From 17 reviews overall

Jennifer Blatz
Cutler Real Estate | New Albany

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Franklin County
65 Haddam Pl W Westerville
We interviewed a number of agents and Jenni stood out by her knowledge of the housing market in our area, including the best way to position our home for a quick sell at the top price. Her financial background gave us a measure of confidence. Jenni is super responsive to messages and emails. She goes over and beyond in helping the seller. We had a contract on the first day which was well over asking.
3950 Logan Court Hilliard
I've worked with Jenni twice now (she helped me buy my home when I moved to the area, and then helped me sell it when I moved away). Both times, she was the epitome of professionalism, dedication, kindness, enthusiasm and creativity. She knows her stuff, her feathers are not easily ruffled, and she's able to keep even the most challenging deals on-track. I can't recommend her highly enough!
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Franklin County
786 Ann St Columbus
I wasn’t sure what to expect as a first time homebuyer, but Kate’s knowledge and communication made the process easy to navigate. I am so glad we had the opportunity to meet and work with her!
16D/6207 Roxburgh Court Columbus
Working with Kate was genuinely a great experience. She secured a full-asking offer on opening weekend—at the end of October, when the market was clearly cooling off. My condo was in a complex with competing units, so I knew it wouldn’t be an easy sale. From our first meeting, she came prepared with comps and a clear pricing strategy. Her biggest recommendation was to repaint the entire place to help it stand out. I was hesitant, but after talking it through and understanding the return on investment, I went for it and it absolutely paid off. The most impressive part is that I had already moved out of state. I only came back a few times; everything else was handled remotely. Kate coordinated painters, handyman work, and even small things like light bulbs and batteries. She stopped by to check on the unit after showings and made sure nothing slipped through the cracks. She made a stressful situation incredibly easy. When offers came in, the strongest one was FHA. Kate walked me through the extra requirements and helped me weigh my options. She guided me through inspection, handled communication with my HOA and property management, and made sure all repairs were completed quickly. I only ended up giving a small concession, which I was perfectly happy with. The last hurdle was the FHA appraisal requiring a handrail. Kate jumped on it immediately. Timing was tight because it was right before Thanksgiving, so I ordered the handrail myself and drove back to Ohio to install it so we could close on schedule. She was ready to take care of it the following week if needed, but fully supported me wanting to close on time. Overall, I couldn’t be happier with the level of service Kate provided. She went above and beyond every step of the way. Meanwhile, other units in my building are still sitting on the market—honestly, they need to hire Kate to get the deal done. Thanks again, Kate. —Jonathan
From 4 reviews overall
Colleen Kasulis
Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Franklin County
248 Chatham Road Columbus
Colleen helped us to find the home of our dreams! She listened, understood our needs, and offered help in any way she could. When the home we purchased went on the market, she knew that we had found a good option and helped us to quickly see the property and place an appealing offer. She checked in often throughout the process, which kept stress minimal. Colleen is incredibly knowledgeable, helpful, and all around great person.
1465 Montcalm Road Upper Arlington
In every respect our experience with our realtor was 100% what we needed. We haven’t been on the realty market for over three decades and we had a lot of questions and anxieties. At every point our concerns were answered promptly and professionally. It could not have gone more smoothly.
1465 Montcalm Road Upper Arlington
Colleen is an excellent realtor. She is warm, approachable and very knowledgeable. She goes out of her way to work with her clients to sell their home and then find a perfect new home for them. Colleen was always available to answer questions and research whatever info we needed. I Will highly recommend her to any of my friends who need a realtor.
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Franklin County
510 Cline Street Columbus
We bought a home through the community land trust (COCLT) this March. That program requires the buyer to pick an agent of their own, but one of the loan officers we spoke to recommended choosing Janene (who also acts as the seller's agent) because it would make the whole process go more smoothly. At first, I was hesitant because dual agency can be an issue if the agent is not truly representing both parties. But in this case, it's the best thing to do! Janene acted as a great go-between from showing through closing. In this case, having our own agent would have just gotten in the way. If you are looking to buy through COCLT and want to have Janene as both the buyer's and seller's agent, I highly recommend! COCLT staff is also great to work with. They are all the kind of people for whom gratitude spontaneously arises.
547 Berkeley Road Columbus
Janene was incredibly supportive, responsive, professional and experienced. I purchased a home through the COCLT program with Janene as my realtor and the entire process ran smoothly from start to finish due to her expertise. She really cares about the people she works with and she made my dream of homeownership possible. If you are thinking of buying a house in Columbus, especially through the COCLT program, I could not recommend her enough!