Michelle McElrath (Severance)

Michelle McElrath (Severance)

CA: 01955049
  •   5   (53 reviews)

Michelle's sales performance at a glance

See how Michelle has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

7
Reviews
2
Properties for sale
9
Sold properties
$865k
Average sale price
$7.8m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

  • top20badge

    Recognized for being in the Top 20% for customer satisfaction.

  • aotybadge

    Recognized for going above & beyond for their clients.

Michelle's customer service awards

See what RateMyAgent awards Michelle has won

  • County Top 5San Luis Obispo County
  • City WinnerArroyo Grande
  • 2x County Top 5San Luis Obispo County - 2026, 2023
  • 2x City WinnerSan Luis Obispo - 2025, 2023

About Michelle

SPECIALTIES- Buyer's agent, Seller's agent, Relocation, Staging Whether you're a first-time home buyer, retiree, investor or someone helping a loved one relocate, I represent the best interests of my clients during their real estate transactions as if they were my own. No detail is too small to handle. My business is to exceed your expectations by maximizing service to minimize your stress. I am passionate about the win-win opportunity that a well-informed Real Estate decision provides to both Buyers and Sellers to buy with confidence and sell with success. Check out my reviews! I work diligently to serve my Central Coast clients and look forward to meeting you!

Social profiles

Facebook logoLinkedIn logo

Michelle's reviews

  5  
Michelle has 53 reviewsacross 9 different locations, showing 6.
Review Michelle
Michelle's qualities as told by our client reviews: strategic, supportive, resourceful, reliable, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
A solid recommendation!!
5 months ago
A solid recommendation!!

We have had Michelle help us on 2 transactions: the purchase of our home 4 years ago, and the sale of it this year. She works tirelessly for her clients to make sure everything goes forward as good as it possibly can. We had some hurdles during the sale, but she calmly led us through them. And to make things more challenging, we live out of state, so there were some issues that we could not attend to personally. She graciously stepped up to the plate and handled things so well. We really appreciate her help. The real question is would we work with her again? A resounding YES!!

Seller review
The consummate professional, again.
6 months ago
The consummate professional, again.

This is our fourth transaction with Michelle, she's always been easy to work with and very thorough. This time, after putting so much effort into updating an inherited rental property to modern standards, Michelle took over at the end and staged the interior with just enough furnishings to make it come alive, bringing in multiple offers.

Buyer review
Above and Beyond Expectations
8 months ago
Above and Beyond Expectations

Michelle guided us through two transactions during a somewhat difficult real estate market. She worked very hard to bring multiple contingent sales/purchases to close. Her knowledge of the local market and what it takes to get a deal done was invaluable. She was awesome!

Seller review
Calm, collected & knowledgeable
9 months ago
Calm, collected & knowledgeable

Michelle was great with us on the rollercoaster ride that it can be in selling property. She’s great about being the intermediary between many involved parties. She knows how to keep everyone calm, collected, and moving things forward.

Buyer review
Recommendation for and appreciation of Michelle McElrath
9 months ago
Recommendation for and appreciation of Michelle McElrath

Our family was relocating to the Central Coast from Northern California and we had only a little knowledge about the area. Michelle was immensely instrumental in finding us a lovely new home in the best area for our family. Her knowledge of the area and determination to find us the right home in the right neighborhood was evident throughout the process. First, by asking relevant questions and listening to the complicated and varying needs of our multi-generational family. In some ways, I think Michelle knew and understood even better than we did what would and wouldn’t work for us. Secondly, with a slim housing market Michelle worked tirelessly, and stayed positive, confident and encouraging that we would find a home in our price range. She sent out mailings in targeted neighborhoods and kept on top of new listings when they became available. She remained steadfast and optimistic throughout the process. Also, it was through a good working relationship with other realtors in the area that lead to her finding us a beautiful new home, in the area we wanted, in our price range, that pretty closely checked all our boxes! Her skills walking us through the purchase and the stress that comes with any real estate transaction were evident by her cool, calm and collected demeanor throughout. Lastly, I believe that it was more than a job for Michelle, she genuinely wanted us to be happy and generously stepped up and stood behind us when there were a few bumps in the road with the previous owners. We appreciate her commitment and professionalism very much and wouldn’t hesitate to recommend her to anyone. Thank you Michelle, we love our new home and it was a pleasure working with you!

Buyer review
Spring Road
9 months ago
Spring Road

One of the first things we look for in an agent is responsiveness, and Michelle was outstanding in this regard. We had limited time to review properties given that we lived out of town, and she consistently set up viewings quickly and efficiently. Moreover, when we could not be in town to view a property in person, she went out of her way to give us video tours that were thorough and comprehensive. This gave us confidence that she knew us as clients, and what was important to us in a home. Given the competitiveness of the market, we also wanted an agent who could advocate for us to sellers. Michelle had just the right balance - she presented us as strong buyers without being overly aggressive. Michelle also helped us to think openly about options we had not thought about before, which can really make the difference between consistently losing out on properties and ultimately getting the one you want. We ended up with the perfect home and we thank Michelle for helping make our dream home a reality!

Show all 53 reviews
map

Michelle's properties

Michelle has 2 properties for sale and sold 9 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldMay 13, 2026
$600,000
1119 James Way
Arroyo Grande CA 93420
2
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of SB Wealth, Inc.
SoldMay 11, 2026
$902,000
1060 Trevor Way
San Luis Obispo CA 93401
3
3
3
Condo
Listing courtesy of SB Wealth, Inc. and The Avenue Central Coast Realty, Inc.
SoldMay 1, 2026
$545,000
4/676 North 12th Street
Grover Beach CA 93433
2
2
2
Condo
Listing courtesy of SB Wealth, Inc. and Compass California Inc.
On Hold
$595,000
857 Mesa Drive
Arroyo Grande CA 93420
2
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of SB Wealth, Inc.
Show all 11 properties

Michelle's sold properties

Michelle has sold 9 properties in the past 12 months, showing 4.

Enter your property details to filter

I'm selling a
bedroom
with
bathrooms in
Property imageAddressBedroomsBathroomsCarparksProperty TypeClosing PriceDate Sold
1119 James Way, Arroyo Grande, CA, 93420
1119 James Way
Arroyo Grande CA 93420
2
2
2
Single-Family$600,000May 13, 2026
1060 Trevor Way, San Luis Obispo, CA, 93401
1060 Trevor Way
San Luis Obispo CA 93401
3
3
3
Condo$902,000May 11, 2026
4/676 North 12th Street, Grover Beach, CA, 93433
4/676 North 12th Street
Grover Beach CA 93433
2
2
2
Condo$545,000May 1, 2026
201 Miguelito Lane, Pismo Beach, CA, 93449
201 Miguelito Lane
Pismo Beach CA 93449
3
3
2
Single-Family$1,779,000Dec 10, 2025
Michelle McElrath (Severance)
Contact Michelle McElrath (Severance)
What information would you like?

Browse nearby locations

SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent