From 9 reviews overall

Melissa Mertogul
Real Estate eBroker Inc
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 93401
4150 La Posada San Luis Obispo
Melissa was so helpful in selling our home. She explained everything thoroughly, helped us to bring in the right team (photographer, stager) to make the home sparkle, and did an excellent job marketing the home. With her help and persistence, we found a buyer who appreciated the home as much as we did.
From 23 reviews overall

Tina Glenn
Richardson Sotheby's International Realty
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 93401
7070 Tassajara Creek Rd Santa Margarita
Tina was our agent in selling our home in SLO. Main point: highly recommend her, she went above and beyond in selling our home. She was beyond full-service. We were living away from the property and she took care of all responsibilities required for ensuring our home was marketed and sold for the right price to a qualified buyer. We would work with her again with no hesitation. If you would like to sell your home--or buy a home--in San Luis Obispo County, I don't think you could find someone better to protect and promote your interests. Thank you, Tina!
From 59 reviews overall

Jessica Burns
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 93401
157/3960 South Higuera Street San Luis Obispo
I have worked with Jessica in two different transactions, one buying and one selling. She also worked with my son in buying his first home. That is how I found out about her. His comment, “I couldn’t have done it without her”. I now understand why he said that. She is extremely professional. Her knowledge of the contracts and timing of things is vast. She had my back every step of the way. She is extremely patient and explained everything I was signing. She was always there to walk me thru the stressful times. She communicated with me on everything that was happening. I can’t say enough good things about her. She is a very nice person who takes great pride in her work and it shows. I will not hesitate to have her as my agent again in selling my home when the time comes and I am honored to recommend her to others. Thank you Jessica, “I couldn’t have done it without you!”
1472 Ashmore Street San Luis Obispo
We had the pleasure of working with Jess to both buy our new home and sell our previous one, and we truly couldn’t have asked for a better experience. From start to finish, she was incredibly organized, making sure that everyone involved stayed on track with the timeline. We had a lot of questions throughout the process, and she always answered them with patience, clarity, and deep knowledge of the market. When it came time to sell our home, Jess was fully devoted—guiding us through each step, explaining everything in a way that made us feel confident and informed. She’s not only professional and dedicated, but also genuinely kind and easy to work with. Her friendly demeanor, attention to detail, and commitment to her clients really set her apart. We’re so grateful we had her on our side and would recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home!
From 52 reviews overall

Michelle McElrath (Severance)
Keller Williams Realty Central Coast

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 93401
4035 Box Spring Road San Luis Obispo
One of the first things we look for in an agent is responsiveness, and Michelle was outstanding in this regard. We had limited time to review properties given that we lived out of town, and she consistently set up viewings quickly and efficiently. Moreover, when we could not be in town to view a property in person, she went out of her way to give us video tours that were thorough and comprehensive. This gave us confidence that she knew us as clients, and what was important to us in a home. Given the competitiveness of the market, we also wanted an agent who could advocate for us to sellers. Michelle had just the right balance - she presented us as strong buyers without being overly aggressive. Michelle also helped us to think openly about options we had not thought about before, which can really make the difference between consistently losing out on properties and ultimately getting the one you want. We ended up with the perfect home and we thank Michelle for helping make our dream home a reality!
11/2225 Exposition Drive San Luis Obispo
Michelle McElrath is a consummate professional. She is detail oriented, an excellent communicator and a pleasure to work with. Michelle worked with us to prepare for the sale, and was there every step of the way. I highly recommend her services!
County Top 5
ratemyagent award
San Luis Obispo County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Arroyo Grande2026