start to finish. They understood the local trends, guided us toward realistic options that matched our priorities, and helped us navigate the competitive landscape with confidence. Their communication was one of their greatest strengths—clear, prompt, and steady, often checking in daily so we always knew what was happening and what to expect next. Their professionalism set them apart. They handled every detail with care, arranged additional showings when we needed them, walked us through the paperwork step by step, and offered thoughtful suggestions based on years of experience. At no point did they make us feel rushed or like our questions were a burden. Patient, dependable, and genuinely committed to making the process smooth, they provided exactly the level of support every buyer hopes for. Because of the outstanding experience we had with them, there’s no question who we will call when it’s time to sell our previous home. The Tinsley Team has earned our trust for every step ahead.


Erik Wentz
Broker | Licensed Real Estate Agent | Team Leader
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Seller of 9731 Violet Circle, Indianapolis
We cannot say enough great things about Erik and the exceptional job he did selling our home. As first-time sellers, the process felt overwhelming at times, but Erik seemed to know exactly what we needed before we even asked. He used a variety of smart, effective strategies that resulted in a successful listing, accepted offer, inspections, and closing—all within just short timeline! His level of communication was absolutely perfect: always clear, timely, and reassuring. Erik was highly sensitive to our needs while also being very transparent about what was required to sell our home quickly and successfully. Beyond the sale itself, he went above and beyond by helping us plan our move, recommending excellent packers and cleaners, and even guiding us as we plan our future purchase in a new city. We would wholeheartedly recommend Erik to anyone looking for a buyer’s or seller’s agent. He is truly the best of the best in Indy, and we are incredibly grateful to have worked with him.
Buyer of 9011 Harrison Run Ct, Indianapolis
Erik did the best job I could ask for in helping us through the home search buying process. He made it extremely easy to understand and process information, and the things that went over my head in this experience Erik took care of for me. I really appreciate Erik's approach, he does a great job of sharing his opinion while not overstepping, making me feel very comfortable when making decisions. We were able to find our perfect home based on Erik's curated list of houses on the market that he thought we would like to visit. Even post closing, Erik is doing a fantastic job keeping us informed and answering any other questions we have. 10/10 would recommend
Seller of 555 Grand Woods Dr, Indianapolis
Erik is one of the most friendly, trustworthy, and professional person I've ever met and worked with. To this day, we've bought and sold 4 homes together, with one more coming up. As a buyer's agent, he works day and night (sometimes too much) to make sure you're well protected and satisfied with the home you're buying. He told me things I didn't think about; shared his insights and opinions, all without being pushy and trying to get me to buy the house, so I never felt pressured in the process. As a seller's agent, he has been phenomenal from the moment I decided to list the house all up until closing and post-closing. He helped coordinate repairs, cleaning (performed the cleaning himself, at 11 PM), picture, staging, negotiation, open-house, etc., even where I was out of the country for weeks. At some points, it felt like he's selling his own house from all the work and effort he puts into it, and that was really assuring for me. If you're looking for an honest, knowledgeable, insightful, and professional realtor, Erik is your person!

James C. Abner
Team Leader | REALTOR®
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 431 W 4th St, Greenfield
I came to the buying process having never purchased a home on my own before Jim was very patient with my questions and my budget. He gave me sound advice and wisdom throughout the process. Thank you for your help Jim I've owned my home for 6 months now and am grateful for it everyday!