From 43 reviews overall

Neil Mathias
Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 43221
3100 Splitrock Rd Columbus
We had a great experience working with Neil! As first-time homeowners, he guided us through every step and made the process feel easy and stress-free. He truly had our best interests in mind and helped us find an amazing first home. We’re so grateful and highly recommend him!
1465 Montcalm Road Upper Arlington
In every respect our experience with our realtor was 100% what we needed. We haven’t been on the realty market for over three decades and we had a lot of questions and anxieties. At every point our concerns were answered promptly and professionally. It could not have gone more smoothly.
2569 Chester Road Upper Arlington
This is the third home Neil has helped us buy/sell. Every time he's exceeded our expectations throughout the entire process. From big picture strategy, timing cadence and daily details, Neil executed with excellence on all items consistently.
From 16 reviews overall
Carie Igel
Cutler Real Estate | Central Ohio Regional

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 43221
3818 Riverwatch Lane Columbus
We had a great experience working with Carie in recent our home search. Starting with the initial meeting, she took the time to understand what we were looking for and helped us find a beautiful home in a wonderful neighborhood close to our daughter and her family. She exceeded our expectations. Carie handled every detail with care and professionalism, making the complicated process of buying a home feel smooth and well-organized. She was consistently responsive. She answered all of our questions quickly and clearly, which made us feel supported at every step. One of the things we appreciated most was her network of trusted service providers. Her recommendations were excellent and helped us transition into our new home without the hassle of finding reliable help on our own. Overall, Carie made the entire experience significantly less stressful and far more enjoyable than we expected. We are truly grateful for her guidance and would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a knowledgeable, attentive, and dependable real estate agent.
3818 Riverwatch Lane Columbus
Carie is an outstanding realtor! She came highly recommended by our daughter and we are so glad we chose her to find our new home. Carie asked many questions to know how to help us and answered all of our many questions. She was patient, kind, knowledgeable and confident. She was helpful in addressing a few issues we encountered during the process of buying our home. We highly recommend Carie and would absolutely use her again!
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 43221
3761 Carnforth Dr Columbus
William Briggs was outstanding to work with on my flip property from start to finish. He found the opportunity, connected me with great resources to help get the rehab done efficiently, and then absolutely delivered on the sale. Even with the listing going live around Thanksgiving—a tougher time of year—we were under contract in 3 days. William truly goes above and beyond, communicates clearly, and stays on top of every detail. I highly recommend him to anyone buying, selling, or investing.
From 4 reviews overall
Colleen Kasulis
Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 43221
1465 Montcalm Road Upper Arlington
In every respect our experience with our realtor was 100% what we needed. We haven’t been on the realty market for over three decades and we had a lot of questions and anxieties. At every point our concerns were answered promptly and professionally. It could not have gone more smoothly.
1465 Montcalm Road Upper Arlington
Colleen is an excellent realtor. She is warm, approachable and very knowledgeable. She goes out of her way to work with her clients to sell their home and then find a perfect new home for them. Colleen was always available to answer questions and research whatever info we needed. I Will highly recommend her to any of my friends who need a realtor.